• Member Since 11th May, 2013
  • offline last seen April 16th

Harmony Charmer

♪ Kingdom of ships around me and it looks like I'm the queen ♫



This story is a sequel to First Date

After Sweetie Belle and Button Mash became a couple, Diamond Tiara has been giving them a harder time than usual. Finally, when Sweetie finally confronts her on the matter, Diamond takes it as a challenge and makes a dare with her: if Sweetie Belle manages to win the upcoming talent show, Diamond will leave them alone. But, if Diamond wins, she gets Button to herself!

Will Button and the Crusaders get Sweetie to perform?

Celebrating 450+ followers!

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 46 )

I can never get enough Button Mash. :rainbowlaugh:
Cute story. Me like. :twilightsmile:

This is nice and diamond tiara doesn't cease to want me to not knock her block off.

It seems Scoots was pretty impressed with Diamond. Given how the event turned out, I guess either that outfit was just a bit much or Scoots has no taste in dance. *shug*

Cute story. Scootaloo really rolled things along with that comment that got a reaction from the three. xD

The battle for Button is over. But the WAR is far from over!

inb4 Scootaloo confesses her secret crush on...

4754618 All's fair in love and war. :scootangel:

And my hatred for Diamond Tiara grow ever stronger. :twilightangry2:

Very cute story. Always love to see ButtonBelle (or is it SweetieMash?) stories. :twilightsmile:

It's very fabulous I love it :moustache:

Very cute and made me smile! :twilightsmile:

Awwwww! I love seeing these together, they're adorable.

How cute! I have a soft spot for ButtonBelle, but stories with them aren't always written as well as this.

4754638 Or maybe Scootaloo secretly has 'feelings' for Diamond Tiara. :trixieshiftright: (Probably not but you never know.)

Adorable. I just love ButtonBelle. And Button is just awesome himself. :moustache:

Sorry, I've been at vaca for a week... ERMAGAWD! Amazing! Think it's time for a multi-chapter!

A cute sequel/followup to a cute story. :twilightsmile:

You know, Button could technically press charges against Diamond Tiara: theft and destruction of property.
That, plus the frequent harassment and her proclaiming her intent to claim him for herself in front of witnesses, and he could file a restraining order against her.
Maybe that should be part three. Princess Twilight presides over Button Mash filing a restraining order against Diamond Tiara. Just picturing Twilight's face when she reads the docket of what the case is - which, to be topical, will probably be filed as a "Cease and Desist" and Twilight will have to tell Button that what he wants is a restraining order - is making me giggle like a loon.


Don't you remember that Scootaloo dances herself? You know, from the talent show episode, of which I forget the name of.

4758325 Oh, I know, :rainbowlaugh: and it's S1 "The Show Stoppers" case you still wondering.

But that's why when she says DT's dance was "yeah, it really was" and how she gave her honest opinion about it, it makes me wonder what factored into DT getting the award she got, aside from the obvious need to have a sort of shoehorn "We won!" with the love rival getting humiliated in the end.

DT arguably could of just gotten a different prize. I'd like to think the dress is what made an otherwise amazing dance, into something the adults were supposed to laugh at.

I hope this makes a bit more sense now, as I can be a pretty facetious at times. Would have been more dramatic as well if DT had actually won FIRST, only for SB to end up getting a bit higher response from the crowd with an award for her performance that basically meant the same or a bit more than what DT got. Though, it being Cheerilee, I'm sure they are all equal outside of category.

In summary: I love Scoots. Which is why I'm slightly disappointed the story questions her character's taste/opinion on DT's dance routine being as good as DT said it was. Meaning Sweetie Belle could of had an actual chance of losing Button Mash after catching some oh the praise from the audience that could build more anxiety in SB.

P.S. I'm still pretty happy with how it ran. But the ending didn't surprise me, and honestly the Scootaloo bit killed the only believability I had with it potentially being DT's overly flashy outfit.

I loved this story so much! :twilightsmile:

I didn't expect Diamond to like Button. What I want to know is why. I feel like that was never really clarified enough for my liking, but that's just my opinion. :rainbowderp:

Also, here's a message for Diamond:

I heard this on Tumblr once and I just can't let go of it. I feel like it fits considering how many times they said "jerk" in the story. :rainbowlaugh::derpytongue2:

I can just hear their voices in the gif… :rainbowlaugh:

SweetieMash is best Sweetie Belle ship. :yay::twilightsmile::raritystarry::rainbowkiss::pinkiehappy::ajsmug:

Gah this was heart-destroyingly adorable.

Never underestimate the power of a moustache.:moustache:

Oh, Button, you so adorkable... :rainbowkiss:

MORE Adorkable SweetieMash based on the story that had that one really epic speech in it?

I approve

am i the only one who sees a clopfic with Diamond Sweetie and Button

I wish sweetie belle could have got her cutie mark but whatever

Good Story:pinkiehappy:

Can't wait to see what Diamond has up her "sleeves" for the next one.

Keep up the great work! :unsuresweetie: (how is this the only SB face???)


Yes, yes you are!

At least that is what I would like to say.

This can be a creepy fan base some times :twilightangry2:

But seriously, their just kids, fictional or not.

4767298 being kids in a fanfic doesn't change anything people can age the characters so their teens or adults but your right on this being a creepy fan base at times but that's what make it fun to read.


Creepy scary, like a horror movie is no problem.

And creepy sex offender in adult themes, meh, what ever floats your boat.

But creepy child abuse/molester, kind of wayyyy over the line. (Not saying you do this stuff, just an "in general" note of my opinion.):pinkiesick:

Is no one going to comment on about the Sweetie "Rarity" breakdown. It was my favorite part, ""You realize I can never unsee that comparison?" and a close second is when Sweetie called DT a Moblin.

Side note: Avery is a very heroic sounding name and i like the implications of that.:rainbowlaugh:

4772421 and i agree with you on that. that's why i say age the characters so its not kid sex. then in normal sex still odd but you can't stop people from wrighting those kinds of thing.

I don't know if I find this funnier than it is, but I think the "comedy" tag is missing :rainbowwild:

i love this story , are you gonna make anymore i just cant get enough of this, looking forward to more. 100% bishop approved :moustache:

stay classy :moustache:

Whelp, Charmer's at it again. Great story, as usual. :twilightsmile:

Haha! Awesome! :pinkiehappy::scootangel::twistnerd:

But one question: Wouldn't Sweetie Belle get her cutie mark from the talent show? Because her real talent is singing; she just can't seem to figure it out.
Oh well, it's a fan made story anyways.

And I agree with Button, matching sweaters would be ABSOLUTELY HORRIFIC.

Thing about cutie marks is that they don't appear until a character accepts that they may have found what their destiny is. Rarity didn't get her cutie mark until her teacher told her that she did a good job with her designs and she realized that she was good at dressmaking; Fluttershy didn't get her cutie mark until she saw how well she communicated with the animals; Rainbow Dash didn't get her cutie mark until she won the race with her Sonic Rainboom and saw that she liked flying. It goes on and on, though there are moments where the character doesn't seem to realize that they accepted their destiny, Twilight being a good example.

Sweetie in this instance just saw singing as something fun to do, not as her destiny; that's for later.

Aha, I see. :applejackunsure:

Welp! That sure makes more sense! Thanks! :twilightsheepish:

This was amazing it was so cute :pinkiehappy: keep up the good work you have earned a fallow

You can never go wrong with the stash :moustache:
Hahahahaha diamond got the comedy medal :rainbowlaugh:

What the — now, wait just a moment! Absolutely not! Doesn't Button Mash get a say in all thi —

.... right. In that case Button, it's dangerous to go alone.

Take this!

I..... I just loved the whole "It's a guy? Shots fired then." Shots fired indeed Apple Bloom, shots fired indeed.

And for Best Comedic Performance, we have Diamond Tiara with her hilarious dancing!"

Let's just appreciate the fact that DT won, in Chris Jericho's words, Stupidest Idiot Award.:rainbowlaugh:
Really cute story. Button being the hero for Sweetie, AWESOME.

beautiful just aboustley beautiful

Login or register to comment