Author's Notes:
Thanks to Deadinlight for beta-reading and helping me edit
Chapter Seven: The Story of the Past Part Three
~ ~ ~
“[…] Don’t worry, Silver Hoof, I’ll be fine, I don’t want you to wait for me, find some other mare to make you happy […]”
~ ~ ~
Bright Star gave the colt a kiss goodnight as they made it back to her house.
“Thank you Silver Hoof, I enjoyed the date, See you next week?” asked the sixteen year old filly and Silver Hoof just nodded blushing and Bright Star giggled before she nuzzled him gently and made her way back into the house...
- - -
Over the course of the next few weeks Bright Star and Silver Hoof grew closer and in secret Bright Star grew more skilled in the dark magic she could get her hooves on. Until one day…
“Let my coltfriend go, Heavy Heart!” snapped Bright Star angrily as the more Athletic colt held Silver Hoof up by his hoof against his neck.
“Why in Celestia’s name would you date this nerd? I could give you so much more” said Heavy Heart and Bright Star snarled at the stallion.
“Oh yes, a broken heart after you have bucked the living daylights out of my flank! I heard all about you, Heavy Heart, and I will not be some conquest, and my coltfriend is not an open target” said the angry mare as she started to charge her horn, sure she would get in trouble, but it would be worth it to get him away from her coltfriend.
“Heavy Heart! You put that colt down, right now! You have just earned yourself detention!”
- - -
It went on like that for months, gradually escalating to the point where Bright Star actually used magic to pull the bigger colt away from her coltfriend, slamming him against the lockers and was about to beat him when she was given detention. When she tried to defend herself she was told that it didn’t excuse her reaction and she gritted her teeth and stormed out of the headmaster’s office, slamming the door behind her knocking paintings and diploma’s off the walls…
- - -
It happened one night when Bright Star was on a date with Silver Hoof, at the theater for the second time, she pressed her lips against his and used her tongue to demand entrance to his mouth, the nerdish coltfriend of hers melting into the kiss as she started to stroke his face with a hoof. It didn’t manage to get any farther as the moment she attempted to go farther she was blinked out of the theater and in front of Heavy Heart who was looking at her lecherously.
“I knew you were a slut, and couldn’t wait to buck again” said the colt and Bright Star gritted her teeth as she recognized the voice and figure in front of her.
“What the-? Heavy Heart? Where the buck is my coltfriend?” Asked Bright Star as she reoriented herself and tried to stand only for Heavy to push down on her with his forehooves.
“Now, now, no need to get up, the fun is just starting.” the colt’s choice of words set off warning bells in the blind mare’s head, and she shot up her horn sparking angrily.
“What do you want, Heavy Heart? And if you say-”
“Oh it isn't a matter of what I want, it's a matter of what you want. I take it you don't want something to happen to your nerd of a coltfriend.” Bright Star stiffened, he was going to threaten Silver Hoof? She shook her head worriedly as the colt got behind her and shoved his nose in her marehood making the mare jump in surprise, before bucking Heavy Heart in the face breaking his nose, shoving the bone straight up into his brain. As soon as she did, she blinked again and reappeared in the theater just as Silver Hoof returned to grab his things and help look for her.
“Bright Star! What hap—Bright Star? Is everything alright?” asked Silver Hoof as Bright Star suddenly nuzzled against the colt as if she needed to know she was safe.
“Just be quiet and take me home, I need my daddy” said the filly and Silver Hoof nodded as he walked out of the theater and announced that he found her before taking the filly home…
- - -
When they made it to the door of her home she used her magic to pull her coltfriend into a kiss, as if to make sure he was still there, she wrapped her hooves around his neck and held him in place as tears ran down her face as what nearly happened hit her with the full force of a freight train.
“D-did you want to come upstairs?” asked Bright Star nervously and Silver Hoof looked at her confused but nodded as she nervously led him into her house and up the stairs to her room, her parents not at home due to the current meeting of Nobles at Canterlot Castle. As soon as they were at the door to her room she shed the clothes causing the colt to blush a bit as, although ponies walking nude was a normal thing, the clothing she was wearing underneath the dress was very naughty. She shed those as well before turning to Silver Hoof. “Heavy Heart tried to have his way with me…” she said suddenly making the blush on Silver Hoof deepen, but from anger rather than embarrassment as his expression grew angry but before he could say, or do anything he felt Bright Star’s lips against his once more. “I want you to help me forget…” she said as she run a hoof on his upper chest…
- - -
She woke up a few hours later, her colt—No, her former coltfriend… She wasn’t going to have him wait for her, because Bright Star was dead. She couldn’t go by that name anymore, she had killed, there were not that many crimes in Equestria that were heavily punished in Equestria, murder was one of them, even Tenebrosus Magus were treated less harshly than murderers… Maybe that was it. She would become a Tenebrosus Magus, but that leaved the issue of a name… Maybe…
- - -
“It was after that I chose to become a Tenebrosus Magus, and take up the name Shadow Eyes” said Shadow Eyes as she sipped at her coffee, Rich Quick had given her after inviting her inside and offering her a drink.
“You mentioned that you weren’t having him wait for you… It sounds like you loved him” said Rich Quick as he drank his own coffee.
“I do, I did, but I couldn’t ask him to wait for me when I knew he wouldn’t be able to go with me, and I couldn’t do that to him. He deserves a mare that would be a good wife for him, and mother of his foals…” she said wistfully before Rich Quick got up and walked around his coffee table and sat next to her before putting a fore leg over her and pulling her into a comforting hug causing the mare to break down and cry into his shoulder. “I loved him, I gave him something I can never get back, and by now he probably doesn’t even remember me. I am probably, at best, the filly he slept with while still at Celestia’s School For Gifted Unicorns”
“How did you break up with him? I mean, how did you tell him to not wait for you?” asked Rich Quick as he tried to think of a way to comfort her.
“I-” she sniffed, “I left him a letter, saying that I had to leave, that I did something horrible to somepony else, that it was better this way, to not look for me, that he was better off without me. That I loved him and that he would forever hold a place in my heart, but not to wait for me”
“He won’t forget you… Unless I am seriously mistaken he probably has that letter still, and he tried to wait for you for a while but after a while he realized you weren’t coming back…” he said pulling away before pressing his lips to her forehead just below her horn causing the mare to shudder as pleasurable feelings rushed from her horn to her brain, he noticed this and, apologized thinking he had overstepped his bounds.
“Don’t worry about it, you don’t know how I see” said the mare before suddenly pressing her lips to his. “Thank you for listening to a mare reminisce on her past”