Narcissus grimaced at the metal choker around his neck,even needing to suppressing a cough as the necklace bit into his throat. The sterile light in the ceiling gleamed off the golden-steel of the necklace. The light seemed to twist itself, almost as it becoming its own entity.
His heart pounded and his veins threatened to rupture under the titanic pressure of his blood. Left ventricle, right ventricle – every pump physically shaking his body side-to-side. His pupils dilated, only to be forced back into line by the incredible shine of the beam of energy before him.
Sweat drenching his body, the beads threatening to drip into his eyes, Narcissus eyed the second beam of ‘energy’: a stream of pure darkness that sucked up the light around it like a blackhole. The beam bore into the six Gems of Clarity, its shadowy tendrils seeping out, slithering through the air and into all six gems, draining them of their luster.
“M-moi never put much faiz i-in Up Above,” Narcissus stammered, blinking the sweat out of his eyes, unwilling to so much as inch away from his position for fear of disembowel–no, disensoulment. “But now-” he gulped “-now moi ‘opes someone’s zere.”
The right corner of Cau’s mouth curled into a smirk. “Grim as ever, my friend? Do you still pray to your old god?” Cau shook his head, his amused expression contrasting so heavily with Narcissus’ expression that one could easily mistake the two for being in entirely separate planes of existence.
Narcissus scoffed. “No, she ees dead to moi, as ees everything from dzose times. You should know, your origin ees not unlike mine.”
Everything stopped. The coiled of blackness released themselves from the Gems, dropping them onto the ground, their luster gone and replaced by a stony gray.
“What ‘ave you done wis dze Gems of Clarity, godiche‽” Narcissus shouted, the choker around his neck no longer strangling him. “’Ow could you transform such etalons of beauty and grace into.... into ZIS?”
Cau rolled his eyes. “Are pretty things all you care about?”
“Moi-”
“Calm down, Wielder of Penury,” Cau chuckled.
Narcissus bit his lip, and if he were anything but an herbivore, the pressure of his bite might have broken skin. “Why, oh Déesse, mon elder goddess from the old lands, why? Why are you so cruel to me?” he whinnied, melodramatically raising a hoof to the heavens. “Why, oh why, ‘as moi received such a cursed gift?” he crooned.
“Let me guess,” Cau nickered, “because you’re the epitome of penury?”
“You are so cruel and mean, godiche! Moi was never bitter! Moi is the epitome of generosity!”
“Yeah, right, and my mother was the illegitimate spawn of Princess Celestia and a farmer.”
Narcissus frowned, groaning, “Eh, godiche, moi ‘ave forgotten that there ees no point in complaining to you.” His expression deadened, his posture relaxing.
“And spoken with such elan,” Cau cooed. His expression deadpanned in kind. “You’re such a buzzkill, Narcissus. Why did you start this entire drama in the first place?”
“Moi was not acting! Dzis is ‘ow moi feels!” Narcissus replied in a matter-of-fact tone.
“Look, I don’t care. The fact is that the Element chose you, and now you’re its wielder.” Narcissus sighed. “And it’s fine with me because now we have one fewer moron to find.”
“Anyway, beau, let’s move on. Danger’s passed. Time for dze real show,” chirped Narcissus, his affect utterly changing. “What are we going to do now? ‘Ow do you wanna find ozer wielders?”
‘Narcissus, Narcissus. You never change. As random as ever’, Cau thought.
“Well how do you think I was gonna find them?”
“Moi ‘as no idea,” Narcissus replied, giving an innocent jostle of his shoulders.
“We are going to search at random,” Cau replied, giving Narcissus a sagely nod of his head as he adjusted his glasses. He picked up an object, a triangular thing with fives seals planted in regular intervals, and brought it from a dusty table to his face. “This is my newest invention,” Cauterium beamed. “This little baby is capable of reading ‘my’ Elements, determining whom they choose via a process of-” He shut himself up as he caught Narcissus’ expression.
“Uh, and dzat means what, exactly?” Narcissus inquired, pawing a hoof at the ground.
Cau sighed. “Well, to put it in your language: dzis seals shall glow stronger the closer potential wielder ees, n’est-il pas?”
“Ahh, moi understands now!” Narcissus exclaimed, and Cauterium facehoofed. “By dze way, you ‘ave used ‘n'est-il pas’ wrong.”
*****
The last of the apples rained down from the tree as Applejack stood beneath the canopy, panting, her legs burning from her work. She craned her neck around, her eyes basking in the menagerie of apples, the majority of which had almost all magically landed in her apple cart. A smirk crossed her face as she imagined the look on her brother’s face when he saw just how many apples she had bucked.
A bloom of sweat blossomed on the dirt below her as Applejack wiped the beads of midday sweat off her brow as she went about collecting the few stragglers who had avoided the vices of her cart. As she moved to attach the cart to herself, she heard a voice.
“Applejack!”
Applejack turned her head to an oncoming squad of three fillies as they galloped over a small hill to her. “What’s all the ruckus about?”
“AJ!” panted Applejack’s younger sister, Apple Bloom, one of three member of the notorious ‘Cutie Mark Crusaders’. “Uncle Claude is coming to the Sweet Apple Acres!”
Applejack’s pupils shriveled into little beads. “D-did you say ‘Uncle Claude’?” She gulped. Lowering the volume of her voice to a conspiratorial murmur, she asked, “What in tarnation is he doing here?”
Scootaloo, another one of the infamous ‘CMC’ stepped forward.“Applejack! Is everything Apple Bloom said about that guy true? Does he really eat cute little rabbits for a dinner?”
AJ sighed. “You’ve been listening to Auntie Apple Juice’s stories again, haven’t you? Uncle Claude is a normal pony, he just-” She bit her tongue. “He just has some... uh, ‘personality issues’. That’s all.”
Sweetie Belle shot AJ an incredulous look. “If that’s true, then why did you have such a weird reaction, huh, AJ?”
Applejack blew a puff of air out of the corner of her mouth. “I was just a little… surprised, that’s all.” The three fillies looked between each other. “Anyway,” Applejack dismissed, careful to contain the vague hint of worry in her voice, “since a member of the Apple family’s here, we ought to give him a proper fancy greetin’!”
Apple Bloom frowned. “Sorry, girls,” she sighed to her three friends. “Seems like we’ll have to go try out water skiing later.”
*****
A fairly bulky stallion sat there, chewing a piece of straw-grass in between sips of his tangy apple cider. His sea-blue eyes lazily shifted about, going left to right as though there was nothing before him, during which time he ran a hoof through his short brown mane. Adjusting his green vest, itself the same color as his coat, he sighed.
The air around him was choked in a thick, invisible miasma. It strangled the senses and tore at the lungs, the swelter slowly drowning all but himself in its effects. Reflecting the thicket where the faces of the four ponies before him. Everypony sat in the penumbra of silence that marked the stranger’s own air.
Thoguh to Apple Bloom he was hardly more than a stranger, Aplejack knew him fairl well. He was Claude Gravenstein, and his name was as apt as anypony’s. The Gravenstein apple was renowned for its bitter taste and hard exterior – a grim reminder of the little jokes that destiny played, always cautioning you to name your foals wisely. Although where ‘Claude’ came from was anypony’s guess – Applejack had heard a rumour that his parents were crazy, which is where the name came from.
Applejack cleared her throat. “H-howdy, Uncle Claude! What brings ya here today?”
Claude regarded her with his eyes for what, to Applejack, felt like an eternity. It was not as if he hated her specifically, he was giving her that same look that he gave everpony – a look that, in Applejack’s opinion, was long stuck to his face.
He lapped up the last few drops of his cider, sighing at his sudden dearth of alcohol. “I’m going to Appleloosa,” he said. “On my way there, I came across yer untidy little town and decided ta pay a visit to my ‘relatives’.” Claude stuffed the empty bottle into a vest pocket, returning his critical gaze to each member of the local Apple clan.
“Look at yerselves,” he chided after short pause. “Where are yer manners, yer endurance? Yer shaking like maple leaves in an august breeze from just my gaze. And ya call yerselves workhorses? Pheh.”
Applejack, Granny Smith, Apple Bloom, and Big Mac all exchanged glances, neither willing to respond to Claude – if you don’t have anything nice say, don’t say anything at all. Claude sneered. “Guess ya can’t handle my pressure, weaklings?” He shook his head. “Then I got nothin’ to do with the lot o’ ya.”
He stood up, making his way to the door. As he was halfway outside, he turned his head around and lectured, “This society need discipline and respect. Equestria's heading into the abyss. If Celestia continues her policy of utter pacifism then we’s all gonna turn into a spineless sons-of-mules like yerselves.” His final gesture was to spit at the external wall as he left.
As soon as he was out of earshot, everpony gave a collective sigh.
“What a troublesome pony he is,” Granny Smith opined to nopony in particular. “Good things he leaves if you’re quiet, ah, Big Macintosh?”
“Eeyup,” replied Big Macintosh.
Applejack shook her head. Her uncle had always dismayed her. She had wanted to be his friend, but he was just so unwilling to accept friendship. In a way, he reminded her of Twilight Sparkle – if Twilight had been aggressively mean, nasty, and a self-absorbed holier-than-thou narcissist.
After a minute of curious silence, AJ turned to her big brother and said, “Hey, Big Mac; told ya I could do all that applebuckin’ by myself! Ya owe me five bits!”
*****
Claude Gravenstein grumbled incomprehensible curses as he cantered down a dusty, gravel road all by his lonesome. The very atmosphere around him seemed to tear itself apart as it tried to blow away from him. The birds, no matter the species, halted their songs as he came within earshot. Even the sun seemed to shy away from his as it darted behind the trees that dotted the countryside.
A feeling crawled along the back of his neck, a feeling he knew only too well; the sense of being watched. It was not the first time he had been watched from afar. Ponies who were often too cowardly to approach him often found themselves staring from afar. But this time was different.
Under normal circumstances, all those looky-loos and gawkers were just that. They seldom paid attention for long, and even more seldom paid attention to him after he had left their presence. But to be watching – no, following – him for a good ten minutes was downright unheard of.
And it was ticking him off.
He stopped himself, spinning around to face where he thought the prying eyes were, bellowing, “Show yerselves. End this charade. I know yer here!”
Somewhere from the foliage came the sound of laughter, eliciting a snort from Claude. Out of the bush walked two stallions: a nerdy-looking unicorn with glasses, and a green sissy – at least that was Claude's first impression. They casually, almost menacingly, approached him.
“See? I told you that he’d find us sooner or later,” chuckled the nerdy-type stallion. The sissy didn't reply, he just stood there with a wry smile on his effeminate lips.
Claude eyed the two strangers. “And just who in tarnation are y’all?” To his admitted chagrin, his usual miasma of gloom didn’t seem to bother the strangers in the least bit. To Claude, this meant they were no weaklings, their looks being deceptively deceiving.
The unicorn whipped out a strange, shimmering object. It had five seals of it, one of which was flashing with an almost epileptic fervor. “Greetings. You may call me… Domenus.... Domin... Domi..." He paused for a brief moment, mumbling under his breath. "Er, Aenigmat - yes! You can call me Aenigmat!” Claude rolled his eyes at the atrocious attempt at lying. “Say, friend,” he said in a tone that was almost seductive, “ever had the desire to, say, I dunno, change the country for the good of all of us?”
Claude continued to glare at the two stallions. “I don’t understand what yer talkin’ ‘bout, skinny freaks. Who are ya anyway? And that hay’s with greenie’s stank?”
‘Greenie’ winced. “’Ow dare you, bourru‽ Dzis is my best everyday perfume!”
‘Aenigmat’ chuckled.
“Perfume? What are ya? A filly?” Claude scoffed.
“Ze fact dzat moi is a stallion doesn’t mean dzat moi must stink like a bucket of manure!”
“Yer disgusting,” Claude spat.
“Calm down, Narcissus,” the nerdy-type stallion chided. “We’re not here to talk about just how girly Narcissus is or isn't.”
“And I know yer name ain’t ‘Aenginamterg’ or whatever,” Claude said.
“‘Ees name is Cauterium,” Narcissus offered, giving the named stallion an evil grin.
Cauterium closed his eyes as he took a long, hard breath. Opening his eyes, he turned back to Calude. “You wouldn’t just so happen to be displeased with the current affairs of Equestria, would you, Claude Gravenstein? Is that not the opinion you expressed so thoroughly back at Sweet Apple Acres?”
Claude gritted his teeth, stopping just short of grinding them. “So, what of it? What do ya want from me?”
Cauterium grinned. “We want nothing. But you on the other hoof, you could use something from us – and we offer our gift free of charge.”
“Ain’t no such thing as no free meal,” Claude replied, his tone seeping acid.
“But of course, Gravenstein. But you see that we just so happen to share the same set of ideals. My ‘price’ has been prepaid in full by your very nature-” he paused for effect “-Wielder of Gloom.”
Out of the clear blue sky came the frantic sound of flapping wings, followed by a strange pegasus with a blue mask storming through the treetops.
“Seems like we shall be having of the company this hour, beau,” Narcissus sighed, not even bothering to notice just how little sense his sentence had made, which he did entirely for ‘climatic’ effect.
Heh, seems like third chapter is the shortest one by far. And as i see chapter 4, it shall be the longest.... Maybe i really should've put part of ch4 events in ch3, but nwhatever
A very interesting concept. Anti harmonius elements. I will be tracking this for sure.
340623
Thanks!
Well i say, Stalin+ good story.
I'll dance for you now
343585
Thanks!
Oh, btw. Seems like i should change so many thing in existing chapters
357417
Soon a full-fledged review shall be ready, and i shall change all chapters drastically, plus new chapter, which shall introduce another oc and show a fighting scene (longest episode by far) shall be ready soon as well
357917
Thanks!
360498
Thanks! As i told before, editing in process. PLUS i shall remade scenes in ch 1 so they shall look more appealing to newreader (i shall give a more clear hints that Twilight is under perfume and such)
A link to a review I did of this story in its current state. Posted in the comments by request.
360498
Agreeing with you, dude. I think that this thing that you said –
– is spot on.
360545
You've REALLY helped me out A LOT here! It's just whati needed! I shall redone existing chapters now. As promised, i'll do a picture of your villians soon
369982
Thanks! Also i partially remade chapter one (partually, hell, almost) Check it out if you want
I read though chapter 3, and so far i'm interested. There are grammar errors here and there, and if usual for a story to have those (Plus i've heard English us not your first language)
I have some problems though. I found the paragraphs to be spaced in a weird way, which was annoying to me. But the storyline is interesting, the OC are interesting, and I will be happily waiting for the next chapter.
370242
Tnx! I am currently working on finding the editor. Chapter four is ready but it has not been proofread yet.
Don't forget to contact me when your second chapter shall be ready
373302
I have not exatly understood what yoiu meant but thanks for feedback
373313
He's just lazy :)
373307Oh sorry my sense of humor is kinda weird, let me put it simply
BATTEN DOWN THE HATCHES AND PREPARE FOR IMPACT, INCOMING SHIT STORM TWELVE O'CLOCK
373323
Are you Discord?
373357No why do you ask (reclines into armchair drinking a glass of chocolate milk)
373369
Cuz during my last Stalinview he vanished, and you're talking like him
373388Perfect explanation for that.
....
42
(claps hads together and dissapears in cloud of confetti)
374758
Thanks!
I like where this story's going. The dialogue is a little confusing and choppy at times, but not hard to follow overall. tracking for certain. I'd love the see how the anti-elements interact with each other when they're all together.
Alright, the grammar and stuff like that doesn't bother me all that much, but I have noticed two things so far that bugged me (One in this chapter and one used in all three chapters so far)
The word Ironic and its other forms. I don't believe you are using that word correctly, and I also think you are using it a bit too often. For example:
“What ‘ave you done wiz gems of Clarity, godiche?!” he shouted in grief. “’ow could you transform such etalons of beauty and grace into THIS?”
The brown stallion looked at him ironically.
Here, you might have said with irritation or , and his annoyance was painted on his face.
These are just a couple of examples you could put in place of ironically. It just doesn't seen to fit in some places you used it to me. There are a few other places you used a form of irony that it didn't really fit, but this was one that bugged me the most.
As for my other comment, 'Applecut' vs 'Appleslice'. You had Claude's name as 'Applecut' for the first time it was mentioned, but the rest of the time his last name was 'Appleslice'. Consistency and all that.
Those being said, I am thoroughly interested in this fiction now. Nice work, Stalin. I'll be watching for more chapters from you. Keep up the great work.
I have 3 questions and a comment:
1. How did he get the darkness back in the box or did it become one with the gems?
2. Being that they are disharmonic, wouldn't the Doctor, need some way of keeping them harmonic in the sense of staying together, especially disloyalty?
3. What is the Doctor's intended goal for Equestria?
Another interesting chapter, I hope though not all of the anti-elements happen to be relatives of the Mane 6. That would just be annoying. The Apple family I can see since they are a massive family, but the rest seem to be in small families. But I am enjoying it thus far, just hoping didn't cry.
375657
Everything shall be answered soon. i don't want to soil. And thanks!
374924
Thanks!
375194
Thanks again!
377079
spoil :)
I like where this story is headed so far, I'm a little upset that I'm not the only one who had the idea of elements directly opposing the elements of harmony...
379757
Thanks!
I'm a little upset that I'm not the only one who had the idea of elements directly opposing the elements of harmony
Well, duh. It's a common thing in fumficton. But i am going a little further with it :)
I am also looking forward to the rest of this story. And if I can, I would almost like to thank you for the Antagonist stalking scene. If If they hadn't shown up I was afraid that a certain family member would take over the story, if only for a little while.
Interesting concept you've got here, I like the way the story is moving and its not a tough read, I can't wait to read more
382139
Curiouser and Curiouser...
I am liking your story so far, butme thinks Narcissus didn't think this one through. How are you going to use the elements of Disharmony, the very nature of Disharmony is not working well together.
I am also curios on what you interpret the opposite to the element of magic. I think it means the bond that is formed that goes beyond human understanding and logic aka 'magic' and the opposite of such a bond would be hard to describe.
Of course you can take it literal and its opposite would be SCIENCE
fc05.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/231/9/f/mad_little_pony___dr__insano_by_bebopanimebabe-d3dd8sw.jpg
391150
Science rules!! ALL HAIL INSANO!
By the way, you are partually correct, but not exatly. I shall explain it all later
396724
Dat's better, thanks! Wait for yer art
396985
Point is, Truth commitie and their special branchTruth Brigade are more compitent than lazy royal guards. They are almost only official group, acting outside of Equestria in their research, which fact making them to learn some combat tactics and abilities, because in some lands they coul'dnt survive without them.
Cauterium managed to stole all those artifacts partiallybecause he was a trusted member of Truth Commite and one of greatest members, called High Five, plus he was lead researcher. No one ever suspected that he would stole something from Garden of Truth. He had instant acess by the way. More on it later in a story
398994
The calling of Applejack's coat gamboge and her mane a pale lightish-grey olive threw me for a loop. I'd never heard Applejack being described as gamboge before, and you must be looking at a different mane, because I see a straw-blonde mane on Applejack and that does not look like any variation of an olive colouring.
Eh, i picked color right from wiki -_-'. And it is obvious that wiki makes mistakes...
The French pony I find pretty funny, although the use of 'dz' in place of a 'z' when coming up with the French accent in English is a little jarring. Neither the English or French employ use of 'dz' very much at all, so to some people the sound may be a little hard to imagine because of the extra 'duh' sound they would place before the 'z-uh'. I didn't find a problem with producing the sound, because I knew what you were going for, but just using a z would have worked just as well.
I picked accent by searching in google "How to do a french accent" -_-'
Thanks for review!
To be honest, i kinda dropped Stalinviewing your story cuz i thought you forgot about your part of a deal, but shall continue :)
Well now, I can see that a confrontation is about to begin. Rainbow Dash speeds away to warn Twilight!
Tracking.
May the Grace of the Valar Protect You
Shire Folk
399069
Oh, it's not Rainbow Dash :). It's a member of truth brigade
As for Azure... i dunno i just decided to replace her "s" with "z"'s
Btw next chapter is battle between Truth Brigade and Cauterium. Sort of confrontation in chap 5, actual in chap 6
muffins to u.
403175
I love muffins!
403343
This show dont tell stuff is hard to me to do in english, even though i am literature teacher -_-. Looks like i've read too many essays. But i have found the way around my inability to show most of the times
Anyway, thanks for your thoughts. I'll do as you said in my next upgrade
Alrighty! Time to dig into this.
The only real problem with this is that you switch from past to present tense as previously stated. Like instead of drowning in enjoyment. Rather more like the room's owner was drowning in enjoyment. Some words (next to none) were misused. Again going back to that one phrase the room's owner was drowning in mirth or pleasure. Missed a couple the's but that's just needling grammatical errors.
Overall, I'd say this is really shaping up to be a good story. But a bit of friendly advice between authors: always have a major/jawdropping plot twist at the end of every chapter. It'll make that sense of foreboding the reader gets better and It'll keep em coming back for more.
Overall, I'd rate this story 9/10. Clear premise, and good grammar.
405019
Thanks! I'll use your advise! You can ask for comission or stalinview now :)
The first thing I did this morning was wake up. The second thing I did was watch "Let's Plays" from JosefVStalin. Then I found this an I couldn't resist something written by Stalin. Stalin follows me around, he even is referenced by name in my fic. Nothing can stop Stalin! Shepard from saving the galaxy, what with his impeccable mustache and vague asian-ness.
Now onto my overly critical review, ho!
thoughtfully - There's that word again...
The room’s owner drowning in enjoyment. - conjunction junction, what's your function? This sentence needs "was" before "drowning" in order to make this a past tense sentence.
Narcissus calmed down instantly. Cauterium put a hoof on his face. - This is "Cau", I presume? You might want to clarify that just for posterity's sake.
“And it’s fine with me, because now we have one fewer moron to find.” - The comma is needed because "because" does not warrant it. Use commas to separate independent clauses when they are joined by any of these seven coordinating conjunctions: and, but, for, or, nor, so, yet. Common starter words for introductory clauses that should be followed by a comma include after, although, as, because, if, since, when, while. However, don't put a comma after the main clause when a dependent (subordinate) clause follows it (except for cases of extreme contrast). - So sayeth the Owl at Purdue. Because you are a teacher, I can presume you know this stuff like second nature, but I don't know how well commas apply in foreign tongues being that English is my main. Just in just, I've been more than a little condescending here to get my (agitated) point across.
‘Eh, Narcissus, Narcissus. You never change. As random as ever’, thought the brown stallion. - ignoring my own quote italics, thoughts are generally placed into italics to help distinguish them. It's not needed per se, but it's really recommended.
“How do you think I gonna find them?” he asked ironically - This sentence is weird and you improperly used irony. You need an "am" after "I", and irony doesn't make any sense in this context. Substitute "Rhetorically" for "Ironically".
“This is my newest toy” said Cauterium with pride. - Needs a comma after "toy". Wow, out of context, this sentence looks extremely weird.
“By dze way” Narcissus called “You have used ‘n'est-il pas’ wrong” - Ditto the above, you need a comma after "Way" and "Called".
Applejack kicked last apple tree with all her might - Needs a "The" after "Kicked".
making attractive play of colors. - You need an "an" after "Making".
A stallion called Claude Applecut was the most spiteful member of Apple family. His presence always put heavy pressure on all those around him, and his character was considered the worst possible fit for a member of the Apple Family. - Show, don't tell, dawg. In fact, this entire sentence is extraneous and makes everything look bad, I get enough show without you telling me he's so bad. Also, all Apple's are named after real apples or apple-based products. Simply having "Apple" in your not does not qualify you for the Apple family. But the case could be made against name, this is just how I see it.
Claude Appleslice suddenly realized that he been being followed. - You changed his name. His name! GAH! What foul magic betwixt thine most sacred eyes!
“I don’t understand what ‘re you talking about..." - Generally speaking, "Are you" is a question, whereas "You are" is a statement. His word choice is awkward as all hells. He needs to say "What you're talkin' about..." Mkay? Accent and proper word phrasing is my assistance.
"...Penury” said Cauterium with ridicule “We are not here to talk about your habits" - Commas, commas, and a peirod galore! After "Penury" and "Ridicule" you'll need commas. You have a slight issue with them, it seems. You also need a period after "Habits".
We are sharing same ideals, you and i… - Awkward phrasing, and you need to capitalize "i".
Narcissus conducted receding blue pegasus. - I don't even know what this sentence was trying to mean.
Final thoughts: This is not a bad story, I'm just overly critical. The premise and the execution feels like it would be a reasonable two-part episode for the actual show. The plot is straight from the mind of the writers. The chapters feel a little anemic, but that's not really a bad thing, yet I've written single dialogues that were longer than your whole story. I can't say anything truly bad about it, but yet I'm at a loss to find too many outstanding things in either direction. I like this, a lot. It's a dang episode made fanfic. It needs polish, lots of polish, but it's a good story. It just needs a few rounds of self-edits, I'd be happy to help you out if you'd like. This has all the marking of something fantastic, it just needs some more spit-polish.
Can I give it a rating 1-10 rating? No. I "thumbs up"ed this story, but to truly appreciate it I think it needs more time to develop. Tracked and liked, but I still think it needs that oil and spit to truly shine.
406829
Wow, fellow ruler, thank you very much! Things like this are all what good ol' Stalin needs! I am in your depth!
By the way, i know i have problem with comas. I learned english mainly from VOICED video games (that's why i am talking almost pure american english), but my grammar sux -_-' I am trying to comprehend commas like i did in my language and i ALWAYS confused, cuz sometimes Russian and English comma placement is similliar, and sometimes not. Also, Russian has 3 tenses (present, past, future) while English have NINE (present perfect, present simple ect...) -_-. I was really unlucky at school learning French language instead of english.
Oh, thank you again! I am in your depth! If you want, i can make any art for you or make a Stalinview of your stories
406883
I wasn't aware we had so many tense, actually? We don't even have a proper future tense, just a weird way of phrasing things in the present. I'm good a English, so says my friends at least. One of my pastimes is helping out newer writers, especially those whose first language is not English (I've done so with a Hungarian and a Swede). Your grammar is still surprisingly well for someone whose third language is English, I can hardly conjugate in my second language, Español (Más más más, por favor. Entre tus piernas llevo). My other non-native-English-speaking friends have more issues during their stories (to the point where I completely rewrote a few of their chapters), but it's to be expected. I'll be here hounding your tales from hereon in. Hay-o!
For notes of commas: Owl at Purdue - I still found that helpful, and I've been speaking English since before I would walk!
Also, it's "debt", not "depth". :p
407633
Thanks!
Alright, time for my review!
I have to say, so far you've crafted a very interesting story! Only three chapters in and I'm excited to see what happens next! You've given some character to your OC's which is good, as that is what they often lack. Narcissus is an interesting character, and I enjoy the way you write him. I think you're strongest in dialogue, as you've written several very funny scenes.
Now, if I could offer some criticism and advice. The first two chapters were written in present tense, and while that can work, past tense usually works much better as you can convey emotions much easier. It's also a lot less awkward looking. From what I see you have changed to past tense in the third chapter, which is good. Stick with it.
You describe scenes very well, but only at the beginning. After that you just focus on the characters and the dialogue, which makes the reader forget about the setting. You should throw in a few more descriptive sentences to help remind the reader where they are, not to mention it helps paint a better picture in their head.
You also don't seem to use the characters names that often, simply referring to them as *insert colour and stallion/mare here* While this can be good once in awhile, when you use it constantly like you do it makes it hard to keep track of whose talking, and that's the last thing you want your readers to feel during a scene.
I've also noticed quite a few mistakes.
Chapter 1
“When it shall be ready?" = "When shall it be ready?"
Why she want to be with him? = Why did she want to be with him?
Spike rushed toward trash can faster than he should have. = Spike rushed toward the trash can faster than he should have.
Chapter 2
Narcissus looked around him, noticing heavy layer of dust. = Narcissus looked around him, noticing a heavy layer of dust.
only god knows what he’s going to do with it” = only Celestia knows what he’s going to do with it”
Chapter 3
Applejack kicked last apple tree with all her might, = Applejack kicked the last apple tree with all her might,
“Perfume? What are ya? A girl?” = “Perfume? What are ya? A mare?”
Don't get me wrong, you've got a wonderful story on your whooves and I'm sure its only going to get better. But please consider what I've said, and I would suggest getting a pre-reader as you have quite a few little mistakes.
I'll be eagerly awaiting seeing you (and Discord!) review one of my stories!
410025
“Perfume? What are ya? A girl?” = “Perfume? What are ya? A mare?”
Word "girl" exist in ponyverse. Twilight said "girls" multiple times during the show
Thanks for a review! You want stalinview with Discord - you got it!
Also, i don't want Cauterium or some of his crew to say "Celestia" as a god. Cuz they are going to fight her, and it shall be illogical to worship her for them
All Glory to Glorious Premier!!!
It is a wonderful story. I definitely enjoyed the anti elements. I thought that it was a wonderful way to bring about a little chaos!
I was wondering where you came up with the ideas for their names. Narcsicssus? Azure Knowledge? Genius!