"Applebloom, Ah don't even know what to say to ya about this." Applejack paced back and forth in front of her sister. The muscles in her forehead twitched as she crossed her arms and glared at her sister. "Why in the world would ya'll want to cosplay as our worst enemies?!"
"I, uh..." Applebloom was unable to make up an excuse as her sister's gaze pierced her soul. Ever since she had been a little girl, she had always been scared of that visage.
"Applebloom, if you just cough up the truth now, maybe I'll be a little more easy on you." Applejack took a step forward and stomped her foot down on the wooden floors. "You of all of the Apples should know just how I can get when people lie..."
"Why in the world should I tell you the truth?" Applebloom almost regretted saying that as she too walked up to Applejack. "Why do you girls always have to hate on the Dazzlings? What is your problem, exactly?"
"What's mah—" Applejack stuttered as she watched her sister stand up against her "—I'll tell ya what my problem is! The Dazzlings tore our friendships apart and used OUR magic AGAINST us! And now you and your friends want to dress up and act like them?!"
"It's cosplay, Applejack! You wouldn't be able to appreciate it, seeing as how you've outlawed anime in this house!" Applebloom shook her head and pushed up to Applejack's face. "You know, ever since I was born, you've been pushing me around like I'm supposed to be some kind of second pet! I'm a teenage girl! You're a teenage girl! Why do you always want to take control of me like this?!"
"Applebloom! Ah won't hear another word!" Applejack threw Applebloom against the sofa and pinned her to it. "You're not going to the Fall Formal this year. I'm gonna make su—"
"Applejack? What in tarnation's going on here?"
Both of the Apple sisters looked to the side to see Granny Smith standing by the door. She walked up to the two of them and pulled Applejack away from Applebloom, keeping some distance between the two of them. She then stood in between the teens, looking down on both of them.
"Granny Smith! Thank my stars you're here..." Applebloom wiped her forehead and pointed over to Applejack. "Mah big sister was trying to keep me from going to the Fall Formal just because of my outfit."
"Don't you listen to these lies, Granny! Applebloom was trying to dress up as one of the Dazzlings from the Battle of the Bands!" Applejack spoke up, brushing past Granny to lock her eyes with Applebloom's again. "Ah ain't gonna let mah little sister act like someone evil just so she can try and win some goofy crown!"
"So? What's so bad about Applebloom playing dress-up for the formal?" Granny Smith turned towards Applejack. "Looks to me like she was gonna go out as the belle of the ball too."
"Granny, I suppose I should try and start from the beginning." Applejack took a deep sigh, knowing that she wouldn't be able to convince Granny Smith without letting her know the whole story. "Back at CHS's Battle of the Bands, there were three girls called the Dazzlings who entered the contest, right?"
"Yes. I remember them. Rather sweet girls, really." Granny nodded and dropped her arms down by her sides. "That blue one sure had a hankerin' for tacos. She almost cleaned me out with how many she picked up."
"Let's just stay on topic here. It'll make the situation much quicker." Applejack groaned and shook her head, pushing her fingers against her head. "Anyway, the Dazzlings made everyone else fight and hate each other, all so that they could feast on their negativity and bad vibes—including me and my friends!"
"Really?" Granny Smith raised her brow at Applejack. "Ah remember there was some hooting and hollering at lunch, but ah didn't really notice anything out of the ordinary. They still seemed like regular girls to me."
"Granny! What's that supposed to mean?!" Applejack threw her arms down in front of her chest and stared bug-eyed at her. "We SAW the magic fly into their gems! Don't you remember?"
"Hmm..." Granny Smith tried to recall the events of the Battle of the Bands, but the more she tried to remember, the less clear it became to her. "Nope. Sorry, Applejack. Yer not convincing me in the slightest."
"But then..." Applejack had to pause briefly to take in what Granny Smith had just said, "you wouldn't say that unless you were still brainwashed by them!"
"Brainwashed? Me? What do you think this is? The time of communism?!" Granny grit her teeth together and stared down Applejack. "Ah might be old, but I certainly ain't mind-controlled by some evil voodoo person to do their bidding! You must have rats in yer brain if you're thinking about that!"
"Granny!" Applejack whined loudly.
"Please, Granny Smith. Can I just butt in for a second?" Applebloom gently got up from the couch and tapped on Granny's shoulders.
"Not now, Applebloom. I'm busy lecturing yer mean big sister." Granny idly waved a hand behind herself as she walked up to Applejack, making her step back towards the wall. "I knew you were a huge liar back when you were in elementary school, Applejack. Don't try to pull that whole thing back in yer teens, ya hear me?!"
"Granny! Please! I'm trying to—"
"Applejack! Be quiet!" Granny smashed her foot against the floor, causing the entire room to fall silent. Both of the girls jumped at the sight of their grandmother losing her temper and had lost any and all will to speak. She took deep breaths and turned back to Applebloom, sitting down beside her on the couch. "Now, go on, Applebloom. What did ya want to say?"
"Well, basically, Granny," Applebloom started, "me and my friends at Canterlot High were going to dress up and go to the Fall Formal to take part in the contest to win the crown this year. We were all worried that our sisters would freak out at the sight of us, so we wanted to keep it a surprise."
"I can see that." Granny Smith gently brushed the back of Applebloom's clothes. "So, why in the heck would yer big sister want to have a go at you for doing it?"
"Well, the thing is, Granny, we were dressing up as some girls who Applejack hated at the Battle of the Bands." Applebloom gulped, feeling unsure about whether or not she would be able to prove her innocence. "They're gone now, though, and we didn't really have any other ideas for costumes on such short notice."
"The Dazzlings weren't mean, Applebloom." Granny Smith patted Applebloom's shoulders and gave her a warm smile. "They were the sweetest, most kind, and clever girls ah ever did see. If they did something bad behind the scenes, then how were we supposed to know about it? Outta sight outta mind, as they say."
"I... guess?" Applebloom tilted her head at Granny.
"Now, you listen here, Applebloom. There ain't no shame in dressing up like that if'n ya wanna impress the crowd at the Fall Formal." Granny Smith tenderly held Applebloom's hands and patted her head. "But there is something called imitation. Copying someone else'll just make you seem like a buffoon. Same goes for the rest of your friends."
"Granny. Why are you being mer—"
"Ah'm not finished, Applejack." Granny Smith glared daggers at Applejack, forcing her eyes to dilute as she lurched backwards. She turned back to face Applebloom again and cleared her throat. "Like I said, imitation'll only get ya nowhere in life. It'll only make you and the girls the laughing stock of the entire school. Don't you remember when you tried to act like that girl Diamond Tiara back at the Spring Fling?"
"What was I supposed to do? She practically had all of the makings of the prettiest girl there." Applebloom tipped her hand.
"Now, Applebloom. I'm gonna let you off this once because Applejack looked like she was being unreasonable, but I don't want you dressing up like anyone else from now on." Granny Smith stood up and helped Applebloom onto her feet. "No matter what you are, you're you, no-one else. Yer a special one-of-a-kind girl, as are your friends. You look perfect just the way ya'll are and as long as you remember that, you'll be perfectly fine, alright?"
"Y-yeah." Applebloom gulped and nodded as she shakily got back onto her feet. "Thanks, Granny."
"And as for you, Applejack," Granny's voice turned bitter in seconds as she let Applebloom go off and prepare for the evening. "How dare you pick on Applebloom like that. She's just as much of a sister as you, heck maybe even more!"
"She was going to make herself hateable at the Fall Formal, Granny!" Applejack tried a last-ditch attempt to win her back. "Ah'm not gonna let mah little sister be the target of bullying and ridicule!"
"Applejack, I believe we've already been over this. You're not gonna win me back with that attitude of yer's." Granny took Applejack by the wrist. "I've been raising you and yer parents for as long as you can remember, so going against me is a fight you're never gonna be able to win, ya got me?"
"I'm still older than Applebloom! In this family, the kids have to be protected at all times by their big sisters and elders!" Applejack tried to pull her arm out of Granny's hold. It was a futile effort, though, as Granny's grip simply tightened with each flail and shake. "Applebloom's gonna be in a whole world of trouble at that Fall Formal!"
"Ah don't want to hear another word of it, Applejack." Granny shook her head vigorously and hauled Applejack up the stairs. "You were going to try and ground her just because of what she was wearing who she was trying to be! You might be older than her, but I'm still this family's legal guardian. And gall'darn it, I can do what I want with you, Applebloom, and Big Mac!" She arrived at a door and walked into a bedroom, sitting Applejack down on the bed as if she was carrying a slab of metal. "So I say, you're grounded for the rest of the week. Ya'll aren't gonna see those friends of yours outside of school hours, and you're not going to the Fall Formal either."
"Granny! This is ridiculous!" Applejack could only throw words around as she watched Granny Smith walk over to the window and lock the key, putting the key in her pocket afterwards. "I'm the big sister! I'm meant to be responsible for Applebloom!"
"And I'm supposed to be responsible for you!" Granny Smith picked up Applejack's laptop and phone and closed them up, taking them out of the room. "And if you're not gonna be nice to Applebloom, there will be punishments. These are staying in my room so that you can't tell your friends about any of this. You won't be getting them back until the end of the week."
Applejack could only watch as Granny Smith took the items out of Applejack's room and close the door. She heard the sound of a lock being locked shortly after the door closed. She hung her head and dropped her hat down by the side of the bed, flopping her face down onto it as well. She balled her hands into fists and began to punch into a pillow, grunting and screaming with each attack.
"Why?" Applejack began to shed a tear as she finally stopped hitting her pillow. "I only wanted to keep Applebloom safe... What's she gonna do without me to protect her?" She turned towards the window, looking out as the first stars began to appear in the night sky. "Now that I'm trapped in here, mah sister's gonna be teased, tormented, and laughed at by everyone at CHS and there isn't anything I can do to stop it!"
You're right, that was very mean to Applejack. Granny doesn't know exactly what happened between them and it kinda sounds like she doesn't understand the situation all that well. Also, Applejack had good reasons to be mad given what the Dazzlings did, especially if she's trying to protect her sister. Overall, it's not fair to her. I know you say you hate Applejack, but I still hope you consider a happy ending for her, and perhaps still let her go to the formal.
7912125 Mayhaps. I mean, she is the worst girl out of the group, but it wouldn't be the Rainbooms without her. I mean, what's she going to do if another magical entity worms its' way out of the crack in the school's statue?
Yeah, uh, show of thumbs up if you didn't expect THIS outcome for Apple Bloom and Applejack before you clicked the chapter link. 'Cause I sure didn't.
I just finished reading this while listening to Rap God. Now, all I can picture is them singing that song.
I like what I've read so far and I'm looking to reading more.
7912174 *thumbs up* i thought applebloom would be grounded, to be honest.
Though I think you're a bit mean to AJ here, she is trying a bit too hard to be a sister. She's still my favorite. Personally, Rainbow is the one with problems.
7912136 Well like I said, Granny doesn't completely understand why Applejack is acting like she is, and while Applejack might have been a bit out of line she had good reasons for it. Applejack not being able to go to the fall formal just isn't fair, and I don't think the other Rainbooms, and perhaps not even Applebloom, would think it was fair either. Personally, I'd think that having her friends stand up for her would be the in-character thing to do.
I liked the chapter.
I would say that you should not preface a chapter with how much you hate the main character in said chapter.
You end up putting the audience on edge because now they are wondering how much of this is going to be part of the story and how much is going to be character bashing.
Instead we were pleasantly surprised with a well thought out chapter that made sense in the context of the story.
Honestly if you had not pointed it out I would have never known that you hated AppleJack.
Wow..., you hate Applejack that much huh? Am I the only one in the fandom who thinks that Applejack is underrated? She's not my favorite, but she is my 9th favorite of the show and my 4th favorite of the Mane 6. Also, I know you're trying to show that Applejack just wants to protect Apple Bloom, but she felt so OoC in this chapter. It's okay if you don't like her, I just think she gets a little too much hate. Also, I've decided to give this story a favorite now.
7912703 You're not alone, I like Applejack too.
I get why people don't like Applejack, but to be just, all the mane 6 have betraie their elements. Fluttershy almost destrioed her friendship with Rarity amd Pinkie on a power high, Pinkie has gotten so wrapped in her identity as a party planner she almost killed Rainbow Dash in a competion with Cheesesandwich, Twilight had undermined and attempt to prevent Starlight from making friends with Trixie, Rainbow Dash was willing to switch teams, plank a easily startled Fluttershy, etc, and don't even get me started on Rarity. And there are many episodes in that other characters were needlessly shoehorned in, look at Twilight fir a good part of season 1. Myself I love AJ, to me she's the best of the mane6, second best pony (Big Mac is best pony) and third best character (Spike, especially season 6, is best character). And while Fluttershy is my least favorite of the mane6, I don't hate her, especially after Flutter Brutter when she gave Zephyr the boot. I will grant the show doesn't do the best job with Applejack and really needs to step up its game with her, but I don't believe she deserves to be hated, disliked in some areas like any other character, but not hated.
A part of me expects to see In an up coming chapter Applejack holding a picture of there parents and crying saying 'Ahm sorry, Pa, Ma, Ah failed ya both.'
Maybe a moment with Big Mac might give Apple Bloom some prespective...
Something tells me Rainbow Dash and Rarity are suffering the same consequences as Applejack.
I think there are worse characters than AJ in the show. But aside the episode in which those two crooks Flim and Flam try to take over Sweet Apple Acres, I can't remember any good AJ episode.
So yeah. Don't worry if you hate a character. At least from me you won't hear any rant or angry/rage comment about it.
7913652 Well there is The Last Roundup, but yeah Applejack is a great support character, unless she is outside of her base or has something she holds dear (Family, Friends and Farm) threaten.
7914402 I forgot about that one and I guess it was because in The Last Round Up, when AJ's letter arrived in Ponyville, I had already figured out what happened and what kinda of episode that one was about. But I agree with you.
After a bit of thought an amusing thought sprang to mind. What if the exact opposite of what AJ expected to happen happens and everyone LIKES the CMC's costumes and compliments them on them? Could you just see AJ's reaction of Shock among other things? Heck it could be amusing if the actual Dazzlings spot the trio and even complimented em.
7914572 I might consider adding our three dazzling queens into the story at some point...
7914594 in the immortal words of Fluttershy ""
Applejack has a point here. Folks are probably still on edge about what the Dazzlings did, and they're not going to take it kindly to see them dressing up as them.
Also, starting off a chapter with a rant about how much you hate a character isn't a good idea.
I would recommend putting the author's note at the bottom.
If you hadn't pointed it out, I wouldn't have even thought you hate Applejack.
7924752
Honestly, he shouldn't have even put that there at all. I don't even like Applejack, but making a rant going into how much the author hates her is a bit unprofessional and may rub some readers the wrong way.
Ah the overprotective streak runs in applejack in both universes it appears
To put my piece in, I have to say I can understand what's going on here. Being a middle sibling, I can appreciate how Applejack feels; it is only natural to want to keep your younger sibling safe and all! On the other hand, having a brother above me, I can also appreciate how frustrating it can be when a sibling is overbearing.
In addition, and I can only hope it is deliberate, there are a few flaws in the logic. Looking back at the film, Granny Smith barely witnessed the events of Rainbow Rocks; she is nowhere to be found in the cafeteria during the events of Battle of the Bands, and is only seen at the farm reacting badly to the Rainboom's dreadful singing. Based on this information, we can conclude here that she is trying to legislate on issues she understands little, which I get with my parents all the time. Furthermore, I find it interesting that she calls Applejack out for her...historic relations with the truth:
But forgets that, less than a year earlier, Apple Bloom and her friends basically pulled the biggest lie in the history of CHS. Nontheless, a fun reinvention of typical tropes, and I look forward to seeing what happens next.