Starlight Glimmer's life implodes when Trixie dumps her, but Sunset Shimmer is there to help pick up the pieces. Starlight may need a friend, but how far is Sunset willing for their relationship to go?
Trixie has finally gathered enough courage to ask Starlight to marry her, so she asks Sunburst to choose a ring for her proposal. However, Starlight has other plans in mind.
"I cut, you pick" is the time-honored rule for sharing treats. But what if a pony is sharing love with two others? When Maud brings one big brownie home to Trixie and Starlight, they have to figure that out.