• Published 28th Sep 2014
  • 926 Views, 35 Comments

Starcrossed - raritypie

After getting some surprising news,shenanigans ensue. Will it make their relationship crumble? Or will they be destined to be together forever?

  • ...


"That was one wild party Mr.Sandwich" Said Mayor Silverstar.

"It was my honor."

"Can you please throw my grandfilly's birthday party next weekend? She would love it."

"Sorry Sir, but in the morning I'll be heading to my next destination."

"Aww. Where are you going?"

"Wherever I'm needed, I'm sure I'll find something soon."

"Well good luck to ya Pardner! You're always welcome here in Appleloosa. Enjoy the rest of your stay!"

"Thank you Sir."

The mayor galloped away into the Sunset.

Today was the 60th anniversary of the town's foundation. My cheesy sense brought me to this town once more. It was one of my first parties where I had been on such a short schedule. I had only three hours to plan and create a party for the town's anniversary.It was quite stressful but it was worth it in the end.

I stayed at a local Farmer's home for the night. The mayor told me he was also a member of the Apple Family but was away in a nearby town competing in some sort of competition.

The house quite spacious and sort of smelly, It smelt of Cinnamon Apples and it had a western vibe that seemed a little too familiar. Where did I know this smell?

Eventually I found a guestroom. It was rather small compared to the other rooms in the house but I guess it would have to do for the night. I got into the bed, it was quite comfortable as if i was laying in a flower bed.

I tried my best to go to bed but mind began to wonder. "Did Pinkie get my letter? How is she?" and many more questions ran through my mind.

I hadn't seen her in about a year but we try our best to write each other.I love her so much and I can't wait to see her again.

I was almost asleep when a bright green flame awoken me. The flame produced two letters. One from Pinkie Pie and one that did not have a name or address on it. I immediately opened Pinkie's but my curiosity nearly got the better of me, What was this mysterious letter and who was it from?

Pinkie's letter read:

Dear Cheese,

I hope you have fun in Appleloosa! Make sure to send lots and lots of pictures. I can't wait to see them and you when you get back! I miss you sooooooooooooooooo much! Chimicherry Changas haven't been the same since you left! I hope to see you really really really soon.

With lots of Love,
Pinkie Pie
P:S- XOXOXOXOXOXOXO infinite hugs and kisses!

I was glad to know Pinkie is okay and I'll make sure to visit her soon, but this letter piqued my curiosity. I cautiously opened it and it read:

Dear Cheese Sandwich,

We are in need of your services. Please come to Ponyville at once, Come to the Town Square tomorrow evening, Come Alone and not a word of this to Pinkie Pie.


A friend.

The mysterious letter shook me up a little. "Come alone? Not a word to Pinkie?" How did this pony know Pinkie and Me? How did they know where I was? Who is this creature?

Many other questions ran through my mind. I wouldn't know who this thing was until tomorrow so I tried my best to sleep.

In the morning, I packed my bags and was ready to leave, I began my walk to the station. There was a rather large crowd blocking the entrance to the train. I wonder what happened? I bumped into the mayor.

"Oh! Mr.Mayor! What's all the hubbub?"

"It's terrible! The train has broken down."

"That is terrible."

"What's worse is the mechanic can't come until late this afternoon. So the express is delayed for a few hours."

"Delayed....wait..." The train is delayed meaning I may not get back to Ponyville in time!

"Mayor! Is their another way to Ponyville?"

"Hmmm. I guess you could get a taxi but it'll cost ya..."

"That's fine! I'll do your Grandfilly's birthday party! Is that enough?"

"Absolutely! Oh little Basil will be so pleased..." He rambled on.

"Can you just get me a taxi?!"

"Oh I'm sorry. That fellow will get you there lickity split." He pointed to a muscular brown stallion standing next to his taxi. "Just tell him I sent you,"

"Thanks!" I ran to the stallion and explained my situation.

"Don't worry. I'll make sure to get you there before Sundown!"

I hopped into the taxi and the driver sprinted off. I looked around and all of the sights and colors blended together. It made me a little dizzy.

I pulled both letters out of my pocket. Pinkie's letters always brought a smile to my face and right now I certainly need one. And then I thought of something, If two letters were delivered to me How did they get Pinkie's? Did they steal the letter? Where they holding her hostage? What is going on here?!

"I guess I'll find out when I arrive." It bothered me the entire trip to Ponyville.

About five hours later, I arrived on the outskirts of Ponyville.

"Sorry Bud but this is the farthest I go. Good Luck on your search."


The driver galloped away into the evening sun.

I needed to get to Ponyville before the sun set,. Looking at the sky once more, It was about Six O' Clock. I needed to get there by Seven before it became nighttime. It may have been only an hour but i tried my hardest to get back to Ponyville.

I galloped and galloped. I soon saw the town on the horizon. I was anxious and I needed to know what exactly was going on. I ran faster than I have done in years but eventually I made it.

It was just getting dark. The ponies were getting ready for bed and settling back into their homes. I walked to towns square and waited for this enigma to rear its ugly head.

It was about an hour until the ponies had finally settled in and an eerie silence laid over the town. I sat on the stairs and was surprised when I heard a voice.

"Hello Cheese."

The voice had frightened me and scared me out of my daydream.

"....Who exactly are you? Where's Pinkie?!"

"Hehehe just as I said in my letter. A friend."

"That's not good enough! Who are you? Where is Pinkie?!"

"She's perfectly fine. I assure you she's safe. Ater all...she asked me to send it."

"You? Who are you?!" I repeated once more. I was aggravated by this pony's games and I just needed to know what was going on.

"All will be explained in due time Mr.Sandwich."

"...." There were too many mysteries lingering about. I need to know,

"How does she know you?"

"I will repeat it once more. I am a friend. I mean no harm. Now if you could just come with me-"

"NO! Not until i know what in Equestria is going on?!"

"I didn't want to do this but it looks like I'm forced to use desperate measures."

"Wait wha-" I was interrupted by a loud whistle.

A large pain sizzled through my flank. What was happening?

"Whats...going... oN?" I was dizzy and my vision began to fade. A streetlight began to flicker and showed the mysterious pony's body. I couldn't find much about the pony, Only that it wore a black coat.

It was the last thing I saw that evening.

Author's Note:

I hope you all enjoy this chapter.Sorry it's just a little dark. I just wanted something a little fun with this. Please make sure to like,favorite and follow me!

Join our Patreon to remove these adverts!
Join our Patreon to remove these adverts!