Supernatural Ponies 1: Welcome to Equestria: Here's a Case

by SwiftStroke


Summoned

Sam, Dean, Bobby, Castiel, and Twilight finally finished repairing the library. They were all tired, exhausted, and proud of a job well done.
"Hoo boy!" Said Dean enthusiastically. "That was refreshing! Looks like everybo- excuse me, everyPONY needs to do some hard work every once-in-a-while. Well, it's gettin' late. You got any hotels in this place?"
"In fact, we do! There's one over by the town hall. Sorry I didn't mention it. I assumed you four at least rented a place before coming here."
"It's alright." Castiel told her. " Just wondering, do we have to pay for a room?"
"Yes you do, but I'll give you some bits. About enough to live here for a week. You'll probably be able to find a job by then."
"Thank you very much. I suppose it's time we head that way. Goodbye Twilight."
"Bye."
"See ya."
"Later."
"Bye guys!" Twilight waved them goodbye and the four newcomers trotted off towards the hotel. Dean slapped three bits on the front desk and lead the rest of group towards the room(211).


The next morning, Sam and Castiel heard a knock on the door. Sam woke up early and Castiel never sleeps.
"Dean, Bobby wake up." Sam said. No response. "Dean! Bobby! Wake up!" No response. Sam inhaled. "DEAN!! BOBBY!! WAKE THE HELL UP DAMMIT!"'
"AAAAHHH!! WHAT THE F-" Dean began.
"Someone's knocking."
"Oh."
"That's no reason to wake us up you God damn idgit!" Bobby yelled. Sam rolled his eyes at this and headed toward the door. He opened it(with a bit of an astonished look when he defied the laws of physics by opening the door with his hoof) and found Twilight Sparkle, levitating a letter.
"Here. Read this. It's important." Ordered the purple Unicorn with a very serious expression. She opened it and let Sam read it.

Dear Twilight, my faithful student,

I've noticed you have some new residents in Ponyville. They appeared seemingly out of nowhere inside a strange carriage if I am not mistaken. It may not seem like it, but these ponies are very important. They have been led here by destiny so that they could assist us. Something strange is going on in Equestria, and they are the only ponies that can help. You and your friends must bring them to Luna, Candance, and me in Canterlot. We need to speak to all ten of you. Please come as soon as possible.

Princess Celestia

"Well, guys. Pack up. We're heading to Canterlot." Sam ordered.
"Sam. Where's Canterlot?" Dean asked.



Twilight told Sam, Dean, Bobby, and Castiel to meet at the train station at 1:00 p.m. on the dot. Sam suggested they leave earlier than they originally intended; Twilight never showed them where the station is. She most likely assumed that they came on train and borrowed the Impala from someone in Ponyville. She didn't know anyone who would own such an item, but then again, she didn't know ALL the ponies in Ponyville.
The four foreign ponies found the train station and arrived just about when Twilight told them to. The purple Unicorn and the rest of her friends were waiting for them.
"THEY'RE HERE! THEY'RE HERE! HI GUYS!" Pinkie Pie yelled as soon as she witnessed Sam's front hoof come into view. The Mane 6 immediately turned to where Pinkie's hoof directed.
"So. That's what they look like." Applejack stated with a somewhat disgusted look on her face.
"Applejack, why did you say that with 'that' look on your face? Show some respect!" Rarity said angrily.
"No, no. They look fine. It's just . . . their cutie marks. They're so gosh darn weird."
"I'd have to agree." Fluttershy muttered, just loud enough for her friends to barely hear. "Bobby has a shotgun, Sam and Dean have the same cutie mark, and I don't even know what it's supposed to mean or what it is. And don't even get me started on Castiel. His personality and his cutie mark are more mysterious than Derpy's mind, and that thing is odd."
"SHH!" Rainbow Dash shushed. "They're almost here! We can worry about this later, and I thought Zecora taught us a LONG time ago to 'Not judge the cover of the book'. Don't throw that out the friggin' window!" Soon after Rainbow gave her piece of wisdom for the day, the four reached the train station, and introduced themselves to the ponies they had not met during the tour. They talked about what Canterlot is like, what the trains are like, and what the ponies there are like. Soon, the train arrived and the ten ponies boarded.


Everypony finally arrived at Canterlot. The ride went fairly quickly for Dean considering he was still tired and went to sleep.
"This is Canterlot, boys!" Twilight shouted with her right, front hoof raised and moving side to side. Sam, Dean, Bobby, and Castiel looked around at the big city. They didn't have much time, so everypony stopped staring and headed out towards the castle.
By sunset, all ten of them had entered the large, towering building, where they were graciously welcomed by the royal guard. Their captain and Twilight's brother, Shining Armor, escorted them to where three princesses resided.
"We're glad you could make it." Celestia, Luna, and Cadance said in unison.
"It's no problem at all!" Twilight said with a gargantuan smile plastered on her face. "Why did you call us and these four here?"
"Well, it's complicated. First I will explain it in a language only these newcomers understand." Celestia told her.
"Princess Celestia, forgive me for my rudeness, but we all speak the same language." Castiel informed.
"She doesn't mean it like that Cass." Dean said, rolling his eyes. "Now let's here 'er out."
"Well, you see. Lately there have been some, odd, occurrences in Equestria. The murder rate has increased dramatically as of late. This may not seem strange at first, trust me, I didn't think much of it. Heck, at first it all seemed like an animal attack, and it looked like it. The Baltimare Police Department(BPD) labeled it as one, but Luna and I knew better. There were no animal tracks. There were no tracks at all in fact. There have been four deaths. So, what do you think?"
"Well." Dean said with eyes wide open. "We have some more questions to ask. If we're going to figure out what did this. So, from what I've heard, I can ask some specific questions. First, did they have some sort of dream job, or got rich, or somethin' like that?"
"Yes. All of them had something amazing happen to them." Cadance butted in and answered.
"Okay, second, how long ago did these events occur?" Sam asked.
"About ten years ago." Luna answered.
"Great. Now, final question, is there some kind of secluded area near Baltimare?" Dean asked.
"Yes. There is a forest to the north of it." Celestia answered.
"Awesome. You thinkin' what I'm thinkin' Sam?"
"Well, Dean, if you're thinkin' crossroads demon, then yes."
"Even an idgit could figure that one out."
"It is most definitely a crossroads demon."
"Uh, guys." Rainbow Dash said to get their attention. "What's a crossroads demon?"
"Oh, shit." Sam and Dean said at the same time, with same expression of sudden realization of something bad. With all that they heard, there would be some trouble with the Mane 6. This, was going to be an interesting job.
"We'll explain later." Sam assured them. "But right now, off to Baltimare."