Convergence Series: Journeys

by TheGreatEater


Chapter 28: Pinkie Pie: Dark Side

A/N: Disclaimer: Chapter contains lots of violence. It should be stated that I love Pinkie Pie, and I’m going to give her a good happy ending next chapter.




Pinkie was horrified when she was ripped from her friends side as the room shifted to find herself tied and bounded to the alter. Her eyes widened with fear as her Dark Side showed itself a from on its face and its’ eyes aglow with raw hatred. Using the “Pinch” that pony’s used to pick up objects with their hooves she duel wielded a pair of scalpels. “Hello Pinkie Pie ready for a party?”




Pinkie screamed as her double came down on her cutting into her flesh. “I HATE YOU PINKIE!!!” Her double screamed over her as she violently stabbed her repeatedly. Pulling out a gag she stuffed it into Pinkie’s mouth suppressing her screams using one of the scalpels to ‘nail’ the gag into place. As the wounds cleared up her double started screaming at her at the top of her lungs while alternating between stabbing and punching the prone Pinkie Pie.




“You always treat life as if it’s full of rainbows and butterflies. And you deny me! Always denying me! Trying to see the good in life while ignoring all the bad! What do you think was going to happen when we finally snapped and I was set free? When all the darkness and horror you’ve suppressed came to the surface? YOU CAN’T RUN THIS TIME PINKIE PIE!!!!”




Her double stopped for a moment her body covered with ichor and gore. As the wounds came and painfully healed slowly breaking the mind of Pinkie. She was in shock from the raw violence that she was just sprung with. Coming for her out of the left field. “I’m going to let you think about what you did to me. To yourself before I start in again. I hate you Pinkie Pie and when I’m finished with you, you’ll hate you too. Then I’m taking over. I don’t know how but I won’t let a weakling like you have control over our body.”




Why is this happening? Did I really make that thing in me? I must have. She said she was me and looks like a duller version of me. Like when I get sad, or I loose me good cheer. If anypony can hear me please don’t let me die in this place. I’ll be a better pony I promise.




By this time her double came back. “Let’s get started again shall we?”




Straddling Pinkie Pie, Dark Pie started violently beating and stabbing her again. The rooms ability to heal physical damage while leaving behind the mental damage made this excruciating to poor Pinkie as the blows kept coming. Dark Pie laughed at Pinkie’s pain. In between each blow she spoke to her victim.




“You know what? You should’ve admitted when you were angry, scared, or even feeling anything other than happy. You should never have denied me for all those years. Ever since you turned eight you’ve been pretending like the world runs on good cheer. As if all the bad things from your past never happened. But they did, and I hate that you never gave me the attention that I deserve.”




But I didn’t know that you existed! I would’ve tried to be your friend if I knew.




“Oh! That’s a funny thought Pinkie! You are everypony’s friend. What about all the times they hurt your feelings, or when you feel sad about something and show everypony a big smile. You know what I’ll give you that smile right now.” She said as she gave Pinkie Pie a glasgow grin.




Pinkie Pie by now had succumbed to shock and fainted. Her wounds were closing up as pain racked her body. Dark Pie laughed and said to herself, “If anypony were to clap for you a special pony would appear to save you. But I don’t hear any clapping. Do you?”




From the multi-verse through the fourth wall. All the ponies who clapped, and all those who cared about Pinkie Pie broke the rules of the spell and summoned Apple Jack to save her. Apple Jack who at this time was worn out from facing her double was horrified to see her best friend strapped to the alter with her double straddling her. Apple Jack saw what Pinkie Pie thankfully did not. Around Pinkie Pie were remnants of severed limbs and chunks of flesh from the furious frenzy that was Dark Pie’s wrath. That covered the alter and surrounding areas like a macabre modern art painting. As her double looked at Pinkie she screamed in rage bolting to Apple Jack. Who promptly turned 180 degrees and gave her a mighty buck.




As her double flew, she hit the alter with her neck at an odd angle causing her head to spin. As the head started to slowly snap back in to place inch by inch. Apple Jack rushed and grabbed the injured Pinkie Pie. Her coat by this time was pure white and her mind snapped. She with the last remnants of her sanity looked at Apple Jack, “Thank you for saving me, but put me on top of my double there is something I have to do.”




Hesitatingly she did as she was asked. But promised herself that if her double did any funny business she’d buck her into the afterlife. As Pinkie Pie landed on her double with a dull thud. She nuzzled her, “Listen up me. I promise that I will never again deny you. I see just how much I was hurting us, hurting you. I don’t want anypony to suffer that includes you. I promise that I’ll be as honest as Apple Jack to myself and others. Cross my heart, hope to fly, stick a cupcake in my eye.”




Her double looked at her and said. “That’s an unbreakable oath. I’ll hold you to that. Because next time you give birth to me nopony will save you.” With that the room faded as Apple Jack picked her back up.




As they walked to the next room. Pinkie Pie’s sanity fled her and all she could think about was staying close to the Pony she saw as her savior. As long as she was with Apple Jack she’d be ok. And with that everything became a blur.