• Member Since 29th Aug, 2019
  • offline last seen April 3rd

BlackShuck


haunted dog haunted dog haunted dog haunted dog haunted dog hau

Comments ( 7 )

Well it could be classified as Canon. That is if you make a sequel that takes place after the reunion birthday party, mainly because her reaction seemed a little over the top for just not showing up to a birthday party before Twilight left for ponyville. That said this is a good story and I would love to see a sequel. :pinkiehappy:

This was a good read.
You get a thumbs up.
Just one thought though.... I mean I'm not a biologist or any thing but shouldn't them pony tiddies be a little further south of the border?

10039028
I play by my own rules, man!!!
...at the same time, I might consider tweaking this more towards anthros in the future hahaha

Felt kinda off to me, honestly. Like the internal dialogue didn't completely feel like Twilight, and their dynamic really didn't feel like what I remember from Amending Fences. Combine that with a lot of little actions and movements that sound really awkward for a quadruped, and I was half expecting to see a comment calling this out as some harry potter smutfic with the names and hands replaced.

Maybe I just set my expectations too high, the premise really hooked me and at a rating of 33:0 I was honestly excited. The "There isn't a colt, is there?" angle is a bit cliche, and kind of a let down when I was expecting something more honest and casual, more exactly like the "science experiment or something" mentioned. I was expecting more awkwardness in the act itself, instead they feel way more experienced than even the most well-read first timer should be... but I digress.

Technically not bad, though a handful of missing/mixed up words, and enjoyable to a degree. I'd say maybe commit to anthro/humanised or pure pony next time

I liked the characterization of Twilight being the one that asks questions, but Moondancer only states statements and Twilight has to often suss out the meaning / questions behind them. They are both socially inept bookhorses, but like recolor ponies identical twins they’ve come up with their own kind of personal language and I like that a lot. Especially the gradual ramp to the spicy smutty bit starts.

Like the other commentator mentioned. I was also very thrown by the mention of tits past the collarbone. I mean not that tits are ‘bad’ thing, but it did make me go “Huh what?” and have to double check the tags again to see if I was reading anthro / humanized. It’s a minor thing, but it did throw me out of the mood. Sorry to say.

Also. I don’t want to be mean, but there were some typos in the text here and there. Enough that I want to suggest you take a closer re-read just to tidy things up. If you want I’ll PM them to you. I see it’s your second story though and it’s a great effort and premise. I hope you keep writing!

This was amazing. Thank you so much for writing & sharing it with us.

Login or register to comment