Trixie and Maud: Heart of Stone

by TheCrimsonDM

Chapter Forty Seven: Cold Consequence

HEART OF STONE
Chapter Forty Seven: Cold Consequence
Written by TheCrimsonDM

Trixie laid completely still as her grasp around Pinkie Pie tightened. The covers of the bed might have been warm, but they couldn’t compare to the heat of Pinkie’s body. Trixie couldn’t help but burry her muzzle into the back of Pinkie’s neck as she tried to stave off the cold. But even though she was warm under the blankets with Pinkie Pie she couldn’t go back to sleep yet.

The thought’s of every dirty act she had done with the other three wouldn’t leave her alone. She had just sunk to a new level of depravity, all the kissing, the touching, the licking, and oh sweet Celestia was Trixie still turned on. She held on a little tighter to Pinkie Pie and tried to forget about what she had done.

“Trixie, your cuddling me a little too tightly. Could you loosen your grip a little bit?” Pinkie Pie asked in a strained voice.

Trixie suddenly released her grip on Pinkie Pie and stayed quiet for a long moment before asking, “Did we really just do that?”

“Yep, and it was fun…fun…fun,” Pinkie Pie said in a quiet voice.

Trixie didn’t like the sound of Pinkie’s voice, or the way she had said that. “What’s wrong?”

“It’s just the fact that I haven’t…done ‘that’ before…and…Trixie, am I a bad pony?” Pinkie asked her voice now full of worry.

“No you’re a wonderfully good pony, why would you even think of yourself as a bad pony?” Trixie said.

“Because I just had sex with my sister…I…oh crap…” Pinkie whispered. Pinkie Pie rolled over in the bed and faced Trixie and she stared with her soft blue eyes into Trixie’s. “I just did something really bad, and if my parents ever found out about this…they hate me enough already, they would disown me for this.”

Trixie closed her eyes and nuzzled pinkie’s nose. Trixie felt the shame and disappointment that was ebbing off of Pinkie’s heart. Trixie knew exactly how Pinkie Pie felt right now, this was supposed to just be a little night of fun and nopony even thought about the consequences. This was exactly why Trixie didn’t want to do this in the first place. She knew that feelings would get hurt afterwards, just not in this way.

“Pinkie Pie,” Trixie whispered.

“Yeah,” Pinkie Pie said before sniffling.

“You are a good pony, this was just a crazy thing that happened okay. There was nothing wrong with this at all…it was just for fun. Now go to sleep like a good little pony, and if you need me I’m here for you,” Trixie comforted.

“But I’m the big sister, I’m supposed to take care of you. Not the other way around, this isn’t right,” Pinkie protested.

“Pinkie Pie, you have done so much for me already. Now let me take care of you for once,” Trixie said.

Pinkie Pie cuddled into Trixie, and found a place for her head to rest against Trixie’s chest. Trixie kissed the top of Pinkie’s head and held her tightly. After a few seconds Trixie could hear Pinkie crying softly and quietly. Trixie vowed to do everything she could to take care of Pinkie Pie, after all that Pinkie had done for her, she only felt that it was right to return the favor.

***

After Pinkie Pie fell asleep in Trixie’s embrace it was time to go and see where the other two had wandered off to. Trixie very carefully climbed out of bed, taking extra precaution to not wake Pinkie from her hard earned slumber. Trixie made her way to the door and took one look back at the sleeping pink pony on her bed and let out a sigh. If only she was stronger she could have stopped Pinkie from getting her feelings hurt, but she had to give in to temptation didn’t she?

Just outside the door Trixie found Maud and Rarity playing a card game on the table. Trixie took a seat next to them quietly and watched them play in silence. It looked like they were playing poker, and Maud was winning…of course. As the game played on the two ponies barely even glanced at Trixie, they were locked in a serious battle of luck, and skill.

The dark sky outside was red as though it was burning, but the snow coming down told another story. The clock on the wall read nine pm and Trixie realized that by having slept so long in the day, she might not get any good sleep tonight. The snow outside was building up on the window ledge and was almost pretty, for snow that is. Something was in the sky though. Something almost pony shaped was flying circles in the sky. Trixie lost sight of it just as quickly as see found it, and came to the conclusion that it was probably just some crazy pegasus checking on the weather down below.

As the two ponies continued playing Rarity began winning, by a lot. Even though Maud was unreadable, she also had a hard time reading others expressions. At some point Trixie felt hunger kick in and she made herself a daisy sandwich as the two continued their game.

Eventually the game was over and Rarity sat proudly with her winning hand on the table. Trixie knew that neither of them were actually that good at the game, Twilight could beat them in a heartbeat but that’s what math geniuses did to poker; they destroyed it. Finally now that the two of them were done playing they gave some attention to Trixie.

“Darling, did you want anything from us?” Rarity asked.

Trixie shook her head as she took another bite from her sandwich.

“Lulu, did you want some dinner?” Maud asked. “I made some while you were asleep.”

Trixie nodded and set the sandwich down, it was almost finished but Trixie hadn’t eaten anything since lunch today and after such extravagant activity she was starving. As Maud began heating up the dinner which smelled heavily of some kind of vegetable soup she finished her sandwich before talking to Rarity.

“So when did the pegasi say that this blizzard would end?” Trixie asked.

“They actually never announced this blizzard. I’ve been thinking it was a fluke in advertising but that’s just not like them,” Rarity said.

Trixie stared for a few moments at Rarity as she considered her words, however Trixie lost her concentration as she stared at Rarity’s pure white muzzle. She remembered how good Rarity was at kissing, and then Trixie’s eyes flowed down to Rarity’s forelegs and she thought about how gentle, yet pleasing Rarity was her hooves. Trixie’s eyes settled on Rarity’s flank and Trixie remembered what it felt like when Rarity had began-

“Trixie, are you okay?” Rarity asked abruptly.

“What?” Trixie said as she tried to focus on anything in the room other then Rarity’s sexy flanks.

“I asked you if you were okay, darling. You looked a little lost, and your eyes were wandering away from you,” Rarity explained with a wink.

Trixie’s face began heating up as she realized that Rarity knew exactly what Trixie had been thinking. Trixie tried to find anything that she could latch onto other then thought’s of shameful activities. Suddenly Pinkie’s shame came back to Trixie’s mind and her heart sunk. Looking back at Rarity and deeply into her eyes Trixie said quietly, “I think this was a mistake.”

Rarity nodded and said, “I was worried that you might not be able to handle this. Especially after everything that has happened to you, I’m sorry if I did anything to upset you.”

Trixie shook her head and said, “I’m not…upset. But it’s just that what we did together…it changes our friendship doesn’t it?”

“I would hope for the better, after all I know how much you dislike me,” Rarity said before looking away.

Trixie couldn’t help but ask, “How?”

“We were inside your mind, remember? After everything the three of us did to you, it would only make sense that you would have a hard time trusting us again,” Rarity answered.

“Look everything we did together, I’m fine with that but…what if I wasn’t the one who was actually hurt by this? What if somepony else was having trouble with this?” Trixie asked in a whisper, praying that Maud wouldn’t hear her just yet.

Rarity leaned in and said in a whisper, “I don’t get it? It was just you and me who were enthralled for a while in there. Shouldn’t you be the one feeling badly about the fact that you were with another pony. After all Maud was busy with Pinkie Pie and that can of whipped cream.”

“You mean that Maud was busy pleasing her sister,” Trixie whispered.

Rarity looked confused for a second, then thoughtful, and then a look of horror crept over every feature of her face as she whispered in such a low tone that Trixie barely caught the words, “Her…sister.”

***

The next half hour was filled with an uncomfortable silence as Trixie ate the wonderfully reheated dinner. At first Maud didn’t seem to notice that something was wrong but by now she was staring at Trixie and causing her to feel very awkward. Trixie wanted to tell Maud exactly what was wrong, but it turned out to be harder then she imagined to find the words that she needed to speak. Eventually Trixie found the courage to say, “Maud, we need to talk about what happened today.”

Maud continued staring at Trixie, and no matter how hard she tried Trixie just couldn’t meet Maud’s eyes. Trixie quietly said, “I…I think this was a mistake. I knew that there would be consequences for doing something like this, but I didn’t think they would be like this.”

“If you’re worried about having enjoyed being with the others, then don’t. It’s normal to enjoy it, Lulu.” Maud said.

“That’s not the problem, I’m just fine with all that but…um…” Trixie said.

“It’ll be fine, darling. Continue,” Rarity said.

Trixie took in a deep breath and exhaled while trying to calm herself for what she about to say. “Maud, you just had sex with your own flesh and blood…your sister. Don’t you think that there is anything wrong with that?”

Maud was silent for a few long moments and nopony could speak a word after that. Finally at great length Maud said, “But I did that for you, Lulu.”

Trixie felt a cold shiver run down her spine as she contemplated the idea that Maud would do anything for her, even this. Trixie closed her eyes tightly and said, “But don’t you think it was wrong?”

“You wanted to watch me do exactly that to Pinkie Pie, so I did it. I saw it in your dream, Lulu,” Maud said.

“But was it wrong?” Trixie asked again, this time taking a serious tone.

Maud was silent for a few seconds before lowering her eyes to the floor and saying, “…it was just sex…wasn’t it…”

Trixie saw a single tear running down Maud’s cheek. Maud had been trying to lie to herself about all of this being okay, hadn’t she? Trixie moved next to Maud and wrapped a foreleg around Maud’s shoulder and held her close. “It’s going to be okay. You just made a mistake, honey…that happens sometimes and then we learn from them.”

“But I hurt my sister again. Didn’t I?” Maud asked.

“Pinkie Pie will be okay, she really will I promise. This was an awkward thing that happened, but we don’t have to let it hurt our relationship with each other,” Trixie consoled. It was strange to be the one giving advice to the others for once, but maybe it was because Trixie understood mistakes better than anypony.

“At first…I just wanted to make you happy,” Maud said. “And then when we were in the middle of it all…I began to think…I…thought maybe I could make it up to her if…if only I was…good enough.”

“Maud, that’s silly…but ponies are silly sometimes. Pinkie loves you more than anything else in the whole, wide world, just making her feel ‘good’ isn’t going to change your relationship…at least not in the way that you want it to,” Trixie said.

“I hurt her again. I just wanted to make you happy, and I wanted to make her happy, and I wanted her to forgive me…I…I just screwed up everything,” Maud said quietly before resting her head against Trixie’s neck.

Trixie tightened her embrace around Maud a little bit before saying, “It’s going to be okay, you two just need to talk about your feelings.”

“I’m not good at talking about feelings,” Maud explained.

“You’re talking right now aren’t you?” Trixie pointed out.

“That’s because you’re special,” Maud said.

Trixie kissed the top of Maud’s head and said, “I know that you use sex as a way to communicate with ponies, you have done that since long before you met me. But that’s not healthy…you need to learn to explain your feelings with words, and I’ll help you if you want.”

Maud wrapped both her forelegs around Trixie and said, “I’d love that, I really would…but I…I have a question.”

“Yes, honey?” Trixie said.

“Was it really so bad…to let you live out one of your fantasies? Was it really that bad of me?” Maud asked, her voice tinted with worry and fear.

“No it wasn’t bad of you, honey. You just wanted to make everypony happy, and that is a wonderful thing to do. You don’t need to feel ashamed of that at all, you are a good pony,” Trixie said.

The bedroom door opened slowly and Pinkie Pie walked out. Pinkie’s face was wet with tears, and her eyes were red. Pinkie Pie looked at Maud and Trixie and said, “I just wanted to have f-f-fun…I didn’t think about what I would feel like afterwards.”

Pinkie Pie sat down and closed her eyes before cringing. Pinkie was fighting back her tears, and trying her best to not cry. Pinkie Pie however was losing that battle as the tears streamed down her face and she finally said, “Why does it feel so wrong.”

“Darling, shh it’s okay we’re here for you,” Rarity offered as she walked towards Pinkie Pie.

Pinkie Pie wrapped her hooves around Rarity and began whimpering. “Please don’t tell her, please don’t tell her, please don’t tell her,” Pinkie Pie begged repeatedly.

“Don’t tell who?” Rarity asked.

“Fluttershy,” Pinkie Pie managed to say, just before breaking down into an inconsolable sobbing mess.

A cold icy sliver crawled its way down Trixie’s mane, across her spine and then through her tail as she heard the name, Fluttershy. Trixie opened her mouth and whispered, “Oh crap.

Comments

[Texus]

Why does Pinki say something about Fluttershy?, is it because she loves Trixie, and Fluttershy was exactly the one Pony, who wasn´t allowed in their little sex adventure?

I hope my sentence makes sense, but i really think that they maybe feel bad, because they had could have invited Fluttershy.

I honesty thought that Rarity was maybe a bit shy, but i guess Maud and Rarity talked already.

edit: i liked it

[crowscrowcrow]

Vacations are surprisingly unlikely times for me to read anything, but now that that's over... Sweet chapter ^^

I'm pleased to see that this wasn't just a spot of random fun sex with no consequences, though I am somewhat surprised that Maud and Pinkie didn't consider that aspect of it prior. They'd joked about it, but then again, perhaps they didn't think it would be a big deal until it actually happened. Pinkie certainly seems to have gotten hit out of left field, she just thought it was going to be fun. Maud on the other hand may have considered that it was something bad, as she tried to 'make it up' to Pinkie by making it feel great. It would seem like Maud had reservations in the first place, but put them aside for the sake of fulfilling Trixie's fantasy.

I am not quite sure how Fluttershy will factor into it yet. One thing I do know for sure is that I'm glad that Fluttershy was not invited to the orgy. It was intended to be just a bit of fun, and I do not think Fluttershy, who has genuine feelings for Trixie, would have been at all helped by getting some 'meaningless' sex with Trixie. Then again, we still don't know what happened between FS and Trixie during the alicorn amulet incident, other than Scath's taunt.

eaten anything since launch today

[radekmiramax]

So far so good. Sorry for my bad english. I am from Czech republic.
"Maud, that’s silly…but people are..." i think the right word is ponies.

[Wolfie 03]

“Maud, that’s silly…but people are silly sometimes.

Ponies, not people. Just sayin'.

[Mr Swanky Hat]

6211063 like how its somepony, no pony and everypony instead of someone, no one and everyone. all hail our pony overlords