Fluttershy's New Pet

by Diablomuerte2

Darn that Appleslut

It was morning and the sun was rising over the peaceful skies above. The town of Ponyville was hit with a storm of drama that only affected the few ponies involved in it. The morning was much more serene than the chaotic night before. With the sun shining down on the town it was giving way to a new beginning.

Rainbow Dash had woken up early as usual but instead of leaving Fluttershy asleep, she gingerly woke the canary mare up using her tongue. "Morning Fluttershy, get up so I can do my exercises." She lapped away at Fluttershy's face earning her a yawn from the sleeping mare.

Fluttershy woke up feeling amazing after their night. She had been able to lower Rainbow Dash's guard and gave her a wicked good preening. With the tongue gently stroking her face, she pretended to be sleeping to allow for more licks. After a few more laps from her pet's tongue she yawned and faced the amazing pet. "Morning Snuggles. Gosh it's early, are you ready to start the day?"

Rainbow Dash was born ready. "Yes I am Shy. I'm about to head downstairs to exercise if you are interested in joining me."

Fluttershy smiled. "No you go ahead, I will get some chores done and get a bath ready for when you're done getting stinky... then I can make you all clean and ready for breakfast."

Rainbow Dash grinned. "Awesome! Well I better get to it." She ran off, feeling more energetic than ever before.

Fluttershy saw her pet run off and had a dreamy look on her face. "I can get used to this... it didn't hurt making that preening extra relaxing. After all, now she is enjoying this more and more. I can't wait till she submits, and I will finally be so happy."

Applejack had an interesting night indeed. She woke up remembering everything that happened as soon as she saw the pony lying next to her. "Rarity?" she asked afraid of what may have occurred.

"Keep it down will you... I think I have a hangover," Rarity complained.

"What happened last night? I mean... what happened after we drank."

"Well I know we got some cider to drown away our sorrows... then you suggested in your drunken stupor to forget about Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash... then you called me sexy."

"I Did!"

"Yes and it was quite flattering, darling."

"Oh no... did we? I mean did we ya know?"

"I don't rightly know. I was pretty drunk myself and rather horny so it may have happened... which would suck because I wanted my first time to be with a handsome prince."

"Well, if we did I will be angry, because I wanted it to be with RD!"

"Stop yelling! plus... from what I do remember last night, whatever we did do was... pleasurable and fun."

"That don't mean we did it, does it?"

"Not necessarily, but there's a high probability we both lost control and reacted on instinct."

"So should we jus' end the mystery and lift the blanket?"

"If you must... but whatever happens, I want you to know... I had fun last night."

"Me too sugar cube, it was nice not worrying about feathered ponies for once."

"So how about we just don't lift the blankets and we pretend nothing happened. That way if it did or didn't, nopony is the wiser?"

"I can't, ya know that, I’m the element of honesty. I need to find out what happened last night... and take responsibility for it."

Applejack went to lift the sheets to discover if they had indeed soiled them with fluids but her hoof was held down. "You love Rainbow Dash, and I don't want to be the pony that spoiled your chances," Rarity said softly.

"So ya want me to lie? That's not the apple way."

"Fine... lift the sheets..."

"Okay here it goes."

Applejack lifted the sheets revealing that in their drunken stupor they did in fact have sex. She was devastated with the results and Rarity began crying. "Oh no... of all the worst things that could happen, this is the! Worst! Possible! Thing!"

Applejack got off the bed and looked out the window. She didn't have any words to say, and she didn't know what she would say to Rainbow Dash. "I guess I'll have to talk to RD during the pony pet play date today. I don't know how she'll take it."

Rarity got off the bed and rushed to Applejack's side. "If she treats you bad because of my mistake, I will hurt her," Rarity said with passion. She felt so guilty and apologetically nuzzled Applejack's face.

Applejack then went wide eyed with shock. "Oh let's just hope we didn't make too many loud noises last night."

Rarity became nervous. "That's right your family are more traditional... oh no..."

Applejack gulped. "It isn't jus' my family, sugar cube. Spike was at the barn all night, since Pinkie and Twilight bunkin' together at the library."

Rarity felt sick. "Poor Spike... we have to tell him about Fluttershy's pet, but how? If he heard this, will he even listen?"

Applejack sighed. "I sure hope so, Rares. Looks like things are going bad for everypony lately. Let's jus' hope things don't stay this way."

Twilight was very comfortable when she woke up. "Pinkie...I can get used to this," Twilight said dreamily. "Are you sure you have to work this morning."

Pinkie chuckled. "I knew you had a sweet tooth, just didn't know you loved the taste of Pinkie Pie."

Twilight blushed. "You're terrible."

"Oh you know you love it, sweet stuff. As to your question, yes, I do have to go to work," Pinkie replied.

Twilight groaned. "Arg, fine! Get to work, I am going to find Spike."

Pinkie giggled as she got out of bed. "Oh Twilight, I think you might have an addiction to pie. Luckily for me it isn't apple pie."

Twilight tossed a pillow at her evading body and groaned. "Yeah well... ugh."

Spike woke up angrily so. The night before he was able to hear it all. The first set of noises disoriented him from sleep but the more amorous noises of pleasure made him grow in anger. "I can't believe they did it... is that why I was forced to the barn so I wouldn't be trouble for them? Well it doesn't matter... I am so over Rarity anyways... and Fluttershy's pet will be my one true love."

He began walking towards the library and left the farm but heard noises again and saw Applejack and Rarity nuzzling each other. "Yeah it's obviously this has been going on for a while," he whispered sadly. He felt used by Rarity, thinking about how Applejack and her have been betraying him this whole time.

Little did he know that his evidence was circumstantial and all of his accusations were false.

Later in the day it was time for the Pony Pet Play Date. The event that happened every at the park. The group of friends would bring their pets and play with them peacefully. It was usually a calm event and free of drama.

Fluttershy brought Angel Bunny and secretly brought her other pet. She ordered Rainbow Dash to go about her usual business during the play session at the park. Once the pony pet play date was over it was back to wearing a collar and being ordered around.

Rainbow Dash was going to have to explain her absence to her friends. She rehearsed something believable and hoped they would buy it. She brought Tank with her and felt good about being able to have some, one on one, time with him. She felt neglectful of the little tortoise and that began to worry her.

Applejack brought Winona and was not her usual excited self. The entire morning became complicated when she was confronted about the wild night she had. Her family could hear them moaning and groaning at all hours of the night. Rarity was there when it happened and she remained silent and red faced.

Rarity had went back to her shop/home after that and got ready for the day. She washed herself of Applejack's scent and even tried grooming opal with major retaliation. When she arrived she noticed how gloomy Applejack was and felt guilty.

Pinkie Pie was excited as usual and even had gummy riding on her back with his jaws clamped around her mane. She was glad to be able to spend some more time with twilight and had made some delicious treats this morning which sold easily. Absence makes the heart grow fonder and now Pinkie knew why.

Twilight wasn't as excited as Pinkie was. She had been consoling a depressed baby dragon that had been mislead to believe things he had imagined in his head. Then the worst part was she had to inform him of Fluttershy's new pet. It was the worst thing ever. She was going to cancel on showing up but felt it would be wrong to not show up and at least explain why she couldn't make it.

When they all arrived it was quiet and peaceful until Applejack got close to Rainbow Dash. That motion of them getting closer made Fluttershy become angry. "That darn Appleslut... why does she have to crowd around Snuggles like that."

Rarity blushed. "Yes, she does seem to be crowding your pet... just remember no one knows about your relationship so don't cause a scene."

Fluttershy watched as the two mares were getting chummy and their bodies were moving closer to each other. She began snorting steam out her nose, and getting ready to charge.

Rarity saw this and was shocked at how jealous Fluttershy was. "Fluttershy, you need to calm down before you do something rash."

"No!" Fluttershy yelled out catching the attention of every pony there. "Sorry... I just really disagreed with something Rarity said."

Twilight felt this was her cue to address a certain issue. "Speaking about Rarity, it seems your sudden relationship with Applejack made Spike a bit upset. He thinks you two have been together secretly behind his back. I told him it wasn't true, but still he was crying about it."

Fluttershy grinned at the information. "So then Applejack is with Rarity? Oh that's great news. You two will be happy together!"

Rainbow Dash felt a bit bummed out. "Well that's... something else."

Applejack was in tears. "I'm not with Rarity... I jus' had sex with her."

Pinkie Pie gasped. "But I thought you loved Rainbow Dash... "

Rarity felt bad and tried to salvage the situation. "Well it's just we got drunk and it was my fault."

Rainbow Dash blushed. "Wait what? Applejack loves me?"

Fluttershy saw the reaction and got angry. "Yeah she says she does... but look at what she did behind your back ... oh that must hurt doesn't it?"

Applejack gave Fluttershy a look that could kill. "Ya know what Fluttershy, ya ain't so innocent yourself! Or should I tell Rainbow Dash about the massage Rarity gave ya, while ya weren't drunk?"

Fluttershy flared her wings in aggression. "Or I could tell you about the preening I gave Rainbow Dash while we weren't drunk. It's much more interesting."

Rainbow Dash felt uncomfortable about the whole situation. "Are you two fighting over me? If so you both are wasting your time. I don't do relationships."

Fluttershy snorted in anger. "Shut your mouth, Snuggles!"

The silence that followed was stagnant. The tensions between all parties grew as the situation escalated. Fluttershy began shaking in fear and ran with tears flowing down her face. Rainbow Dash just froze as she mentally checked out of the entire awkward moment. Applejack walked away angrily and felt like speaking to nopony at all. Rarity wasn't sure who to console but knew who to blame. Twilight was filled with guilt and couldn't shake the feeling that things were going to get worse. Pinkie Pie felt her Pinkie Sense go off.

Rarity rushed to Rainbow Dash's side. "I know you are in there and you have to listen right now. You have two distinct choices. You can either go after Fluttershy and calm her down or you can go after Applejack."

Rainbow Dash stayed silent but flapped her wing in acknowledgement of what she was saying.

"If you choose to go after Applejack then you must let be honest with her about how you feel, and I will go after Fluttershy and stop her from doing something stupid. If you go after Fluttershy then I am going to take my chances with Applejack and well... I will give her the love you can't."

Rainbow Dash flapped her wing again letting Rarity know she is understanding her so far. She was trying to digest what took place and how she could save face in all this.

"So Rainbow Dash... which is it? You can't be at two places at once, and they both need you... I will be honest. I hope you choose Fluttershy. Because last night I had an amazing time with Applejack, and this may be selfish of me to say this but... I think she deserves someone who is emotionally stable."

Rainbow Dash snapped. "Well what about what I think? You have no idea how I feel about all this..."

Rarity looked into Rainbow Dash's eyes and asked slowly. "How do you feel about all this?"

Rainbow Dash opened her mouth and replied with, "I feel that I should go after... "