Pinkie Pie and Applejack circled around each other thinking about where Rainbow Dash's hiding spot could be. They searched everywhere but two places. Cold Rock Cove and Hangpony's Tree. They can't seem to figure out how-to actually get there.
"They should be holding a treasure there, but how do we steal it?" Applejack asked.
"We can do a 200 pace run to Hangpony's tree, and set a surprise trap for our, LITTLE, ponies," Pinkie Pie replied and laughed as she took a drink of Apple Cider. "But how can we steal it?"
"Maybe we can catch Rainbow Dash and take her treasure before we awake," Applejack replied.
"Great idea! We trek now!" The entire Jolly Roger crew then left for the treasure - Rainbow Dash's Element of Harmony.
Twilight Sparkle couldn't sleep that night. She was too busy writing in a journal for all the strange things that happened in the past hours. Celestia walked over to her. "Twilight?"
"Sorry for being up late, but everypony I know seems to be here and in Equestria except for me, Shine, and Dash."
"I know the feeling Twilight. I have the same feelings as the other me. I know it all..."
Rainbow Dash snapped awake. "Lost ponies! Foward Run!" She, the lost ponies, Twilight, and Shine started running to Hangpony's tree. "I left my Element of Harmony there! If they get to it first I don't know what'll happen!"
"Gee Rainbow, we didn't know this was going to be the big flaw of today."
"Shine, please! I already had enough trouble already!"
They made it to the tree. Rainbow Dash got her Element back in a flash and they ran off before Hook could find them. "We are so busted!" Rainbow Dash said.
"We most certainly are," Derpy and Lyra replied. Twilight Sparkle suddenly saw a big fog ahead of them. "Oh no!" The fourteen suddenly get trapped in it. Rainbow Dash knew it was a trap. She stayed low to see what was going on. She could see the lost ponies looking for each other and Twilight Sparkle and Shining Star were stuck in the middle looking for a way to get out of the fog.
"We must capture Rainbow Dash and take her treasure," they heard a pirate command. Then they saw a pony in the form of Applejack rushing towards the two. Shining Star started getting an odd feeling. He used his magic to clear the fog. Rainbow Dash growled at Applejack. Applejack gulped as the fourteen ponies surrounded her.
Applejack only had two options... join or fall. "I give up, you fourteen are just too strong for me..." Rainbow Dash smiled and said, "Welcome aboard, Lost Pony Jack!" Then she came to a sudden realization. Somepony was caught.
Twilight.