• Member Since 10th Mar, 2012
  • offline last seen Aug 1st, 2023

CGPH


Bohemian. Bard. Bastard. + Dr. HADLEY on Youtube.

E

Every time Sunset was waiting for the bus she'd go into the coffee shop and order her usual. Little did she know that this time, that simple act was about to result in her discovering a shocking truth about herself.

Chapters (6)
Comments ( 35 )

That was her dad. Unmistakably her dad. But… Sunny Flare’s dad?

You have me completely intrigued now.

Is Principal Cinch Sunny's mother in this story?

Oh my god.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT!?

omg, does she have AIDS???

8125114 dude... spoilers :fluttershysad:

*STARTS TRACKING IMMEDIATELY*

“You look like you’ve seen a ghost.”

Oh, I'm sure someone will be "seeing ghosts," but I have a feeling it won't be Sunset...

I'm sure Twilight isn't very suspicious about Sunset's sudden interest in the Shadowbolts...

Not at all.

So, did Sunset not think to ask Twilight if she knew the name of Sunny's brother? That seems like it would be important.

This should be interesting. Looking foward to next chapter.

So we can probably take this to mean that human!Sunburst is Sunny's sibling, but not human!Sunset.

The mystery deepens...

Okay, consider me intrigued. This is such a cool story and I can't wait to read more! Do they share mothers? Did Sunny dye her hair (and skin)? Can't wait to read!

One of the first things she did was try and seek out her human self so she could enlist her help with her revenge plot, but the search had come up short.

That would be so fun to read about. Although, I guess Sunset gave up easily. If she had been serious about finding her counterpart, she probably would've googled her brother and parents' names to find herself indirectly.

Last thing, I swear: If Sunset and Sunburst are siblings, did Sunset know of Starlight's existence before Twilight did?

Is Sunny Flare a nickname for Sunset Shimmer?

I'm so intrigued!!!!!! I can't wait for the next chapter!!!!!!

Was not expecting this update. YAY!

Ooh a late Christmas present! Yay!

Sunset be careful, you really don't want to hook up with your alternate universe self. Pretty sure that was what Celestia was really worried about when she only let Twilight through the portal the first time.

Yay! I'm so excited to see how this turns out!

Ruh roh. Something tells me Sunny Flare has different motives in mind than friendship.

Ha, Sunset is totally falling for Sunny.

And my bet is that In this world, Sunset's dad ended up with a different woman, not Sunset's mom.

Ahh the protectiveness begins to show its stubborn head. Me thinks Sunset doesnt know her own feelings as well as she thinks she does.

Not seeing a romance tag so hopefully this doesn't turn into an incest ship. I really liked seeing Sunset confront her friends on befriending the Shadowbolts. I think it gets to a difference between human and pony values. Ponies would only not befriend someone if there was a good reason to.

I hope Sunset gets Princess Twilight's opinion on this.

great chapter! Also this explains the differences so well. I'm amazed Sunny Flare is still so similar to Sunset however... Maybe some of it is from Sunset's biases? Like she is actively looking for commonalities?

Poor Sunny Flare though... Something like this can emotionally scar you so bad...

I kinda like this pairing, I hope to see them actually get together, and have a hot makeout session too

So focused on her quest for the truth Sunset forgot to realize she somehow started dating the subject of her inquiry.
Another good chapter. Now we are really getting to the meat of this story!

“Sunset,” she shook her head, smiling. “I think I know where you’re going with this and… it’s okay. I’ve noticed it too.”

It was at this moment I knew for sure where this was actually going. This is gonna be one hell of a mess to untangle.

Also, Sunny Flare having the same father but with a different mother makes a lot of sense considering the hints given so far.

Poor Sunset, getting kissed by your half-sister is definitely weird.

8887557 That 's a good point. Will Sunset get a chance to ask her dad about that girl that got away, *Name of Sunset's Mom* ?

Ouch. I feel very bad for Sunny Flare. She must be absolutely devastated. What’s going to happen next I wonder?

Awesome story the drama and the story are interesting.
I need more of this.

Fascinating. So I suppose that we can either infer that Sundance married a different Mare on the other side, or since Sunset hasn’t mentioned her mother at all it was the pony version of Abacus but she either left him or died before Sunset’s memories began to develop. That last one assumes that Sunset and Sunburst were born within short order of each other and is more unlikely given that Sunset would likely wonder who her mother was before this point. Either way the train wreck has started, let’s see what kind of damage it does.

“You guys are meant to be the Elements of Harmony.”

“Our ponyselves were the Elements,” Rainbow stated.

Thank you!

I've been waiting so long for someone else to point this out!

As this seems to be on permanent hiatus I'm not even going to bother finishing the chapter.

Cinch? Cinch has canonically always been portrayed as someone old enough to be a grandmother, great-grandmother even. Having her be the mother of a high school student is kind of a stretch for me.

I've liked the story up to this point so I'm going to watch for updates.

Man, her friends ain't gonna be happy when sunset and sunny hook up.

Login or register to comment