I could not belive my eyes. the mare that had made my first day in Equestria so miserable stood before me. And worse yet she was not alone. Another female of equal height looked on, her muzzle twisted in a sneer.
The creature wore a green dress, her pelt a dark grey that blended perfectly with the cave. Her hands possessed sharpened digits that gleamed dangerously. Her hair a toxic green oddly enough with circular holes cut though it. And most importantly a jagged horn that looked better for impaling than performing magic.
She examined me disgust evident on her face. Her insect like wings fluttering in annoyance. Her body whilst lean around the stomach and arms was far less around the breasts rear and legs, each perfectly proportioned as I admired her stunning form.
"Hmm Chrysalis looks like the little fly came of his own accord." Nightmare Moon chuckled. The mare beside her merely rolled her eyes.
"Be quick I don't doubt that his friends will eventually look for him!" The creature replied. Nightmare Moon gave a grin her eyes fixated on me. In the blink of an eye I was pinned, Nightmare moon tearing at my water logged clothes with a primal hunger. Eyeing my smaller frame as she tore my shirt from my body. It had to be a nightmare, it had to be! How could she still be alive? Twilight promised me she had been killed. How could she be here? Jolted by her yanking at my trousers I reacted.
"Get off." I screamed, lashing out wildly not caring I frantically tried to free myself. Grinning the mare continued to fondle me, unperturbed by my actions. I continued to struggle refusing to lay down and submit as she continued to try and undress me. I cried out for help. Calling out for my friends, Twilight anyone who could save me.
"Oh someone is feisty." She laughed, her hand slipping down my trousers as I felt her caress me.
"GET OFF OF ME." I screeched pushing her back. Collapsing I scurried back until my back was pressed to the wall hoping she would let her guard down and allow me to escape.
"I'm warning you. Stay back... Or else" I threatened my voice barely a whisper, a lump forming in the back of my throat. The demon looked on with amusement, crawling towards, a sadistic demon closing in on her prey. Like that night months ago I was once again defenseless.
"Or else what? " She grinned leaning down her face mere inches away from mine.
In what many would consider a cowardly move, I bawled up my fist and sucker punched the bitch. The mare recoiling as the shock caused her to stumble backwards. Landing on her ass hard the mare gave a small hiss, gingerly touching her cheek.
Petrified I looked on eyes wide as the mare looked up at me. A frown plastered across her face. Seconds trudged by, my heart pounding in my ear as I waited. Any second she would recover from the shock and tear me limb from limb. A brief calm washed over me.
"You've gotten stronger, nearly killing a stallion and now once again injuring an alicorn. You may yet prove to be useful!" Standing she again approached me forward eyeing my exposed chest. "But I'm afraid like last time. you are going to pay dearly for that." She finished, running her tongue along her serrated teeth, I gave an involuntary shudder. Leaning in she inhaled her body giving a small shudder. I hope those little whores down in Ponyville have toughed you up. I would hate for you to get hurt like last time." She finished sweetly. Gently stroking my face almost lovingly.
Maybe it was stress, maybe it was the fact I was feverish. But in that moment I wanted nothing more than to wipe that grin off her face. Pushing myself up I roughly grabbed the mare by her dress yanking her down as my lips crashed against hers. The mare gave a startled cry her body tensing before a light moan escaped her lips. Pushing though her lips our tongues met with hatred and passion. The mares arms wrapping around me as I pushed her onto the ground.
"I want you now!" She hissed punctuating each word with a kiss. Grinning I gave her ass a sharp slap still green when it came to foreplay but my sloppy work seemed to please the mare. Maybe this was me trying to get back at my so called friends a fucked up way albeit.
Nightmare Moon gave a muffled cry of pleasure in response. , our tongues dancing in passion as I grabbed her ass. Pulling her closer I found myself wedged between the freezing cold wall and the burning warmth of her fur. Her soft lips caressed mine almost lovingly as our hands explored the other.
Her hands, none to gently racked my body, leaving small cuts on my body. I hook my arm under her right leg, pushing it aside allowing me to access her plump lips. Caring not if she was ready or not, I thrust forward, hilting her as she whines in delight. Her walls entrap me, the cries of pleasure lost over the roar of thunder.
Like a vice, Nightmare Moon's leg latches around my body using me for support as she bounces atop me. Her arms wrapping around my shoulder, her free standing leg shivering from her desire and strain of the position. Our drenched bodies met again and again renewing our cries of passion as each slap brings a fresh wave of pleasure. The bitter cold seems to evaporate, the pleasure blocking out the wind and rain. Her silken fur warming my naked form.
She flirtatiously winks as her elegant hands clasp around my head bringing my face to hers. Her tongue runs up the side of my face, matting my cheek. her soaked fur tickles my body, her arousal trickling down me as the wet slaps of skin on skin echoed around the desolate cave. Pivoting, I push her against the cold wall her body arching as her bare form touched the muddy rock side. She gently nibbles my neck her teeth leaving small love bites as I cheekily smacked her ass. Her gasp of shock muffled my light chuckling
“Naughty,” she grunted as my fingers massaged her fur. My hand traces the delicate texture of her majestic wings as they wrap around me, encasing me in a feathery cocoon.
Nightmare Moon was surprisingly gentle, her aggressive dominate streak seemingly non-existent as she pulled me onto the floor lying beneath me as I built a steady rhythm her limbs snaking around me as she held me tight given me little maneuverability. She swirls her finger around my chest the gentle pattern relaxing as I gently brushed a stray lock of her mane aside, her eyes shining in the low light.
“You have gotten better,” she jibed as I hungrily kissed her again, biting her lip. Chrysalis watched with fascination as she nervously rubbed her arm her face showing distaste as we ignored her withering looks. Chrysalis looked turned on herself her hand caressing her own body as she tried to hide her arousal.
I slammed into Nightmare Moon in a violent rhythm. My lust for her body increasing my boldness as I briefly dominated her, my smaller frame able to keep up with hers as sweat poured from my body matting our already filthy frames as the throws of passion claimed us.
“Ah you’re so perfect,” she giggled as I stared at her in fear of her bubbly personality that's scaring me. Her soft borderline caring look actually scared me more than her homicidal streak. Or so I thought her eyes darkened as her grip tightened around my shoulders, the bones creaking as her steel grip threatened to break my shoulder blades. Her mouth latched onto mine drawing blood as she bit my lip my eyes widening as panic set in. She was getting aggressive as I feared for my body as our once smooth rhythm was distorted, her legs forcing me to go faster as she grew restless.
“Harder you bastard!” she roared, causing me to flinch as she rolled me onto my back her hips slamming into me as my body dealt with the strain. Her aggressive nature seemed to only worsen, her hands racking down my body as Chrysalis at times had to restrain her from nearly killing me. My body was brutally battered but still able to perform and did all it could to prevent the enraged mare killing me. Her first orgasm hit her causing spasms to shoot through her body as her walls clenched, fluids soaking my pelvis as I gasped in pain. Her ruthless thrusts calmed as her eyes softened brimming with tears as she gently hugged me.
“I’m so sorry,” she sobbed, her body shaking as Chrysalis looked on, mortified. I was confused and above all else horrified at the mare breaking down before me, her eyes swollen and puffy. This was the demon that still gave me nightmares. A sobbing mess, was what had struck fear into me.
I shakily caressed her, wishing to avoid her anger as I comforted my captor. Terrified and confused by her arbitrary mood swings, I was unable to do anything other than hope her unpredictable mood swings did not result in her turning violent and deadly.
Nightmare Moon's fidgeting made her body rub up against me resulting in me getting hard as I grimaced. With a small "oh" she looked down a wicked smile flashing across her face. All beat far more gentle the mare lightly shoved me to the ground her hands pinning mine over my head as she inhaled, drinking in the scent of lust and fear I was given off. Lowering herself I gasped as the nip of the cold was extinguished against her blanket like fur, her body helping to stave the cold as she mounted me.
‘What the fuck is wrong with her!’ I mentally winced as her hands molested my body no part left as her hands glide across my sore frame.
“Again, do me again, harder... please,” she begged, her extensive lustful moan of passionate desire contrasting my fear.
I submitted to her, fear of being disemboweled insuring my cooperation with the mare as time and time again she slammed her body down onto me. Her delighted moans drowning out mines of pain. Chrysalis had a look of disgust and amusement as Nightmare Moon degraded herself, her royal neutral attitude gone as she pleaded for me to get her off.
“AH, ah, ah, ohhhh fuck me!” she moaned her lips grasping mine as once again I found my bleeding tongue being dominated by hers. We reach our respective peaks the feeling deep as she collapses on top of me. I gently prod her stomach as she growls making me cautious and suspicious. My heart races as I gasp for breath her rough love making having ruthlessly bruised and exhausted me. Her gentle breathing cuts off as she tears herself of me running outside as retching is heard, her body heaving as she vomits.
My horrified suspicions are correct as I realize how much shit I’m in,
‘She’s pregnant’ this thought terrifies me as the lingering question of ‘Is it mine?’ pesters at the back of my mind.
“Is there anything you want to tell me?” I ask as she blinks in, confusion her eyes narrowing as she covers her body, my staring at her stomach obvious as she blushes.
“No, why would you ask?” she asks, her tone sharp as I look at her skeptically.
“Eh, you know you look slightly bigger?” I cautiously probe as she bares her teeth.
“How dare you, so what if I have put on weight, it’s not my fault, I have been eating healthily, but it won’t stop and these damn cravings!” she cries in frustration as she collapses on the ground her emotions running wild as she rants, “I keep vomiting and I feel sick and sore all the time!” she bawled as she gently massaged her stomach, her childish moaning not unsurprising as I remember my best friends Jodie’s pregnant months. Walking towards her I carefully extract my hand rubbing her stomach soothingly as my hand strokes her chin.
Lightly pinching her cheeks I force the mares eyes up to meet mine. In that moment I held no anger for her or disgust.
“You're pregnant.”
At first a chilled silence fills the cave, Chrysalis watching the two of us intently as for what I assume is the first time in her life, Nightmare Moon is left speechless. her mouth parts in an O shape. Her eyes showing the tidal wave of emotions going though her head. Letting go of her cheek I stand back, fearful that she will over react.
“No, that is ridicules." She mutters, shaking her head to reaffirm her statement.
"The signs are all there." I reply neutrally, part of me feeling bad that she had also raped a stallion. there is no way I can be pregnant I am the mistress of the night. A god. There is no way something like you could impregnate me. ” her weak protests are cut off by Chrysalis steeping forward her horn glowing a sickly green as I step in front of Nightmare Moon.
"Easy no need to get violent." I replied Chrysalis rolling her eyes as she steeped forward.
“Move you fool, I am going to confirm you suspicious since this foal seems clueless!” Chrysalis snapped smacking me away as I gingerly nursed the welt that she had left on my face. Her eyes dulled as she looked at Nightmare Moon, her body rigid as the spell worked its course. Chrysalis gave a small gasp as she looked at Nightmare a look of horror on her face.
“As I suspected she is pregnant, but it is more than that. She is pregnant with an Alicorn foal!” she expressed her eyes wide as I looked at her with an oblivious look.
"And that is good, I assume?" I piped up the two giving me an incredulous look.
It is impossible you fool, only two Alicorn’s can have an Alicorn foal, any other species that mates with an alicorn results in the foal being born with the characteristics of the father!” Nightmare Moon panicky shouted her eyes wide as she looked at me.
"Maybe the stallion you fucked had alicorn in him?" I questioned, the two mares groaning as they gave me looks as if I was being an idiot.
“The spell isn’t lying, and be silent, stop trying to help. Nightmare Moon has only been with one male since her return. ” Chrysalis dryly stated her neutral expression withering away as she grinned viciously pointing at me.
"You are the father you fool." Chrysalis voice echoed around the cave leaving a stunned silence. I suddenly felt ill, my head spinning as I fell backwards. Landing on my ass with an oomph I looked back from Chrysalis to Nightmare Moon. This had to be a cruel joke. I was not even from this planet how could I possibly impregnate something that was a different species to me.
"Bullshit." Not exactly tactful. But it was all I could form as I shakily got to my feet. This was a lie the two were merely trying to pawn another ponies bastard child onto me. "I am not going to be trapped here looking after a bastard child with this bitch." I snarled, the two mares recoiling at the harshness.
"Do not be such a fool child. Do you really thing I would make this up?" Chrysalis spat, marching towards me as I backed up. "What I say is the truth, she is pregnant and you are the father." Chrysalis finished emphasizing her point by pointing from the nightmare to me. My eyes flickered over to Nightmare Moon though I wish they hadn't as I took in her broken, dejected look.
The creature that had installed terror into me looked like a kicked dog, her lower lip trembling as her matted naked form looked pitiful rather than dangerous. With a weak snap of her fingers, like when i had first met her, her clothes materialized onto her body, thought the armor and helmet were oddly missing.
I had to bite my lip to stop me from groaning as I spied a lone tear trickle down her cheek. Humiliated and scared she was in that moment, not the monstrous nightmare that had plagued my subconscious. She was simply a mare scared out of her wits and about to be a mother. A small part of me gave a reluctant sigh as I awkwardly moved towards her. A small part of Nightmare Moon returned as she fixed me with a weak sneer, one of her arms raising in an aggressive display. Reaching her I turned to face Chrysalis one of my arms lightly coming to rest on her shoulder in a half hearted display of support.
"Are you sure I am the father?" I croaked, my voice wavering as the changeling nodded. A cold realization of my situation seemed to kick in as my legs threatened to collapse. I was going to be a father. I wanted to scream, I wanted to throw shit about but stuck in a desolate cave all I could do was stare down at the mare that had been the source of all my problems. With a groan I made my decision. crouching beside her I gave her a weak smile.
"I guess we are both kind of fucked." I laughed weakly, feeling ill inside as nerves wracked my body. Sighing in relief the mare wrapped her arms around me, embracing me as I was pulled into her lap. With a content sigh she rested her chin on top of my head. I was scared, what did I know about being a father. Never mind being a father to child that might not even be human.
I was nineteen I knew nothing about babies. Hell I could barely look after myself. What was worse was that Nightmare Moon was most likely equally as clueless. Despite her age she was still a villain and i doubted that position came with parenting classes.
“How long does pregnancy for mares last?" I spoke up, deciding that it was best to start somewhere.
“Most mares take six months. Alicorn’s and changeling’s take about eight.” Chrysalis answered, sitting herself down opposite me her tail lazily flicking from side to side. I grimaced realizing that I had been in Equestria for roughly four months. So I only had four months to prepare. Where did I start, we were homeless, jobless and given Nightmare Moon was hated by most of Equestria it was not like we could just settle down with a nice cottage. I was stuck with a criminal that would most likely be executed for her crimes if she was caught.
A small voice at the back of my head wanted that. To watch as she was punished for her crimes. But at the same time despite what she had done it made me uncomfortable to even contemplate letting someone die. Did that mean I forgave her. No, I hated her for what she had done. But all I had to do was make sure she had a healthy pregnancy then take the child. I would not let a child be raised by one as hateful and spiteful as her.
For the moment my main objective was keeping myself alive and the child inside her safe. I was snapped out of my thoughts with Nightmare Moon giving a snarl. Yelping I was hoisted off the ground, her enraged features matching her cold tone as she glared at me. Shaking me slightly her eyes burned making me shiver.
“You did this to me,” She hissed.
"What? Fuck off." I cried out, affronted. " You were the one that fucked me." I snapped, the mare baring her teeth.
"Maybe if you had controlled your pheromones and not smelled like a bitch in heat, I would not have been struck with a brief spell of madness. Which is the only reason I would have ever mated with you." the mare retorted.
"Really you are actually going to try and blame me for you being a piece of shit?" I retorted. " I am sorry you were so weak that you could not resist. I forgot that you were a four year old." I spat, the mare dropping me before giving a harsh shove.
"You know nothing of ponies you fool so I suggest you keep your mouth shut before I decide to shut it for you." the mare snarled, Chrysalis having wisely left. "We are driven by instinct if you had had any sense you would not have wandered into a castle with a mare that has missed 1000 heat cycles and was on edge." She shouted back our voices slowly increasing in volume.
"I don't give a flying fuck about your heat, it was my first night in this shit hole so I did not even know what you were never mind that you had a 1000 year itch. And guess what I still don't care. You raped me," I roared. Spittle flew from my mouth as I panted for air angrily looking at the mare as she gave a stunned look.
" R-rape?" She whispered recoiling at the word. Almost afraid as she seemed to crumple before me. The look of disgust and loathing actually bringing a satisfied smile to my lips. "I did not, I am not a." She paused looking away, her hands balled up into fists. Neither of us spoke, the gentle rattle of rain hitting rock signaling the storm had eased up.
"I'm sorry." Nightmare Moon whispered, causing me to double take as I stared at her incredulously. of all the things I had expected her to say I never thought for a second she would apologies. " I never realized I had hurt you so badly." the mare finished her eyes meeting mine, fresh tears dripping down her face. " I just thought you were playing hard to get. I was not really going to kill you." The mare continued.
"You broke my ribs, you broke bones and laughed whilst I pleaded with you. I begged you to let me go. Humiliated myself and what did you do? You laughed and told me I was a thing. A thing to fuck and discard. How in the hell could you think I was playing hard to get." I replied incredulously. The mare licked her lips going to speak before wisely deciding to keep her mouth shut.
"That does not make up for what you have done. But if it is of any small consultation to you I forgive you." I sighed, rubbing my face as I yawn threatened to escape my lips. With a nod the mare propped herself up against the wall, her horn glowing as my trousers were flung in my general direction. Haven been spared the destruction of Nightmare Moon's nails, they were in relatively good condition.
"Thought you might want a bit of protection from the cold." She stated, looking at the rag that had once been my T-shirt before tossing it aside. With a small nod I sighed, surprised that instead of being drenched the trousers were actually dry. Given the mare an appreciative nod I hastily threw them on, sighing at finding some relief from the cold.
Despite the added warmth I was still freezing. My body shivering violently as I rubbed at my arms. Rolling over so her body was facing me the mare gave an amused smile at my situation. A small semblance of her attitude returning she smirked as she dainty patted the ground beside her. At first I flat out refused turning away as I tried to keep my pride in tact.
I was not about to cuddle up to her like we were a couple. I would freeze before I allowed myself to be humiliated like that.
"Look runt despite the tearful apologies from my hormonal state. Do not think I am suddenly doing this out of the kindness of my heart. I don't like you. But it will do neither of us any good if you freeze to death. Come I will keep you warm." she spoke up, rolling her eyes as I gave her a glare.
"Glad the feeling is mutual." I responded, shivering as I tried to ignore her laughter.
"For the sake of my sanity get over here before I drag you over, whelp." She snapped. Biting my lip, I weighed up my options. With a reluctant sigh I crept over to her. Gingerly sitting down, I flinched as the mare wrapped an arm around me pulling me into the warmth of her fur. Not happy about my circumstance, I still found myself melting in her embrace. The mare draping a wing over me as I was enveloped in warmth. An uneasy sleep came as I drifted off. the gentle patter of rain and the mares heart beat oddly relaxing.