Rainbow screamed at the top of her lungs at the sight of the Timberwolf and ran behind Fluttershy. Fluttershy on the other hoof didn't even flinch. Fluttershy flashed her flashlight at the Timberwolf only to see that it was a statue.
"Looks like the brave one isn't so brave anymore."
"BE QUIET!" Fluttershy laughed at Rainbow and started to taunt her.
"Come on Scaredy Dash! Don't be afraid of the dark!"
"Stop it! We need to focus on getting Spike!"
"Fine..." Both ponies then went to find Spike. Searching every room, every floor, every secret passage. They didn't find anything.
"Huh... I can't believe Spike isn't in this house." Rainbow Dash went over to the windows. Nothing was outside either.
"But if Spike's not here then..." They both looked at each other and realized. Spike was still in Ponyville.
BZZT
"That's right! Congratulations you won! What did you win you might ask? A chance to perish in this very house!" Rainbow and Fluttershy both turned to see that Slappy had started to speak again.
"I can't believe it! So that Twilight we spoke to inside the closet was..."
"Actually that really was Twilight. I was just somewhere around the abandoned houses in Ponyville."
"Ooooooh.... That makes sense."
"But we'll get you! When we can figure out a way to get out of here..." Fluttershy then looked around for a door. They were all gone.
"How do doors just disappear?" Rainbow went over to the spot where the front door was. She put her hoof over the spot where the knob should be. The spot was solid wall.
"Why don't we jump out of the windows?" Fluttershy suggested. Rainbow thought for a while before agreeing. She then jumped towards the window only to find out it was rubber not glass.
"The only way you both are going to get out is if you jump into the toilet and flush yourselves into the sewer system!" With that Slappy stopped talking.
"What?! I don't want to jump into a toilet to get out of here!"
"You're starting to sound like Rarity..."
"Please don't start now."
*Twilight earlier after Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy went to the Everfree*
"I can't believe they forgot to untie me!" Twilight struggled with breaking free from the ropes. She would've gotten free by now if she used her magic. Although while struggling she had totally forgotten to use it at all.
"Come on... Yes!" Twilight broke free from the ropes and got out of the closet. She looked around and noticed it was silent. Well of course since Spike wasn't with her.
"Alright time to wait for them." Twilight went over to her variety of books and wondered which one to read while waiting.
*Knock*
"What? Who's there?" Twilight walked over to the door and opened it very slowly. There on the ground was a note.
~If you want to help out go to this house number 9697 at the edge of town~ ~P.S. Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy are stuck in the Everfree because of you~
"..." Twilight stared at the note for a while before leaving.
"Alright mystery pony. I'll do your task." Twilight went ahead and left the library to go to the house.
"...I know you can do it. I know you can beat my brother, Slappy."
"Okay 9697... Wow this is some house." Twilight said sarcastically. The house was about as high as 4 feet as wide as 2 feet. It would be hard to believe that such a house could be that small.
"If I just squeeze into the door..." Twilight struggled a little before getting through. "Got it!"
"Whoa, this is HUGE!" Twilight looked around her and saw that she was inside a room about 10 x 10 meters with Spike in the middle. Slappy was near him using some contraption.
"Hm? Now what do you see?" Slappy looked at what Spike was looking at but saw nothing.
"Don't expect that a pony will come from that door to save you so be quiet." Slappy said the sentence in a harsh tone that would make anyone scared.
"Gotta save Spike! But what can I do to get him out?" Twilight looked over to Slappy. He wasn't paying attention at all to the surroundings. Maybe... She could use magic to defeat Slappy!
"Here goes nothing!" Twilight concentrated and started. Her horn glowed with a bright purple aura and used the magic on Slappy. He was now enveloped in the aura.
"Hey! Let me down whoever you are!" Slappy flailed and screamed and tried as hard as he could to escape from the aura but failed.
"Excuse me but the name is Twilight. You're presence on this world is threatening all ponies. You must be gone." Twilight concentrated a bit more and her horn glowed brighter. Slappy who was still flailing was starting to lose his energy.
"Mmph! Mmph Mm Mm Mm Mmph!(Yeah! Keep going Twilight!)" Spike said.
"Oh no!" Twilight lost control and Slappy broke free from the aura. Twilight collapsed and stared up at Slappy.
"Looks like your plan has backfired on you. I guess I could destroy you now but torturing is way better. Starting with breaking your horn!" Slappy raised his hoof and held it there in mid-air.
"Any last words?" Slappy asked. He didn't wait for an answer and moved his hoof at lightning speed at Twilight's horn. What happened next was what changed everything.