Shining Star suddenly drops down onto the ship and lets Twilight run to a safe spot. Pinkie Pie withdrew her sword. Shining Star used his magic to get out a knight's sword and shield. The two suddenly started trading sword blows. Meanwhile, Rainbow Dash started running around the ship being chased by pirates for her Element. She whistled and the Lost Ponies started fighting them off.
Shining Star suddenly kicked Pinkie Pie in the stomach getting her head stuck in a party cannon. "PARTY IN THE HOLE!" Fluttershy fired Pinkie Pie where Twilight was. Applejack came behind Fluttershy with a smile. "Pony overboard!" she said. Fluttershy knocked Applejack overboard right after she said that. "Ready the cannon Lost Pony Jack...!"
"Make way!" Rainbow Dash said headbutting a pirate away. "Oops! My bad!" Shining Armor suddenly took another pirate's sword and threw it off the ship. "You won't need that."
Pinkie Pie suddenly gets up ready to attack Shining Star, but then turns to Twilight. "Magic." She suddenly pins Twilight to the ground. "Get, off, of, me," Twilight said firing a ray of light at Pinkie Pie. She suddenly gets launched at Shining Star. Shining Star then shield bashes Pinkie Pie out of the way. "Try to keep up," he taunted.
Twilight Sparkle coughed twice. "You're beginning to be a true night, Shine."
"Thank you Twily."
"You're Welcome!" She smiled and blushed.
Applejack rose to the surface really weak. She took off her pirate outfit. "Sorry Cap'n Hook, but you're not the one to control the Jolly Roger. I'm done with this." She suddenly fired a cannon at the ship and it broke a window. "I AM A LOST PONY NOW." Pinkie Pie got up and then cut the cannonball in half. "Traitor!" She suddenly turned to Shining Star and they started trading blows again. Twilight Sparkle kept watching but felt as though he was doing something correct. Protecting her.
Rainbow Dash and the lost ponies started dealing with the pirates easily, thanks to Applejack being on her side. "I know why Captain Hook is corrupted. Please! You've gotta listen to me!"
"We were forced to join our lives since we had no friends in Neverland!" one pirate spoke up as he knocked Apple Bloom away.
"That's... the problem! Of course! Forced bonds!" She suddenly flew into the sky and dived back down performing a Sonic Rainboom knocking all the remaining pirates away. "We can stop fighting and become great buddies."
Shining Star suddenly flew up to the top of the ship. "Yeah, that's right, fly away you coward!" Pinkie Pie taunted.
"Coward!? Me!?" Pinkie Pie laughed. "You wouldn't fight me Pony to Pony, letting your friends be forced to join me as you cowardly fly off!!"
"Nopony calls me a coward and shines," Shine retorted. "I'll fight you pony to pony with my wings locked in place."
"You mean... YOU WON'T FLY!?" Twilight gasped as Shining Star came down. "Shine! It's a trap!"
"Pinkie Promise!" Pinkie Pie grinned. "Let's end this, shall we?"