AWKWARD: Being a normal guy and having Cadance switch bodies with you. BAD: Being sent to Equestria in her body. REALLY BAD: Shining thinks you're actually his wife. REALLY, REALLY BAD: He tells you he wants kids!
2795141 I know, I really wanted to take that somewhere, but it's just really hard. I like following the protagonist day by day as they start to accept their new role, and for pregnancy elements you really need like a "SEVEN MONTHS LATER" time jump which sort of ruins the flow.
But if it makes you feel any better, in this story line I totally have them set to have kids. The clop scene that takes place right after the story ends is supposed to result in a pregnancy. I was actually going to include another scene and bring that up, but it ended up feeling too tacked on so I cut the story where it ends now. But yeah, it totally happens in this universe
2795149 Well all is forgiven then! I mean if you're going to end up going from a human male to a pretty pink pony princess, then you might as well go all the way and get pregnant too! And so the cycle is complete!
And best of all, they lived much more happily ever after.
great ending, shocking twist with Shining, although i would be interested just to see maybe a paragraph or two to show what happens to 'real' Cadence in the human world brilliant premise for the story, i hope you keep doing stories like this it has definitely been a very good read and very well written, you get a happy pony here i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/120/393/PinkiePieAwesomeness.jpg
2795157 Human Cadence was later arrested for showing in public, fined 4000 in court for the offense and later added another 6000 for various. Two days after the court she is again arrested, this time for assaulting an officer and spend a week in jail plus another 10000. She is evicted during that time because she had no money for rent and including bills and fines she's now indebted 24000 with no means to pay. Dumped on the streets she starts stealing and robbing to get food for the day, where she one month later get's arrested at a bank robbery and spend six months in jail.
The down spiral continues in jail and multiple sessions in isolation plus several fights keeps her inside for another year before she's let out. After said jail time the first thing she did was drink herself (himself) plastered, found a knife somewhere and somehow killed four people before he passed out. Got lifetime in jail.
2795242 I don't even know if I kept Cadence in character, but from the little we've seen it might as well be it. My only remaining question is exactly what did Sweetie Bell agree to?
Celestia: "Hello Sweetie would you like to help me pretend to be an alien trying to invade Equestria I throw in a cage and ask Cadence to come here so she can confess?"
2795247 probably more along the lines of: 'Hey Sweetie Belle, would you like to practice acting by pretending that i have captured you so i can expose this pony who is an imposter, it will be fun and you will be in no danger whatsoever, you might even get your cutie mark' or it could be just this: media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lo1b0z5WGb1qidxg0.png and get her to agree
You know I wish I could do what twisted spectrum does. And that is to make awesome stories I mean hell royal duties awesome five score divided by four awesome.
Ending was a bit abrupt, and I find it hard to believe Cadance was as bitchy as Shiny was describing her. I had the impression she kept up a nice solid facade around others until this last bit, actually. Would've been more emotional if Shiny had to come to terms with his wife being a total bitch in the few moments he had to decide which one to toss back through the portal.
Also half-expected the hero of the story to open the portal and see Cadance wearing an orange jumpsuit and say "Yeah-fuckno." right there.
All told, not a bad bit of clop, but it could've been a little better. This last chapter especially seemed really rushed, and it doesn't look like you even ran it past the pre-readers. Ah well, this being done means we get the next chapter of Five Score, which is good.
2795208 I have to agree. The story as a whole was great, but the "real Cadance" parts just left my rolling my eyes at how much of an over the top bitch she was.
2795149 Yeah, a time skip would ruin the flow. Also, not sure if you knew this, but equine pregnancy is eleven months, not nine, so seven months would probably be a bit short for a time skip in this circumstance.
Perhaps a several-years later epilogue? I also kinda want to learn what ended up happening to the old Cadence. I imagine her next day was seriously upsetting, and I can also see her ending up in prison...
that was interesting. Very very very very very *ten minutes later* very very very very very, VERY interesting.... just realized something... I want an epilogue of former cadence when she he wakes up
This was an utterly, utterly bizarre story. And yeah, I loved it.
The protagonist's willingness to accept such a massive, unexpected change in his life and learn to find joy in an existence he never wanted is a good theme, I think. A lot of stuff happens to us in life that we can't predict or control, but by and large we still have plenty of opportunities to be happy if we can simply accept it. Getting turned into a girl, and a pony no less... well, is that such a bad thing really? You're just exchanging one set of genitalia for another. General rule of thumb for life: If it makes you happy and it hurts no-one, just roll with it.
The only sticking point that bugs me a bit is Old Cadence. It's true that she's pretty massively out of character, but I can file that under suspension of disbelief because it's pretty much the premise of the whole fic; if Cadence isn't a bitch, the story doesn't work. That's not really what she's like, but I can accept it as a 'what-if' so that we can have a story at all. The thing that WOULD actually bother me in the protag's shoes is the moral ambiguity of assuming Cadence's role just like that; whether she was a bitch or not, whether she ran off or not, it was still HER life and I'm not so sure about just taking it from her and leaving her stranded.
Still, overall I thoroughly approve of this story and the direction it took. Transformation stories are always fascinating, and I do love me some good feels / happy endings, which were certainly provided here.
nice story if you ever decided it could be even better with a possible sequel but the choice is ultimately yours to make in that regards i am just giving my opinion
Not bad. This fic certainly aids in helping me write my own TF story... Though a few more pointers from the writer personally would be nice. However, something tells me that a mediocre fanfic wouldn't be much to his liking. Why waste his time with something so trivial and downright bland that it hurts to even read it? Oh well...
Anyhow, quite an interesting twist that you put in here. Wonder how "Cadence" shall deal with the foals though.
love it. while i agree that an epilogue of old cadence/new human guy (i dont even know his name, or remember if it was ever said in the first place) waking up to realize s/he is stuck like that FOREVER!
She has the be, the story literally wouldn't have made any sense if she was a perfect loving pony. I wanted to make a clopfic where there is a forced TF/TG and the protagonist is dumped in Equestria and suddenly has to play the role of wife and not let anyone know what happened. For that to happen, Cadance has to be pretty damn mean, I mean... - She had to be mean enough to leave her husband for a few days without even leaving him a note telling him that a human was taking her place. - She had to be mean enough to steal some poor human's body without asking if he wanted to be a pony. - She had to be mean enough that Shining (and Celestia) would tell the protagonist that he should keep her body and replace her. - She had to be mean enough that the protagonist wouldn't feel totally horrible for just outright stealing her body and her life!
So yeah, I mean literally the entire story requires the former wife to be pretty cold hearted. On reflection, I should have just used an OC instead of Cadance. I suppose that would have made much more sense. But I don't know, personally I wouldn't have found an OC couple as interesting as using the canon couple, but from your replies I'm thinking making Cadance so OOC might have been a slight mistake Oh well, shit's done, Cadance is OOC
Oh no, like I said, I understand completely. And I'm not complaining. It's the premise of the fic. I DO think it's quite out of character for Cadence, but I can deal with that, and it was a fun ride.
2795202>>2795250>>2795454>>2795516>>2795561>>2795689>>2795731>>2796174 I guess you guys have spoken. I'm not going to write any direct sequels, but I'll write a short epilogue. Expect in sometime early next week
2795247 Lone Spartan answered this pretty well. Celestia probably knows Sweetie Belle as the little sister of one of the Elements of Harmony. Rarity probably mentioned one day how Sweetie Bell was taking acting classes (slight FiW reference btw, Sweetie following in Rarity's footsteps) so Celestia sent her a letter asking if she wanted to play a fun role for her. 2795230 I'm assuming she started off happy and lovingly, but she got mean over the years. I sort of mention this when Celestia says “I like Cadance, but she’s been so incredibly bitter these past few years.". I guess that infers she wasn't always this mean.
Ahahahahaha. Old-Cadance got served. We never did find out if they got to have the kids they wanted, though! Saddest-of-faces. :(
2795141 I know, I really wanted to take that somewhere, but it's just really hard. I like following the protagonist day by day as they start to accept their new role, and for pregnancy elements you really need like a "SEVEN MONTHS LATER" time jump which sort of ruins the flow.
But if it makes you feel any better, in this story line I totally have them set to have kids. The clop scene that takes place right after the story ends is supposed to result in a pregnancy. I was actually going to include another scene and bring that up, but it ended up feeling too tacked on so I cut the story where it ends now. But yeah, it totally happens in this universe
2795149 Well all is forgiven then! I mean if you're going to end up going from a human male to a pretty pink pony princess, then you might as well go all the way and get pregnant too! And so the cycle is complete!
And best of all, they lived much more happily ever after.
Bitch Cadance gets what she deserves.
great ending, shocking twist with Shining, although i would be interested just to see maybe a paragraph or two to show what happens to 'real' Cadence in the human world
brilliant premise for the story, i hope you keep doing stories like this
it has definitely been a very good read and very well written, you get a happy pony here
i2.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/original/000/120/393/PinkiePieAwesomeness.jpg
are you going to write an epilogue/sequel
Cadance is too OOC in this fic
Why did Shining marry Cadence in the first place?
2795157
Human Cadence was later arrested for showing in public, fined 4000 in court for the offense and later added another 6000 for various. Two days after the court she is again arrested, this time for assaulting an officer and spend a week in jail plus another 10000. She is evicted during that time because she had no money for rent and including bills and fines she's now indebted 24000 with no means to pay. Dumped on the streets she starts stealing and robbing to get food for the day, where she one month later get's arrested at a bank robbery and spend six months in jail.
The down spiral continues in jail and multiple sessions in isolation plus several fights keeps her inside for another year before she's let out. After said jail time the first thing she did was drink herself (himself) plastered, found a knife somewhere and somehow killed four people before he passed out. Got lifetime in jail.
There I made that up just now, happy?
2795239
it did, it brought a tear to my eye
media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m4vmi617j51qj3ir1.gif
2795242
I don't even know if I kept Cadence in character, but from the little we've seen it might as well be it. My only remaining question is exactly what did Sweetie Bell agree to?
Celestia: "Hello Sweetie would you like to help me pretend to be an alien trying to invade Equestria I throw in a cage and ask Cadence to come here so she can confess?"
It just doesn't work for me.
Bravo. Another masterpiece of literature written by your hooves TwistedSpectrum
Sequel?
2795247
probably more along the lines of:
'Hey Sweetie Belle, would you like to practice acting by pretending that i have captured you so i can expose this pony who is an imposter, it will be fun and you will be in no danger whatsoever, you might even get your cutie mark'
or it could be just this:
media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lo1b0z5WGb1qidxg0.png
and get her to agree
2795257 Imagine Sweetie's face when she hears the conversation that follows her release.
We both know I'm not Cadence -> from a very Cadence-looking pony.
2795260
3.bp.blogspot.com/-nHeB3pmzL-o/TuENNcBtK2I/AAAAAAAABdA/E3EHlZhjzhY/s1600/mlp_wat.jpg
and
24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m1vrth9EwD1r5xzspo1_500.gif
This is now one of my top 5 favorite fics or clop fics or whatever you get the point.
You know I wish I could do what twisted spectrum does. And that is to make awesome stories I mean hell royal duties awesome five score divided by four awesome.
Ending was a bit abrupt, and I find it hard to believe Cadance was as bitchy as Shiny was describing her. I had the impression she kept up a nice solid facade around others until this last bit, actually. Would've been more emotional if Shiny had to come to terms with his wife being a total bitch in the few moments he had to decide which one to toss back through the portal.
Also half-expected the hero of the story to open the portal and see Cadance wearing an orange jumpsuit and say "Yeah-fuckno." right there.
All told, not a bad bit of clop, but it could've been a little better. This last chapter especially seemed really rushed, and it doesn't look like you even ran it past the pre-readers. Ah well, this being done means we get the next chapter of Five Score, which is good.
2795208
I have to agree. The story as a whole was great, but the "real Cadance" parts just left my rolling my eyes at how much of an over the top bitch she was.
that was an adorable story, well done sir!
Sequel?
I whont more
2795149
if you make it an Epilogue then the flow isn't broken.
Indeed.
Just.. indeed.
I loved this story - I wish I had more to say, but all that I can come up with is "awesome"
If I could give this story 5 stars, I would give 6.
2795149
Dddduuuudddeeee, epilogue! Pregnant pony sex, c'mon!
This story would have totally worked as a non clop fic
kudos for one amazing story!
2795149 Agreed! Pregnancy Epilogue! XD And keep up the good work. Loved Five Score as well. XD
2795149
Yeah, a time skip would ruin the flow. Also, not sure if you knew this, but equine pregnancy is eleven months, not nine, so seven months would probably be a bit short for a time skip in this circumstance.
2795149
Perhaps a several-years later epilogue? I also kinda want to learn what ended up happening to the old Cadence. I imagine her next day was seriously upsetting, and I can also see her ending up in prison...
Shining Armor in this finale:
[youtube=DnOIvn8hMS4]
that was interesting. Very very very very very *ten minutes later* very very very very very, VERY interesting....
just realized something...
I want an epilogue of former cadence when
shehe wakes upThis was an utterly, utterly bizarre story. And yeah, I loved it.
The protagonist's willingness to accept such a massive, unexpected change in his life and learn to find joy in an existence he never wanted is a good theme, I think. A lot of stuff happens to us in life that we can't predict or control, but by and large we still have plenty of opportunities to be happy if we can simply accept it. Getting turned into a girl, and a pony no less... well, is that such a bad thing really? You're just exchanging one set of genitalia for another. General rule of thumb for life: If it makes you happy and it hurts no-one, just roll with it.
The only sticking point that bugs me a bit is Old Cadence. It's true that she's pretty massively out of character, but I can file that under suspension of disbelief because it's pretty much the premise of the whole fic; if Cadence isn't a bitch, the story doesn't work. That's not really what she's like, but I can accept it as a 'what-if' so that we can have a story at all. The thing that WOULD actually bother me in the protag's shoes is the moral ambiguity of assuming Cadence's role just like that; whether she was a bitch or not, whether she ran off or not, it was still HER life and I'm not so sure about just taking it from her and leaving her stranded.
Still, overall I thoroughly approve of this story and the direction it took. Transformation stories are always fascinating, and I do love me some good feels / happy endings, which were certainly provided here.
nice story if you ever decided it could be even better with a possible sequel but the choice is ultimately yours to make in that regards i am just giving my opinion
Nice ending. That is all.
Plot twist: The human was the real Cadance all along!
2795149
im just wondering now, do you dislike Cadence or was that just for the purpose of making the story the epic adventure it was?
I love this happy ending!!!
Love and sex conquers all!!!
Not bad. This fic certainly aids in helping me write my own TF story...
Though a few more pointers from the writer personally would be nice. However, something tells me that a mediocre fanfic wouldn't be much to his liking.
Why waste his time with something so trivial and downright bland that it hurts to even read it?
Oh well...
Anyhow, quite an interesting twist that you put in here.
Wonder how "Cadence" shall deal with the foals though.
This was awesome, expected it to run for a bit more though.
love it. while i agree that an epilogue of old cadence/new human guy (i dont even know his name, or remember if it was ever said in the first place) waking up to realize s/he is stuck like that FOREVER!
2795230
2795294
2795305
2795736
2795969
2795208
She has the be, the story literally wouldn't have made any sense if she was a perfect loving pony. I wanted to make a clopfic where there is a forced TF/TG and the protagonist is dumped in Equestria and suddenly has to play the role of wife and not let anyone know what happened. For that to happen, Cadance has to be pretty damn mean, I mean...
- She had to be mean enough to leave her husband for a few days without even leaving him a note telling him that a human was taking her place.
- She had to be mean enough to steal some poor human's body without asking if he wanted to be a pony.
- She had to be mean enough that Shining (and Celestia) would tell the protagonist that he should keep her body and replace her.
- She had to be mean enough that the protagonist wouldn't feel totally horrible for just outright stealing her body and her life!
So yeah, I mean literally the entire story requires the former wife to be pretty cold hearted. On reflection, I should have just used an OC instead of Cadance. I suppose that would have made much more sense. But I don't know, personally I wouldn't have found an OC couple as interesting as using the canon couple, but from your replies I'm thinking making Cadance so OOC might have been a slight mistake
Oh well, shit's done, Cadance is OOC
2796333
Oh no, like I said, I understand completely. And I'm not complaining. It's the premise of the fic. I DO think it's quite out of character for Cadence, but I can deal with that, and it was a fun ride.
2795202>>2795250>>2795454>>2795516>>2795561>>2795689>>2795731>>2796174
I guess you guys have spoken. I'm not going to write any direct sequels, but I'll write a short epilogue.
Expect in sometime early next week
2795247
Lone Spartan answered this pretty well. Celestia probably knows Sweetie Belle as the little sister of one of the Elements of Harmony. Rarity probably mentioned one day how Sweetie Bell was taking acting classes (slight FiW reference btw, Sweetie following in Rarity's footsteps) so Celestia sent her a letter asking if she wanted to play a fun role for her.
2795230
I'm assuming she started off happy and lovingly, but she got mean over the years. I sort of mention this when Celestia says “I like Cadance, but she’s been so incredibly bitter these past few years.". I guess that infers she wasn't always this mean.
Uhhhh.... Interesting to say the least... Very different from other Human in Equestria stories I've read