Story
My name is Dismal Dapple. I was born a normal unicorn with a black coat and red and black striped mane and tail. I loved my mom and dad, but they never understood me or my black colored magic. All of the other fillies thought I was evil because I was so misunderstood.
One magical day, I got my cutie mark when I realized I just wanted to be myself. My cutie mark showed through, and it was me! It was so special that Celestia made me into the very first alicorn prince! My parents were excited, but all of the other fillies and colts were jealous of my powers, and bullied me, and I grew up without a friend.
Then, one day, a magical meteor fell towards the city of Canterlot. Celestia and Luna try to stop the meteor, to no avail. Even the elements of harmony were no match for the ever falling meteor.
Ponies held one another in terror as it looked like our entire world would be gone in a moment. I knew I had to try something. I stood on the highest hill I could find, using my magic and my belief in myself to help my magic. To the surprise of every pony, I stopped the meteorite that eluded the princesses. It barely touched my horn before it flung back into space.
The magic embedded in the meteorite transformed my body, imbuing me with a magic never before seen in Equestria, and I became the first bi-corn: an alicorn with two horns. With the transformation, Celestia dubbed.me with a new name: Alicornious: protector of all Equestria, and life was wonderful.
But, it wasn't meant to be. Not even a moon after my heroic deed, a terrible creature by the name of Hexbane came, jealous of my deed. He put a curse on me and my whole family. When my family and I were on our way to celebrate the anniversary with the princesses, we were in a terrible accident!
The flying carriage fell. I tried to catch my parents only to be caught by an anaconda with an elephant head. I could do nothing but watch as my parents were torn away from me.
Hexbane laughed. He told me that he was going to take everything from me, and his pet struck, biting my second horn right off. When I went to the princesses for help, they didn't remember my heroics. No pony did. Worse even, Celestia had no recollection of making me an alicorn. When I tried to explain it was due to my unique cutie mark, she raised an eyebrow at me.
I looked down to find my cutie mark had changed. Instead of being a miniature version of myself, it was a shattered mirror with fragments of myself, and both princesses believed me to be evil.
I had no choice but to hide in my family's expensive mansion outside of Canterlot, alone. Maybe I'm meant to be alone.
I thought that, but then, I found a magic page in my mailbox. The magic page can change anything. I just can't decide. Do I just get everything back, or should I get revenge?
[CHOICE]
> Get your life back. (Chaos)
> REVENGE! (Villain)
[ENDING A: CHAOS]
I write down my dearest wish. My parents are back, safe and sound. I am the hero of Equestria, and every mare loves me, but Hexbane still vexes me.
Still, we are ever vigilant in keeping our memories and my loved ones safe, finding guards against his hexes.
(+1 page for Chaos)
[ENDING B: VILLAIN]
I wrote down my dearest wish. The page glows, and I find myself in front of Hexbane, my fury in my eye. I have control of his pet, using the anaconda with the elephant head against him. He quickly becomes entangled just like I had, and…as they say, an eye for an eye…he's never seen again.
(+1 page for Villains)