• Published 23rd Sep 2018
  • 5,996 Views, 1,468 Comments

Playing House - Krickis



When Sunset learns about problems in Fluttershy's home life, she invites her friend to live with her instead. For Fluttershy, it’s a shelter from the storm she lives in fear of. For Sunset, it’s the hope to be part of a family for the first time.

  • ...
33
 1,468
 5,996

PreviousChapters
Epilogue


“Hey, you’ve reached Sunset Shimmer. Sorry I couldn’t get to my phone, but leave me a message and I’ll get back to you.”

“Sunny! Please don’t let this be too late, please call me back… I… I never wanted you out of my life completely, Sunny, please! I can’t do this without you. I know this is all my fault for how I treated you, but I still need you! I don’t know what I’ll do with myself if you’re really gone forever, I just… I just…

“Sunny, please…”

Author's Note:

Who We Become is a story that takes place across two worlds. The human story and the pony story happen concurrently and affect each other, but they can also be read as standalone stories.

Finding Home is the next main entry in the series, taking place in Equestria moments after Sunset steps through the portal. Reading it isn’t necessary if you’re only interested in the human story, but is the next recommended fic if you want the full story or want to see what happens with Sunset.

Thicker Than Water is the next recommended fic if you only want the human story. It follows Fluttershy and Rainbow a few years after the events of Playing House as they go on tour with Bitchette.

PreviousChapters
Comments ( 116 )

Dude... Fuck you, Fluttershy. Seriously, fuck her. I'm glad Sunset missed that message.

Anyway, what a ride it's been. Hard to believe it's over. I said in an earlier comment all I really needed to say about this story, but it really was quite the journey, and it's still quite hard to believe it's finished. You are a brilliant, majestic, and genius motherfucker, and I'm going to jump into Finding Home right away. Can't wait to see your next story!

9958621
I just went with the chapter I left off on okay bun you're just a meanie ;~;

9958623
It’s definitely been a trip and a half over this past year and change. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed it as much as you have, and I hope you enjoy Finding Home just as much if not more (it’s definitely an easier story to digest what with how sad this one was) :ajsmug:

This has been a fantastic slow-knife-twist with occasional bouts of happiness over the last year! I think the message Fluttershy sent at the end really proves that this was for the best. Their relationship didn't start on the best of foundations, and while there were times where things were improving there were always secrets being kept: The extent of Fluttershy's trauma being kept from Sunset for months, Sunset keeping their relationship hidden from Equestrian Twi/Shy, Sunset taking the fall for the thrown glass and losing her friendship with Rainbow in the process, and then Shy lying about having met someone new. There was never a complete sense of trust between them, and towards the end the two were relying on each other more for a sense of security than anything, a way to keep themselves from having to face the realities of their lives. It just wasn't healthy.

I look forward to seeing where Shy's journey leads her, despite knowing that thing's aren't going to be better anytime soon. I'm still wondering when Human Sunset is going to show back up after her cameo in the epilogue of Looking Glass. Her showing up to a Bitchette concert would cause some serious chaos. Regardless, this has been amazing to tune into each week. I think I'll go follow it up with a re-read of Finding Home.

9958680
I was going to try and hype you for Thicker Than Water, my Fluttershy based sequel to Playing House, but I just realized – aren’t you my newest patron? Because Thicker Than Water is on Patreon, homie. You can like, just read it whenever lol (well, as of writing this seventeen chapters of it are).

Anyway, I’ve loved your comments through out this story and I very much appreciate you sticking through it, the good and the bad. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed it as much as you did, and I hope you continue to enjoy my future stories :raritywink:

9958691
I could binge it all now, but I enjoy getting one chapter a week like this. I tend to remember it better this way, and I enjoy reading it then scrolling down to the comments.

9958721
Ah gotcha, that makes sense. It makes me even more grateful that you became a patron, since you didn’t do it for the early chapters incentive at all but just to be helpful. Thank you so much :scootangel:

I fear whats in store for Shy.
She clings to rainbow who in turn wants to protect her but doesn't contribute in any form to help her gain independence.

Sunset self destruction the other hand gets finally stopped by ponyshy and she gains two marefriends, lots of other friends, a big family including Celestia/Luna/Twis parents/Cadance/Shining and even her own parents( which contributed nothing other than making her not an orphan )
Perhaps things get better for her but I don't really believe it :unsuresweetie: (In the short term at least)
And I would like to see Sunset showing Violet that she didn't imagine being a Unicorn :P

9958768
Fluttershy’s story will be coming out in February, and I’ve been very much enjoying it so far myself, so I hope y’all will as well :scootangel: And honestly I don’t have any plans for Violet right now, but there’s plenty of chances to change that now that I’m finally closing up the gaps in this series and can soon focus on its future.

9958800
Die Hard might be up her alley.

AAAAAAAAA I HATE YOU
Gods above that impaled me in so many waaaaayssss
What the fuck! I mean come on!
I'm literally biting my nails here thinking of how Thicker Than Water starts, and how she just forgot this message existed probably and like
damn it all!

I'm not crying over this but I'm very pissed at this
I'm sad sure but
Ughhhh like
There's no defense to either of them and Helheim on earth if Fluttershy didn't see this coming
It's her fucking fault
AAAAAAAAAA I HATE IT ALL



---------^^^----------

This is the sum of the impact this story had on me
It's funny because this is exactly how good it was
This was legit anger that I will forget but I won't forget this story
It's literally impossible to forget something like this
Either way.


Onwards! Towards watching Sunset Finding her Home
Or trying, anyways, I wouldn't know.

Or would I?

9958854
I'm glad the story was good enough to spark a reaction like that. I've been looking forward to you reading Finding Home and the rest of WWB, so I can't wait to read your comments on those stories (when you get to them, of course)

Comment posted by The Scarlett Mare deleted Nov 25th, 2019

9958915
Nice to know I make you happy by sharing my thoughts!
It's nice making someone happy by doing something deliberately

Wow what a ride this was one of the best stories I've read if not the best. Was glad to see her get some advice on what to and was glad it was violet dusk. This story was quite a ride taking us up one point then letting us crash another , I don't know what to think about the epilogue would like to see how that plays out and see if it matches up to finding hoome. I can see how sunset became the way she is in finding home, that bugle has finally played it's last note and as the sound fades I gotta say I looked forward to seeing how this plays out for fluttershy cause I gotta say rainbow isn't the type to after really sound advice sure she may try to help but end up making it worse. But that being said I do have hope for them

9958997
Glad to have you stick with the story, and I'm delighted you enjoyed it as much as you did. I'm really excited to bring y'all Fluttershy and Rainbow's story in Thicker Than Water when that gets here, I think you'll like that one :raritywink:

9959000
Thank you I'm sure I will although I still think sunset leaving like that is just a quick stitch effort

This was, overall, devastating to read.

It's also in my top three fics, and likely the most emotional piece of literature I've read.

Starting with post-looking glass Sunset and ending with pre-equestria Sunset, the whole thing was basically a giant buildup, then a huge drop. I loved the early chapters—they felt like Sunset was building a new future with Fluttershy: Sunny and Shy vs. the world. Then there was the event, and the story became Sunset vs. everything including the person she loves most, and basically turned into a hopeless slow downfall.

I was definitely wrong when earlier I thought the emotions were all over the place—really, they're not. The first section is a steady increase in hope, and the second section is a steady decrease in hope. It's a wonderful plot structure for this story in particular, since it really lends itself to a sequel where Sunset can build her life back up again (which I will be promptly reading).

The epilogue was definitely an oof. It feels extremely desperate and hopeless, especially since Fluttershy still loves Sunset. Unfortunately, Sunset did the same thing Fluttershy had already done, and decided to put her own needs first. It's definitely a fitting epilogue, though. I never expected playing house to end on a positive note.

Thanks, Krickis, for the feels—even if they're not good feels, I still love them.

JMP

...You just had to twist the knife some more, didn't you. Well, you may not see my comments for a while. Gonna go through "Inner Strength", then I'll continue on with "Finding Home" afterwards, and I tend to comment less on older/completed fics than I do ones I'm tracking. Gonna be kinda weird reading that one, though, given that it was written before this story.

So if the next one is Fluttershy’s story... is Rainbow Dash gonna finally find out that Sunset never actually did anything to Fluttershy?

It doesn't hurt, it burns me, it hurts me.

9959147
Yeah but it's Fluttershy's dam dault. She lied, and said it was to help Sunset, she tricked her into thinking she found someone else, replacing her it seems.
So drives Sunset to make some bad choices, and in the end further to drive her away. You read it, when she refuse to admit she still love Sunset it hurt her, and she thought it was a good thing to make her move on.

Well she got her wish, Sunset has moved on. I hope she happy about it, and sure Dash going to love learning the truth.

A phenomenal ending to this all things considered, and followed up well in it's pony-side sequel.

I look forward to seeing Fluttershy's own side to this tale, and hope she somehow finds peace and happiness in time as well.

I'll leave you with this, which I feel fits the end of this tale well;

https://m.

Well, here’s to waiting for another installment of queer horses and skittle people: the soap opera.

On a happier note it's quite amusing to imagine Applejack still with Sunset's phone constantly getting messages from Fluttershy who hasn't realised she has the phone now so is singing love song after love song that she wrote to try to win back Sunset, but Applejack has committed to just listening to them as they come and not replying to clarify the situation out of embarrassment.

Okay actually that's even more depressing

Oh and I kinda take back my previous 'damn it' comment because reading some comments and taking the time to think about it has lead me to believe that this is the perfect ending to this story. It shows the hopeless/ hopefulness of them both as they constantly get put into situations they are not prepared for; both doing just enough of the wrong thing to push each other apart while trying their best to keep themselves together except when they broke up of course but even then they still cared and failed to show it properly. okay i kinda forget what i was trying to say originally, something about themes and its all connected in tragedy and love (that didn't have to be a tragedy i some key timings were different), but just very well done!

Also can't wait for all the the main characters to show up on a hilltop to stop the evil human sunset evil midnight sparkle and evil evil evil stormy skies like they did in the 2 part finale of the show.

9959147
I’m thrilled to be so highly rated, devastating as it was :raritystarry: I admit to liking the early chapters more than the later ones at the moment, but the super heavy mood is just not my jam anymore. I wish I had more to say to such a long and lovely comment, but mostly I’m just delighted you think so highly of my story :scootangel:

9959151
I hope you enjoy the other stories in this series, and I’ll look forward to seeing your comments again when you’re caught up and I’m posting new WWB fics :ajsmug:

9959189
It’ll come up again, although I won’t say with whom or how it all goes down. Can’t go revealing the future of this series like that, but I’ll say that the plot point isn’t getting forgotten about.

9959214
I’m not known for being a kind author :pinkiecrazy:

9959405
That’s a fantastic song for the this story. I hadn’t heard it before but I love it now, so thank you for sharing it! And I look forward to bringing you Fluttershy’s story in due time :scootangel:

9959485
lol skittle people. Hope you enjoyed this particularly drama-filled story :twilightsmile:

9959728
Oof yeah that would be depressing in its own way. Suppose Applejack probably does retrieve Sunset’s phone from her house at some point, but I hadn’t given it that much thought. Anyway, I’m glad you’ve enjoyed this story and know that I’ve always thoroughly enjoyed your comments on it and my other fics. And yeah, I like to think this story ended exactly as it needed to, from the last chapter with Applejack and Sunset’s talk to the desperate voice mail epilogue. Glad to hear you agree :ajsmug:

9960248
As much as one can enjoy the pain Sunny and Flutters have been through. As others have said before, I'm glad Sunny never got the last message. Though, since it's been a while since I've read Finding Home: she does stay in contact with some of the human six, yeah?

9960270
Glad to hear it :twilightsmile: She does indeed. Pinkie and Applejack wind up visiting Equestria with some degree of regularity, and even though they’ve moved away, Twilight and Rarity still make it from time to time for special occasions.

I’m working on a Previously on Who We Become document for future stories so that there’s a nice summary by the time I start posting fics that take place in the future of this series. It’s been years that I’ve been writing Looking Glass and Playing House, I don’t expect people to remember the other stories as well :twilightsheepish:

9960274
I think "Looking Glass" is still the one I remember best. How's the progress for print versions of this and "Inner Strength" btw? (I presume that FH is possibly getting printed too?)

9960281
The progress is essentially nonexistent because I’ve been writing instead of working on that lol. So my current plan of attack is to finish Thicker Than Water, which is almost done, then work on the print version of Inner Strength as my primary focus. I still hope to have IS in print sometime in the winter, but it’ll for sure be January/February at the earliest. A PH print edition will absolutely follow IS, although I’m unsure of when that’ll happen. Finding Home will be after that, although that story needs editing, so it’ll take some time. I hope to get my entire bibliography in print someday, even if I’m the only person likely to collect the whole set.

9960321

even if I’m the only person likely to collect the whole set.

Last time I checked, I wasn't a rabbit. :trixieshiftright:

9960326
Hehe I’m extremely flattered that you’d go out and buy my books :scootangel: Makes me feel a little more motivated to get them underway since someone other than me is going to actually get them.

9960338
i like big books and i cannot lie

9960248
Hey, just as long as Rainbow Dash understands how much of a jackass she's being, I'll be pleased :P

I don't need anyone else to be happy. Just more schadenfreude.

9960321
I would totally buy them as well if I wasn't a poor college student and the shipping wasn't as expensive.

9960969
Yeah I feel that, totally fair. Hell, I can barely afford them and they’re my books :derpytongue2:

This is the first story of yours that I read and I loved it. Thanks for sharing it

Also discovered that you have many other stories related. Is there a chronology order to read them? Where should I start/continue?

9971198
Thank you very much, I’m glad you enjoyed it :twilightsmile:

Here’s the full chronological order of the series, and I generally recommend people read it in that order. That starts with Looking Glass, which is before this story (mentioned here was Sunset’s childhood growing up in New Horizons. Looking Glass is the story of that). That would be what I’d do if I were in your position, but if you’d rather move forward with the series instead of reading the older stories since you know how those worked out to an extent, Finding Home picks up right after where Playing House leaves off. Whatever you decide to read, I hope you continue to enjoy it!

I'm glad that you yoinked Everton as the name of the city.
Also, "Epilogue" but listed incomplete?

10066035
I love the name Everton, I'm so glad you thought of it. And whoops lol I guess I forgot to switch this story to be listed as complete :twilightblush:

10066379
Gonna have to start over but at least now I can read it through. Maybe it'll push on Pursuing Happiness a little.

10152969
having finished the story Playing house, i'm definately on Sunsets side

10153097
Interesting. Since you asked Sunset not to screw things up earlier, I thought you sounded like you were more on Fluttershy’s side in this one. In any event, wow, you really tore through this story! I’m surprised at how fast you read it, it’s not exactly a short fic :pinkiegasp:

10153113
on holidays this week from work, had alot of time to myself. LOL several chapters near the end i was expecting Sunset and Dash to literally throw down and have at one another while Fluttershy yelled at them to stop fighting lol

10153135
lmao and me being me, I could’ve totally had them do that because that idea is extremely appealing to me :rainbowlaugh:

10174062
Oh yeah adding a person doesn’t fix things but it does make for more drama. Maybe I shouldn’t wish for pinkie to get on a train that’s destined to wreck

10208310
Characters actually do eventually learn to communicate in this series, it just takes them a couple books lmao

Wow, lots of comments here! I would honestly love to go through them all and reply to each of them (it at least to a good amount of them) but I don't have a lot of energy these days... So let me just say how much I appreciate the play by play on reading this story :yay: It really helps with the funk I've been in these past few days to have something nice like this to wake up to.

Login or register to comment