“Twilight, Twilight, are you there?” I asked, rapidly knocking on her door, “It’s me, Rarity!”
“I’m coming!” Twilight said as she opened the door, “Uhh, Rarity why do you have on a black cloak?” Oh that’s right! I put on this black cloak, so Spike wouldn’t see what I had on before I gave him the “surprise.”
“Uhh, reasons,” I replied, blushing and sweating, “Anyways, is Spike home?”
“Yeah, but you should know something-“ Twilight began before Spike came running downstairs.
“Is it Sno-“ Spike began, “Oh, hey Rarity.” He seemed a bit down when he saw me.
“May I come in?” I asked, grinning.
Spike opened the door some more and gestured me to come in, “After you!”
“Thanks!” I said, trotting inside the house.
“So, what’s up Rarity?” He asked, closing the door behind me.
“Here goes nothing,” I thought as I slipped the cloak off, relieving my beautiful dress!
“What’s all this?” Spike asked in awe.
“It’s your surprise!” I responded, magically placing the radio I had in the cloak on a table next to me.
“Surprise? What is going on?!” Spike asked.
“Just sit, relax, and enjoy the show!” I replied, magically picking him up and setting him down on the couch while Twilight went into the kitchen.
“Rarity, I’m making tea, okay?” She asked.
“Okay!” I called, and then I pressed play on the radio. As the beat started to play, I magically lifted a small microphone I also had in the cloak.
“This is for you, Spikey Wikey!” I said, “It’s called Broken-Hearted Mare!” Spike sat there in silence, waiting for me to sing.
“You're everything I thought you never were
And nothing like I thought you could have been
But still, you live inside of me, so tell me how is that?
You're the only one I wish I could forget
The only one I love to not forgive
And though you break my heart, you're the only one
And though there are times when I hate you
'Cause I can't erase
The times that you hurt me and put tears on my face
And even now, while I hate you, it pains me to say
I know I'll be there at the end of the day
I don't wanna be without you, babe
I don't want a broken heart
Don't wanna take a breath without you, babe
I don't wanna play that part
I know that I love you, but let me just say
I don't wanna love you in no kind of way, no no
I don't want a broken heart
I don't wanna play the broken-hearted mare
No, no, no broken-hearted mare
There's something that I feel I need to say
But up til' now I've always been afraid that you would never come around
And still I wanna put this out
You say you've got the most respect for me
But, sometimes I feel you're not deserving of me
And still, you're in my heart
But you're the only one
And yes, there are times when I hate you, but I don't complain
'Cause I've been afraid that you would walk away
Oh, but now I don't hate you
I'm happy to say
That I will be there at the end of the day
I don't wanna be without you, babe
I don't want a broken heart
Don't wanna take a breath without you, babe
I don't wanna play that part
I know that I love you, but let me just say
I don't wanna love you in no kind of way, no no
I don't want a broken heart
I don't wanna play the broken-hearted mare
No, no, no broken-hearted mare
Now I'm at a place I thought I'd never be, ooh
I'm living in a world that's all about you and me, yeah
Ain't gotta be afraid, my broken heart is free to spread my wings and fly away, away with you...
I don't wanna be without my baby
I don't want a broken heart
Don't wanna take a breath without my baby
I don't wanna play that part
I know that I love you, but let me just say
I don't wanna love you in no kind of way, no no
I don't want a broken heart
I don't wanna play the broken-hearted mare
No, no, no broken-hearted mare
Broken-hearted mare
No, no, no broken-hearted mare
No broken-hearted mare!” I sang. When the beat ended, Twilight dimmed the lights for effect. I mouthed “thank you” to her as Twilight nodded her head.
“Spikey Wikey, what do you say? Will you give me a second chance?” I asked as Twilight turned the lights back on.
“Oh, well, about that,” He began.
“Spikey Wikey!” I cried as my eyes sparkled due to tears forming in my eyes. I couldn’t cry now; my makeup will run! Suddenly, Twilight came in with the tea.
“Here ya go!” She said as she quickly gave Spike and I our tea. I nodded as I took a sip.
“Look Rarity, I like you and all-“ He began before I cut him off.
“LIKE ME!??! YOU USED TO LOVE ME; NO, YOU USED TO BE OBSESSED WITH ME!!?? WHAT’S GOING ON?!!?” I shouted, almost spilling the tea on my new dress. I squeaked as I quickly caught the tea and put it back in the teacup with my magic. Then, I quickly started drinking the rest of my tea.
“I’m dating Snowcatcher now,” Spike explained.
“WHAT??!!” I did a spit take! The tea was all over Twilight. “Hehe, uhh, my apologies Twilight!” Twilight gave me a glare.
“How about no tea!” Twilight replied, lifting all of our teacups with her magic and going back into the kitchen.
“Sorry!” I called out.
“It’s okay! I need to get washed up, anyway!” She called back out.
“Rarity, I’m sorry, but I asked Snowcatcher out already,” Spike explained, “It’s too late now!”
“B-B-But I did all this for you, Spikey Wikey!” I responded, heartbroken!
“Thanks, but it’s too late,” Spike replied, hanging down his head, “Oh, and by the way, call me Spike from now on!”
“B-But-“ I tried to say, but nothing came out except for tears, “FINE!!! WHO NEEDS YOU!!??” I ran towards the door, but then turned to face Spike.
“Oh, and tell Miss Snow Licker that I need to speak with her!” I shouted as I bolted out the door. Spike started to cry as Twilight came back in with a towel wrapped around her.
“It’s okay Spike,” Twilight said, “Let me speak with Rarity. I’m sure everything is going to be just fine!”
“I don’t know, Twi, but thank you,” Spike replied as Twilight nodded. Then, she wrapped her hooves around him, trying to stop him from crying.