Wow. Just wow. So instead of a story that twists reality, offers a one sided argument, and depicts a character who is doing horrible things as being ultimately the lesser of two evils, completely ignores canon against HUMANS, you write a story that twists reality, offers a one sided argument, and depicts a character who is doing horrible things as being ultimately the lesser of two evils, completely ignores canon against PONIES.

oh I got a god damn bloody-smile or boner for sick-fucks from hearing that Twinkles was skinned

...A new-foal psychopath.

That is... freaking brilliant. Talk about two horrible things, getting worse thanks to a positive feedback loop of horribleness.

This character reminds me of Dexter Morgan, anyone else getting that vibe?

5211844 Please leave.

This is brilliant and, based on common interpretations of the Newfoal potion, makes perfect sense. Well-done.

5215239 I'm guessing in this universe, the potion twists the person's conscious to the point it is overpowering to the point their body won't respond to them. A living hell for anyone who isn't already exactly like what a new foal is. A pyschopath doesn't any conscious to twist so the reversal happened. The potion's effect became 100% for any action.

5219419 I'm thinking more like an evil Sherlock or Hannibal.

5219419
Kind of, but he wouldn't tolerate his ally killing a foal. Dexter's only moral standard in the books and show was that he wasn't willing to kill children. That and an aversion to rape, but that was largely because he's asexual.

and the librarian was one of the biggest bibliophiles

Personally, I think 'sophophiles' would be more accurate.

Wow. They really screwed the pooch with this one...

i wouldnt mind an investigator perspective on this one