The Student Six have their first Nightmare Night, Gallus volunteers to take part of a magic trick in which involves an artifact haunts him. Even after the show was drawn to a close.
Angel Bunny makes Fluttershy go out on Nightmare Night when she would rather stay at home, but a chivalrous Bat Pony soon brings a blush to her cheeks. Even Zephyr Breeze inadvertently helps bring the couple together and somepony gets a new hairdo!