A playdate to Silver Spoon's house leads to an uncovering of what may be one of Ponyville's most horrific tragedies. The young foal known as Silver Spoon is missing, as is her family, and all are presumed dead...
It was a simple investigation of a shootout. A heat of the moment killing...but it led to the discovery of a horror unforseen: the slow, starving death of a foal...Sheriff Applejack's first great case.