The girls all traveled to Rick Roll park, where there was a pond beyond the trees, where some of the park's animals live. Right next to the unfrozen pond was a unfrozen pool of mud big enough for a German Shepard to bathe in. When the girls reached their destination, Pinkie handed Rarity a bathing suit and a swimming cap. Rarity took the items and questioned them.
"Pinkie, whatever do I need these for?" Rarity asked, not really happy about the answer about to come from Pinkie's mouth.
"DUH! Isn't it obvious, Rares? You're going to be swimming!" Pinkie exclaimed, clapping her hands.
"Swimming?" Rarity looked at the other girls, in which they shrugged. "That doesn't sound like something I would dread. It sounds quite...delightful...actually." Rarity looked at the small fish in the pond, "Swimming with the fishes, huh?"
"Actually, it's just fish." Sweetie Belle interjected.
"What are you, a dictionary?" Rainbow rolled her ruby eyes.
"Well, yeah, actually I-"
"Silly Rarity!" Pinkie patted Rarity's head, "You're not going to swim in the pond!"
"Oh? Do tell. Where else would I be swimming then if it's not the pond?" Rarity asked.
Pinkie pointed to the answer next to her. Rarity almost fainted at the sight of the mud filled with little insects swimming in it. It looked almost as dirty as the pig pen's mud in Applejack's farm. Rarity blinked twice to see if she was living a nightmare, and truly she was. The other girls all looked at each other, then at Rarity, and shook their heads in disappointment.
"Rarity, really, it's just mud. How bad could it be?" Applejack asked.
"Easy for you to say, Applejack, you probably bathe in mud everyday in that farm of yours." Rarity scoffed, with an angry Applejack ready to rip her hair out.
"I do not BATHE in the mud! I take a shower just like every other normal human being does." Applejack growled.
"Come on, Rarity, just get this over with." Rainbow groaned, stretching her eyelids, "I'm getting bored."
"Funny," Applejack said, "Boredom is what led to our breakup, huh Rainbow? What, you gonna do the same thing you did to me to Rarity?"
"Applejack, come on, don't bring up our breakup now to everyone." Rainbow sighed, "I said several hundred times I was sorry."
" 'Sorry' ain't gonna cut it, sugarcube. I shouldn't even be calling ya that either, huh?"
"What HAPPENED between you two?" Twilight asked.
Fluttershy changed the subject as she turned to Rarity, "Um...Rarity...think of the mud as a...mud bath...it's nice and thick-"
"That's what she said!" Pinkie giggled.
Fluttershy rolled her eyes, "And think of the insects as rose petals. Just imagine yourself at the spa doing all this."
Rarity was still unsure, "Are you sure about this Fluttershy?"
"I'm sure. Trust me Rarity, it won't be as bad as it looks."
Rarity stared at her animal-loving friend for a moment, then at the pond. Sighing in defeat, Rarity quickly got undressed and put on the bathing suit and cap. Stepping into the cold mud puddle, Rarity cringed at the feel of it. She was about to back out, but she looked at Twilight and Fluttershy, who had done those horrible things before. Rarity sighed once more and plunged her entire body into the mud. It was deeper than she thought. Much deeper. Rarity smelled the horrible stench, and her face started to turn a bit pale. Nonetheless, she was sitting in there, doing what she had to do.
Pinkie wasn't satisfied when she saw the somewhat relaxed expression on Rarity's face. She had to come up with something worse, and fast. A lightbulb went off and Pinkie snapped her fingers. Sweetie Belle looked horrified at the lightbulb mysteriously floating above Pinkie's head. Pinkie snatched the pad from Sweetie's hand and started writing something in there. Then she gave it to Sweetie Belle and whispered some things into her ear. Sweetie Belle, with a disgusted look on her face, shook her head. Pinkie showed her a cupcake and that's what got Sweetie Belle to do what she had to.
'Whoops, it appears I forgot to mention." SweetieBot droned, "Rarity has to swallow the mud as well."
"WHAT?!" Everyone else shouted.
"That's right. She has to swallow some of the mud, with some insects in it."
"ENOUGH WITH THE BUGS ALREADY!" Twilight shouted.
Rarity turned paler and looked at mud, then at Pinkie, who merely whistled all innocent like. Rarity was boiling with rage and flipped Pinkie off, who only looked back with a shocked expression. Rarity gulped and bent down until her mouth was completely under the mud. Then she started to drink some of it, along with a few insects. Fluttershy couldn't stand to see the sight, so without a care, she got in the mud, still with her bathing suit on, and pulled Rarity out of the freezing thing. Rarity was cold and very, very pale.
"Rarity! Are you okay?!" Applejack asked.
"Oh, I will be, once I-" Rarity couldn't even finish her sentence before she barfed right into the mud itself.
The sight wanted to make everyone quit the game, but Pinkie wasn't finished yet.
"Alright, who's next?!"
"Oh gosh, this is too much, Pinkie." Rainbow said, "I may be a daredevil, but this shit is completely crazy! Hell no, I ain't doing this!"
"Really?" Applejack said, "You didn't have a problem doing her three weeks ago!"
"WHAT?!" Everyone shouted, looking at the madly red Rainbow Dash.
"Dashie, you lost your virginity?!" Pinkie asked.
"You had sex with someone who wasn't your girlfriend?!" Twilight shouted.
"You never had sex before?" Rarity pondered. Everyone looked at her, with the most unamused expressions on their faces.
"Pinkie, I hope this dare you got is a real good one." Applejack said, glaring at her ex-girlfriend.
"Oh, it's a doosie, alright." Pinkie said, rereading the dare.
Rainbow matched Applejack's glare. "Bring it."