• Member Since 25th Oct, 2011
  • offline last seen Mar 26th, 2021

paxtofettel


E

Ok, this is my first ever MLP:FiM fic, so please don't expect anything on the same level as stuff by Buttersc0tchSundae or Lunafyre. Please be gentle with the reviews, however, I am open to any suggestions that can help me improve my writing.

Note: In this story, I made Caramel into a farm hand instead of an Apple Family member. So don't worry about any incestual stuff.

Also, please ignore the second chapter. I am new to this site so I can't delete that blank chapter.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 6 )

Short and simple- too much so, in fact. It was a bit lacking and empty-feeling. But still, not bad for your first fic. No grammar or spelling errors I could see, and it reads well other than just being too, well, bland. Keep working at it, look forward to seeing more from you! :twilightsmile:

18513

Hmmm, I see. Thank you for the honest review, I will be sure to take what you said in consideration in my next fics.

I'd assumed chicken soup given by Fluttershy being what she gives to her chickens.:twilightsmile:

Too quick and short.
I liked it, but was disappointed it ended so abruptly.

Keep writing, just try elongate your stories a bit. Very impressive from a newbie though (Not to be confused with noob. Newbie is nice :heart: )

Caramel was never even a relation of Applejack's to begin with. Also I'm more inclined to think she's closer to a mare than filly. But it still is a nice story. :yay::heart::eeyup:

Login or register to comment