Secret Evils

by Feather Guide

The Downfall

"Is Surprise your other mom?" Mia asked for making Surprise and Pupa blush.

"Yes." Watermelon said.

"How powerful are you Watermelon?" Fluttershy asked.

"I've been told I'm pretty powerful." Watermelon said.

"Do you have any siblings?" Surprise asked.

"No." Watermelon said.

"Lights, cast the spell now!" Dawn Pie said.

"I'm still nervous." Party Lights said.

"There's no reason to." Dawn Pie said.

"We never knew cared about your family." two unmistakable female voices said. The Golden duo walked up to Dawn Pie.

"What are you two doing here?" Dawn Pie asked.

"We just came to see how you freaks were doing." Gloden Delicious said.

"We aren't freaks." Dawn Pie said.

"What are you going to do to us?" Golden Bow asked.

"We don't have time for your bullying." Dawn Pie said.

Roselily appeared with a wilted rose in her mane.

"How are you?" Posey asked.

"A little better," Roselily said.

"I'm glad," Posey said.

"We need to go to Canterlot," Cloudy said.

"Why?" Posey asked.

"Princesses Celestia and Luna are very ill," Cloudy said.

"I'll come," Roselily said.

"Rose, you shouldn't be out here right now," Cloudy said.

"I want to help," Roselily said.

"We don't want you to get hurt more than you already are," Cloudy said.

"Lilith, go home and Cloudy fly to Canterlot with Galaxy." Sweetie Belle said.

"Ok," Cloudy said flying off with Galaxy.

Roselily teleported away. Fire Streaks walked up to Robert.

"There is something I need to tell you." Fire Streaks said.

"What?" Robert asked.

"I have a crush on you." Fire Streaks said blushing.

Robert rubbed one of his front hooves with the other.

"Just kiss already!" Cadence said.

Robert started to blush then Fire Streaks kissed his cheek. Robert stood frozen for a couple of seconds.

"Lala, come here," Fluttershy said.

"No, I'm stronger than you know. I won't turn evil" Larva said.

"You need to send yourself free from your cage," Fluttershy said.

"Lights, cast the spell." Dawn Pie said.

"I will try." Party Lights said.

Party Lights lit her horn then looked at Fluttershy, Shuddercord, Deedee, and Red Velvet before closing her eyes and blasting them all at once when she opened them there was a book where the four ponies had been.

"You did it." Dawn Pie said.

"Now what?" Pupa asked.

"Larva still might turn evil." Sweetie Belle said.

"Does she become evil?" Pupa asked Watermelon.

"We don't want to risk creating an alternative timeline." Sweetie Belle said.

"What happened?" Golden Delicious asked.

"Battle between good and evil," Mia said.

A portal appeared behind the book.

"Bye." Watermelon said sadly hugging Pupa and Surprise.

"Take care." Pupa and Surprise said in unison.

Watermelon went through the portal before it disappeared.

"What do we do now?" Surprise asked.

"You could all confess your feelings and/ or kiss the one you love," Cadence said.

"I love you," Petula said to Posey.

"I love you too," Posey said.

Rainy kissed Mia. Flint was running before he stopped in the middle.

"Princesses Celestia and Luna are dying," Flint said.

"Why today?" Cadence asked.

"What's wrong?" Flurry asked flying to her mom.

"I just need to see love. There is barely any in the Crystal Empire." Cadence said.

"How's a dad?" Flurry asked.

"He died a couple of weeks after the gala," Cadence said.

"Why am I just now hearing about this?" Flurry asked slightly angrily.

"I couldn't send the letter," Cadence said.

"We should probably go to Canterlot now," Posey said.

"We shouldn't all go today," Cadence said.

"I will go today." Cosmic Stars said.

"We will too." Posey and Petula said in unison.

"I will come with," Tina said.

The book started to glow and float in front of them.

"What's happening?" Cosmic Stars asked.

"I don't know," Derpy said.

"Where's the sun?" Pupa asked.

"It must be gone because of Celestia's dying." Derpy and Rainbow said in unison.

"Who's going to raise the sun now?" Party Lights asked.

"I don't know," Rainbow said.

The book continued to glow then the four ponies that were trapped inside escaped.

"No! This can't be happening! They can't be back!" Derp said.

Larvas body started to twitch. Her mind felt like there was a swarm of bees in it.

"What's wrong?" Pupa asked concerned running towards her twin.

"Lala, don't fight it and join us," Fluttershy said.

"Never!" Larva said.

"Never say never," Fluttershy said.

"Larva, keep on fighting." Sweetie Belle said.

"Why can't they see that you're the true villain here, not me?" Fluttershy asked.

"I'm not a villain." Sweetie Belle angrily.

"Yes you are," Fluttershy said angrily.

In Larvas's mind...

"No." Larva cried.

"Give in." a familiar voice said.

"Never." Larva said.

"Yes you will!" the familiar voice said.

"I will never be evil." Larva said.

"You can't fight destiny." the familiar voice said.

"Are you my conscience?" Larva asked.

"Yes." Larvas conscience said.

"Why do you want me to be evil?" Larva asked.

"Evil is power, good is weak." Larvas conscience said.

"I'd rather be weak then be powerful then." Larva said.

"Think about it you could learn the truth about who you are." Larvas conscience said.

"I don't care about that." Larva said.

"You should." Larvas conscience said

"Why?" Larva asked.

"It's whats best for Equestria." Larvas conscience said.

"What do you mean?" Larva asked.

"In this world, you are all alone. We have no choice but to stand on our own." Larvas conscience sang,

"I won't have you seal my fate. I will stand with everything in this debate." Larva sang.

"There's one thing you must know in the end. You will ultimately be betrayed by your so-called friends." Larvas conscience sang.

"What would something ghastly as you know?" Larva sang.

"More than you that the world is cold." Larvas conscience sang.

"I've had enough of your stupid evil plans." Larva sang.

"Yet, you're here with all your tightening demand." Larvas conscience sang.

"I'm sick of all the lies you try to show!!!!" Larva sang.

"Why be chained down with all of society's rules? Why not be evil, and free?" Larvas conscience sang

"Evil may be free but they are all alone." Larva sang.

"I don't understand the need to blend in with those fools." Larvas conscience sang.

"You may stand at the top yet I'll never stop." Larva sang.

"They call it twisted, vile, and plain right means... I've heard those all and more. Those idiots are just a bore." Larvas conscience sang.

"I'm just considering the possible aftermath." Larva sang.

"Why live with such worthless subjects when you can be a queen?!" Larvas conscience sang.

"What do you mean?" Larva asked.

"If you accept, you could be the ruler you were destined to be." Larvas conscience said.

"Never." Larva said.

"I know you want it." Larvas conscience said.

Larva heard a faint voice that snapped her back to the battle.

"Larva, are you alright?" Pupa asked her sister.

"I feel torn." Larva said.

"Lala, join me," Fluttershy said.

"You could be the queen." Larva heard her conscience say.

Larvas reached put her hoof to shake with Fluttershy's.

"Larva don't." Sweetie Belle said.

"This is my destiny." Larva said.

"No, it's not," Cozy said.

"This what is best for Equestria. You have to trust me!" Larva said.

"This isn't what's best for Equestria," Derpy said.

"Yes, it is." Larva said.

"I know it seems like it but it's not," Cozy said.

"Larva, please don't do this," Chrysalis said.

Cadence looked up at Fluttershy and met her eyes.

"Are you ever going to tell them?" Fluttershy asked.

"I don't know what you're talking about," Cadence said no longer looking Fluttershy in the eyes.

"Yes, you do," Fluttershy said.

"Did you truly love me or was it just an act?" Cadence asked angrily.

"Of course I loved you, my little candy heart," Fluttershy said.

Cadence tried not to blush at that nickname.

"Then why did you do what you did?" Cadence asked.

"I was still learning what love was," Fluttershy said.

"That is a unique reason," Cadence said.

"I know and I'm sorry. I couldn't help myself." Fluttershy said.

"You should've tried harder," Cadence said.

Chrysalis walked over to Cadence and looked up at Fluttershy.

"Fermata and Skyla should know the truth," Fluttershy said.

"I can't believe how foolish I was," Cadence said.

"I know how you feel," Chrysalis said.

"You two were both broken until I came. I never got to express my feelings in the past so I didn't know how to show my feelings." Fluttershy said flying closer to Cadence and Chrysalis.

"You will always be evil." Sweetie Belle said.

"You're the evil one!" Fluttershy cried.

"Lights, raise the sun." Dawn Pie said.

"My magic isn't strong enough." Party Lights said.

"Yes it is, I believe in you. Please believe in yourself." Dawn Pie said.

Party Lights lit her horn and floated for a couple of seconds before hitting the ground.

"Did I do it?" Party Lights asked weakly.

"Yep." Dawn Pie said.

Party Lights got up and looked at her flank seeing that she got her cutie mark. Her cutie mark was a book with the sun and four streamers on it.

"Why didn't you tell me that I got my cutie mark?" Party Lights asked.

"I didn't think you cared." Dawn Pie said.

Deedee shot Party Lights with a powerful blast causing Party Lights to fall back down.

Derpy rushed over to check if Party Lights was still breathing.

"She's barely breathing," Derpy said.

"No one hurts my sister." Dawn Pie said angrily.

"I think we should run," Mia said.

Larva, Shuddercord, and Deedee looked at each other and combined their powers.

"No one hurts my sister!" Dawn Pie repeated angrily before jumping up and punching all of them.

It started to rain hard and Mia turned into her merman form.

"Why can't they see that this is all your fault?" Fluttershy asked angrily.

"None of this is my fault." Sweetie Belle said.

"Yes, it is," Fluttershy said.

"A villain like you can never change." Sweetie Belle said.

"Maybe I could've if you had forgiven me all those years ago," Fluttershy said.

"Why would I ever forgive you?" Sweetie Belle asked.

"The same reason you secretly don't forgive anyone," Fluttershy said.

"Is that true?" Tirek asked.

"Of course not dearie." Sweetie Belle said.

"Aren't you going to go to Canterlot Derpy?" Fluttershy asked.

"Why would I go there?" Derpy asked.

"Because of a secret of yours that you've been hiding for over a thousand years," Fluttershy said.

"What is it?" Derp and Tina asked in unison.

Derpy didn't answer she just looked up at the rainy sky. Rainbow and Cozy looked at each other and nodded.

"Derpy is Luna and Celestia's mom," Cozy said.

"Wait, Luna and Celestia are my sisters?" Derp asked.

"Yep," Rainbow said.

Derpy started to cry well still looking up at the rainy sky.

"I miss them," Derpy said sadly.

"Then go," Fluttershy said.

"Belle, what do you think?" Derpy asked.

"You're not going." Sweetie Belle said.

"You are a monster who only cares about herself," Fluttershy said.

Stormy flew towards Fluttershy and flapped down.

"If you all stop this you could be forgiven," Stormy said.

"It's too late. They had their chance of forgiving me and never did." Fluttershy said.

"You don't deserve to be forgiven." Sweetie Belle said.

"Everyone deserves to be forgiven," Stormy said.

"You need to learn that the world isn't all sunshine and rainbows." Sweetie Belle said bluntly.

Stormy started to cry a little. Her tears were gray. Everything started to get gray.

"Come here sunshine," Rainbow said.

Stormy ran up to her mom and continued crying and turning everything gray.

"Belle, why did you say that?" Derpy asked.

"She needed to know the truth." Sweetie Belle said.

"No, she didn't. She's very sensitive." Rainbow said.

"Yes, she did." Sweetie Belle said.

"We should probably calm Stormy done before all of Equestria and possibly the whole world turns gray," Derpy said.

"Go to Canterlot and be there for Celestia and Luna," Rainbow said.

"I can't," Derpy said.

"Follow your heart," Rainbow said.

After a couple of seconds of thinking, Derpy flew towards Canterlot castle as fast as she could.

In Canterlot castle...

"I'm so sorry Lullaby, and Sunny," Derpy said with warms tears running down her face.

Luna and Celestia's ears perked up when they heard those nicknames.

"Mommy?" Luna asked weakly opening her eyes.

"I'm here," Derpy said.

"Your back," Luna said with a weak smile.

"I'm sorry for leaving you when you two were young," Derpy said.

"We forgive you." Celestia and Luna said in unison.

"How can I forgive myself for leaving you two as I did? Derpy asked starting to cry more.

Author's Note:

Thanks for all that helped with the lyrics.

Derpy being Celestia and Lunas mom is kind of based on a dream from a couple of weeks ago but instead of Derpy it was Sweetie Belle.