• Member Since 18th Apr, 2014
  • offline last seen Jul 4th, 2019

Night Soul


Im a girl that enjoys making my own art for my covers and writing ponies. Did I mention I like Brony music and I'm a Pegasister?

E

Luna spends her nights crying on the overhang every night. And when she is met by a fellow unicorn, she finally has a solution to end her miseries.
A really short story, and my first fic. Hope you enjoy!

Chapters (2)
Comments ( 14 )

I don't have much of a story here, but I tried my best :twilightsmile:
Hope you enjoy! And I don't mind critique.

Nice!!!!!! But,, just 1 little question:
Why was Twilight there? I might sound dumb but...... :rainbowhuh:

4254218 That's for the reader to decide :twilightsheepish:
I honestly had no idea why I included Twilight, but she is Celestia's student, after all. She wasn't an alicorn for this story, so...:twilightblush:

I don't want to sound negative - there is the core of a good idea in here - but it just seemed to be over too quickly. I guess, with a story that involves suicide, I want more of an explanation, more exposition of why the character feels that way. Also, there are some narrative and grammatical problems that disturbed the flow.

4254386 Yeah, I figured that :twilightsheepish:
Its my first fic after all and to be honest I actually made this a while back and found it afterwards.
I'm actually thinking of adding another chapter that implies Luna's actual feelings towards her death, with visiting Celestia in a dream included. But it is a short fic, after all.
And my narrative speaking/grammar was bad back then, but now its improved. Thanks for your critique! :twilightsmile:

4254454

You're quite welcome. Another chapter would be very welcome. I, for one, would love to see more of this. :pinkiesmile:

Immortals don't die...
..they always come back, so a sequel is in order.
Meh, love=return from the grave. I know it's creepy, but it has happened in numerous movies and books.

Besides, I hate endings where somepony dies, because that is an unhappy ending, and I hate those:ajbemused:...

...but this might be that one exception to my rule, which is 'happy ending or bust'.

SEQUEL!

There is no emotion in this story. :ajbemused:

Edit- The dialogue is wooden, Luna's explanation remains unknown, and Celestia took her death as one would their goldfish.

All in all, I don't like how lazy the whole thing is. Here, have an explained dislike.

4254857
Finally, first negative critique! :pinkiesmile:
Thanks for your comment, and I know my story totally needs big improvement. I'm going to add a new chapter that should help with the confusing stuff.
:twilightsmile: And yes, its very lazy. I wrote this before, and I wasn't so keen. I am now, thanks to you! :pinkiehappy:

4254712
Ha, I broke your rule. Oopsie!
Hey, does adding another chapter count as a sequel? :scootangel:

4254970
A new chapter isn't a sequel, but it IS what I meant.:twilightsmile:
This story needs more, well, story!:twilightsmile:
:yay::flutterrage:MORE!:flutterrage::yay:

4254963

Good!

It's nice to meet a guy who can take bad feedback :twilightsmile:

4255124
Yeah, I get around the Internet a lot :trixieshiftright:

Login or register to comment