Fairy Tail: The Pony arc

by Tythen


Chapter 2: The Mane 6

The Town of Magnolia. A bustling place full of people... well, ponies doing their day to day jobs. The ponies doesn't seem to worry about themselves becoming ponies when they were once humans as they could still do their day to day jobs. In this certain town, lies a certain guild called Fairy Tail.


Natsu kicked the front door open.

"HEY EVERYPONY!!!!! GOOD MORNING!!!" Natsu yelled

"Did you just say everypony!?" Gray belted out shocked of what he said

"What!? Since we're ponies, can't I just make the joke of saying "everypony" instead of "everybody"?" Natsu said

"I don't think this is the time for jokes now..." Happy tried to change the subject.

"This isn't a joke now! We are ponies!" Gray said

"Jokes are important! It keeps the morale up Freezy Flank!" Natsu taunted

"What did you call me Smokey Tails?" Gray retorted insulted.

"GRRRR!!!!!" They both locked their heads and horns against one another trying to overpower each other

"I'll take you down! Not If I take you down first! Stop copying me!" They both said in unison then both got whacked simultaneously by Erza's hooves.

"Stop it you two!" Erza commanded. "This is no time for a fight!"

The Mane 6

"Salamander!" A haughty low voice called out as a dark grey unicorn that had iron piercings on his face, no doubt that was Gajeel. Other things that gave him away was his bushy spiky mane and tail, the metal armlets on his legs and his cutie mark which was very similar to Natsu, only that the dragon looked metallic to show that it was an Iron Dragon.

"Gajeel!!! Hah! You're also a pony, you look so pathetic!" Natsu laughed

"Gi Hi Hi Hi! You know I can say the same thing to you as well Natsu!" Gajeel taunted back

"Good Morning Guys!" A young unicorn filly spoke up. Having a light blue colour and a long dark blue mane, she also had a symbol on her flank that is just like Natsu and Gajeel except the dragon this time is white and made of clouds resembling a Sky Dragon.

"Wendy! Carla!" Happy exclaimed in greetings, Carla who's still an exceed just turned her face away in a 'hmph' way.

"Still standing strong I see. Even on all legs and a horizontal body" Panther Lily said as he approached the group in greetings.

"How's the guild coping with the equine changes to their body?" Lucy asked

"They're as worried as ever and are hastily trying to fix it." Carla explained but was confused about one thing "Unlike you guys, you seem perfectly fine with it!"

"Its because we still have our magic power! Not only that, but despite ponies using all their legs, we all get small telepathy powers to make up for hands! And, our physical strength is slightly boosted since Equines are stronger than humans." Gray informed the good things.

"Its best that we adapt to our new bodies so we can take advantage of it. Or somepony's who's been a pony before should know." Erza advised

"Erza! Did you just say somepony?" Happy asked confused

"What? I said somebody!" Erza corrected worried

"Hmm... With Natsu said everypony and Erza said somepony. This doesn't seem like a coincidence. Is this also affecting the way we talk?" Lucy wondered

"Hey Natsu!" A small faint purple unicorn with Dark purple hair came up to them. This colt is Romeo, unlike most of the unicorns in Fairy Tail, his flanks lack a symbol unfortunately.

"Romeo! Its good to see you! Even if your smaller than you used to..." Natsu greeted

A orange unicorn with a rather sporty blue mane and tail with her mane tied with a bandana put her book down and took off her Gale-Force Reading glasses (with her magic of course, since they don't have any hands anymore!) to wave at them

"Levy-Chan!" Lucy exclaimed as the Celestial Spirit Mage Unicorn went to go greet the Letter Mage unicorn

"Its good to see you Lucy! Life is really unexpected you know that? First, most of us and the town got turned into Lacrima, and now the entire Earth-Land turned into ponies! But hey! At least I can still read and find the cure instead of being an inanimate object!" Levy explained the problem.

"Don't worry Levy-Chan! We will cheer you on!" Two stallion unicorns that looks like Jet and Droy drumming off as a cheering squad. Lucy just looked blank at them.

"Gray-Sama!" A voice cried out as a Blue Unicorn with a sea-blue mane that has curls at the bottom and a symbol of a large water drop galloped and embraced Gray

"Gray-Sama! Juvia's so happy you've made it here alive! Juvia has been turned into a pony, as have you and everyone! I'm so scared! Please help Juvia!"

"Its good to see you too Juvia... Now please get off me... I'm... Losing... Breath!" Gray squealed so Juvia let go, "don't worry, we'll get to the bottom of this soon."

"You know..." Erza said inspecting her own body, this body style seems rather familiar..."

"Now that you mention it..." Wendy added overhearing her "Our bodies do look familiar to a show..." Upon hearing that, Erza looked up startled, alert, and embarrassed

"You... You mean... Wait! Don't say what the show is about Wendy! Please!" Erza begged but unfortunately, that got Natsu, Gray and Lucy's attention.

"Erza and Wendy, please spill out what you know about our current forms. Unless you want to tell us that your behind this scheme!" Natsu ordered, even though he wouldn't dare take a tone like that to Erza.

"Of course not! I didn't do it! My magic isn't that powerful, but yes. I do recognise what our pony bodies look like, it's from a show." Erza explained and Wendy continued

"The show is called "My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic". We watch this show from a giant movie lacrima!"

"We? You mean its not just you Wendy? I mean, a show like that would be targeted for young people like you." Lucy asked.

"You'd be very surprised Lucy." Carla piped up "Apart from me and Wendy, there are a few other Guild Members that watch with us. There's Erza..."

"WHAT!?" Natsu, Gray, Lucy and Happy blurted out in unison then faced Erza who was smiling sheepishly and sweating uncontrollably, seeing red with embarrassment. Carla just ignored them and continued the list.

"...Evergreen..."

"A member of the Rajin (Thunder God) Tribe!?" The four said again, Evergreen just looked at them and chuckled and continued on using her fan to cool herself down while chatting with Freed and Bickslow.

"Well, at least she's a mare." Gray implied then was surprised he said 'mare' instead of 'woman'

"Oh no... Maybe Lucy's right, our vocabulary is being um... Ponified?" Gray realised at this sudden realisation

"What!? I never told you anything!" Lucy was shocked

"... Then Mirajane and Lisanna. So not counting me, those six girls watch the show, just as if they're the Mane 6. There are six main characters in the show so with the use of puns, we gave the 6 characters their team nickname." Carla finished

"Well I don't really need to know the gist of the show. That show sounds really stupid then! I guess it is stupid." Natsu judged harshly then stood dead scared as he was then staring at a levitating sword aimed at his neck. Erza gave Natsu a death stare.

"Watch what you say Natsu..." Erza warned "Its a good show but if you make fun of it one more time and I will tie you to a chair and force you to watch it... Understand?"

"A...Aye sir!" Natsu whimpered for Erza to hear so she dematerialised the sword.

"Sometimes, Elfman joins in as well." Carla added on, the four went completely silent

"Elfman watches PONIES!?!?!?" Natsu blurted out loud enough for the three Take Over Siblings to hear.

"PONIES ARE MANLY!" Elfman barked scaring the team. His body was bigger than the average colt and had a tan colour, he still kept his trademark scar below his right eye and his symbol on his flank was a kanji symbol (For Fairy Tail watchers, you would know what the Kanji would be... 'Man!'). Natsu tried to suppress his laughter, Elfman still looking displeased. Lucy went to Mirajane who was currently talking with a green bird.

"Mirajane... Is it true that you mares watch this MLP show Carla was talking about?" Lucy asked

"Well of course!" Mirajane happily answered without any signs of embarrassment. "Its a cute and sweet show about friendship! It's pretty much like how things roll here in Fairy Tail... Without the destructive nature of course..." Mirajane paused for a moment to brush some dust off her body. Her body colour is the same as Lucy's while Mirajane's mane is the same as her hairstyle when she was a human. In fact, everyone's mane style is just the same as their own hairstyle when they were human.

"Well? Can you change back into a human?" Mirajane asked the bird who shook its head, when the bird spotted Lucy, it started to search the crowd for someone until it found someone, the bird must have realised something. If Lucy was here, then a certain someone is here too. The bird surrounded itself with some magic transforming itself and at the same time, running towards Natsu.

"Natsu!!" Natsu turned to the source of the voice to see a blue-eyed white unicorn with a white short-haired mane embracing him.

"Li-Lisanna..." Natsu whimpered, still unable to get over the fact that their Lisanna is still alive all the time in Edolas and had recently come back with them.

"Grr..... Get your hooves of him." Lucy grumbled quietly as she glared at Lisanna.

"Jealous much?" Happy taunted cheekily

"Shut up Cat! I'm just worried about my team mate getting distracted!" Lucy yelled pulling and pinching Happy's cheeks.

"Wha? How can you do that?" Mirajane asked in fear and confusion

"Do what?" Lucy asked still pinching Happy

"How do you manage to pinch and pull Happy? You don't have any fingers!"

"Good question. I don't really know!" Lucy answered confused herself so she let Happy go.

"That was mean Lucy..." Happy sobbed rubbing his painful cheeks

"Where's Gildarts? Hey Gildarts!" Natsu cried shaking Lisanna off and galloped away to find him, Lisanna smiled at Natsu and so did Lucy did the same as she came near Lisanna. When Natsu was gone from their presence, the girls immediately locked heads and horns glaring at each other, just like Natsu and Gray did earlier.

"Hooves off Natsu, he's mine!" Lucy warned

"I've been his friend longer than you have!" Retorted Lisanna

"Then you 'faked' your death and left him alone for 2 years!" Lucy taunted again

"I didn't have a choice! I had to support my Edolas counterpart siblings!" Lisanna retaliated

"Do you want to take this outside?" Lucy threatened

"How about right here right now Don-Key?" Lisanna taunted

"What did you just call me you 4-legged stallion-eater?" Lucy retaliated insulted by the pun.

"IT'S ON!" They both cried

"Oh dear, even insulting words have to include things that deals with Equines." Happy said upset.

"Oh no! Not you guys as well! Please, sis, Lucy, don't be like me when I was young with Erza" Mirajane tried to help stop them but they still were pushing against each other.

"Oh I had enough! Take this!!" A cry from Natsu echoed the room as Gajeel was sent flying across the room crashing into Gray, this is what diverted the girls from their rivalry fight and focused on what was happening.

"Now you've taken it too far!" Gray yelled and galloped straight for Natsu accidentally knocking into Erza which made her drop her desert.

"M-My strawberry cake!" Erza stuttered as nearly about to cry. Elfman stomped on it flat freaking Erza out with sadness

"Hey everyone! Real stallions speak with their hooves!" Elfman announced ready to fight

"Shut your mouth you oaf!" Erza angrily snapped as she gave Elfman a powerful buck sending him flying. What can be described next is destructive brawls all around the hall, the casualty of ponies and destruction of guild property resulting in utter chaos, the usual ordinary day at Fairy Tail.

"You know what? I take back calling you a 4-legged stallion-eater." Lucy apologised

"Don't worry, it was a pathetic insult anyway. I'll also take back calling you a Donkey." Lisanna also made up.


Back outside in Magnolia, six ponies and a young baby dragon approached the building of Fairy Tail.

"So this is the town hall?" Rarity questioned "Looks big to be a Town Hall."

"Wow! This place is as big as a castle!" Pinkie Pie admired "I wonder if there is a King living here? Does he like parties?"

"Let's not jump into conclusions now" Applejack snapped

"Hey! This building has a name!" Spike exclaimed as he read the big words on the entrance. "It says, 'Fairy Tail'." Spike concluded

Fluttershy gasped, "Fairy Tail? You mean those birds back a long time ago in Equestria? Their tails are really beautiful. Ahh... I wish I could see those birds!"

"Fluttershy! You know that the inhabitants here don't know a single thing about Equestria." Rainbow Dash explained "But the first thing they'll know about Equestria is me!"

"Yeah Yeah! But first, we've got to introduce ourselves to the people. We need to make first impressions that we are well behaved ambassadors of Equestria." As the seven approached the door to the interior of the guild, Twilight added

"Judging by the Town Hall as the size of a Castle, I bet these people are royally behaved just like Canterlot! I think were going to have a great time!"

But as she opened the door, six bodies flew out of the door tackling the entire Mane 6 and knocking them out. Spike was the only one unharmed. The entire guild immediately stopped fighting and see who their new visitors were.

"Ack! Twilight! Rarity! Everypony!" Spike gasped in horror.

"Wow... Nice welcome!" Pinkie Pie muttered before going out of commission.

"Oops... We are really sorry about your friends little one!" Wendy apologised to the dragon

"This happens all the time." Lucy explained

"Why don't we get your friends checked up inside the guild?" Lisanna asked "Its better to be inside a shelter than be outside, I mean it can rain soon."

"Let's just get these guys in there. Can you help me Happy?" Lucy said as she dragged the unconscious Natsu and Twilight with her mouth.

"Aye sir!" Happy replied dragging Rainbow Dash and Gajeel

"The guild's overdone it this time... In fact, they do it all the time." Carla said disgusted as she pulled Gray and Rarity.

"Oh dear. Elf-Nii must have nearly squashed the poor mare!" Lisanna said worried as she pulled on Elfman and Fluttershy as hard as she could

"Heh heh... The guild doesn't change now. Does it?" Wendy asked pulling Bickslow and Pinkie Pie

"I guess not then. Its fun anyway!" Mirajane answered sheepishly as she was in charge of AppleJack and Panther Lily.

"Well then little one." Erza talked to Spike. "You coming in or what?"

"U-Uh Yes madam!"