The Equestrian Critics Society (Dead) 1,058 members · 1,075 stories

-=[The Equestrian Critics Society]=-

The best place on the site for quality reviews and critiques, guaranteed.

Looking to get your story in the review cycle? Here's the place to line-up!

[Currently Full and Locked]

Reviewer Applications
Want to have the cool status of being a TECS-class reviewer? Click here to find out how!

These are the rules for both requests and forum posts. Super important that you check them out!

-=[Current Events]=-

We've brought on another admin, who will be focused on organization and overall management. Please welcome Smiles!

In other news, I am looking at changing our rating system. Because our reviewers and members aren't always on skype, I feel that posting a forum post would get more input than direct messages or skype.

I am looking at making this a rating based group, out of necessity and in part due to the demand for guiding reviews that rarely seem to be received as detailed critiques but more as a general rating...

Click here to read more!

-=[Fic of the Month]=-

April 2014


Comments ( 187 )
  • Viewing 168 - 187 of 187

Whos willing to initiate a twenty one gun salute?

Just dropping by to pay respect

Oh, alright then, kinda sad, but it happens I guess...

Professor Plum
Story Approver

The original founder bailed, the backlog built up, reviewers burnt out, and the admins brought in by the founder to fix his group were too little too late, simply put.

What happened?
I hope nothing along the lines of which happened to Twilight's Library...

hey! um i need some help on my story pls help ill do anything just tell me what i need to do

Professor Plum
Story Approver

This group has been pretty much dead for a long time.

381681 I've noticed a lot of groups sitewide have substantially diminished in activity since February and March, even large ones like this.

Out of curiosity, is the group still active? There doesn't seem to be much forum activity going on, and the "Fic of the Month" box above is from six months ago …

Anyone willing to review my Fan-Fic?

It's just a story about my OC's daily life at a magic academy in Canterlot. This is my first fan-fic, so any advice will be appreciated.

Anyone want to read my story? It's called Oneway Ticket to a Dead End and it doesn't have many views, or a review. :applecry:

I need some positive feedback to build on.

Hello I was wondering if someone would like to take a look at my fic and tell me if they like it or not

Hello all. I was hoping I could get some assistance with my fic, The World They Once Knew. I would like to see it improved and I need to know where to start on that. So, if there is anyone who can or would like to do so, send me your thoughts please.

Comment posted by Princess Maxii deleted Jul 18th, 2015
Comment posted by Princess Maxii deleted Sep 3rd, 2014

If I could get some feedback on my misfits story it would be great

I know no one will see this but I have to try
"magic in the stars" by Australian chaos is a amazing story that will touch your heart. Please read it

If you have the time can someone review this got a few likes making sure this was not a flukeyou can always trust me also my newest story if you want this won't be easy

I have an incomplete comedy story that I'd like to be reviewed by someone. I have editors already that have also critiqued it, but i would also like at least one "proffesional" opinion, persay, before continuing as it is. Where can i submit the story for critiquing later on(I undertand the queue is full currently)?


  • Viewing 168 - 187 of 187