Only a single day had passed since the absolute ticklish destruction of Pinkie Pie. The fact he didn't stop tickling her when she begged him to certainly influenced the way that she talked about the incident. Fluttershy in particular began getting slightly scared of the stories, thinking that she was going to be next on the list. Her friend Rainbow decided to stay over for the night, so the timid pegasus would feel more comfortable.
Little did they know that the changeling would turn this into a golden opportunity to double the fun...
It was around 11:50 PM, when Card was sneaking through the woods, being one with the shadows. The strong breeze was giving him trouble keeping his hood on. The next target was very clear. The element of kindness. She's already very sensitive emotionally. So that should physically also be the case.
Card arrived at her cottage. Light was still burning from inside, meaning that she was probably still awake. He sighed, as this was going to make things very difficult. Especially if her bear is around. The changeling sneaked around the cabin and stopped near a window, carefully peeking inside. There were Fluttershy and Rainbow, sitting near her fireplace while roasting some marshmallows.
The changeling's eyes widened. Not one, but two of his targets in one place. A mischievous smile appeared on his face and he went to plan his next move.
Card sneaked to the bedroom window and pushed the lock back with a crowbar. He slipped and when the window was opened, his tool dropped inside the house,making a loud noise.
Fluttershy squealed and quickly backed away into a corner.
"Eeep! Can you please go check what that was?!"
Rainbow sighed.
"Told you to keep all the windows closed. The wind probably slammed it shut. I'll go have a look..."
"But... All my windows are closed...?"
Fluttershy whispered to herself.
The rainbow mane colored pegasus put her marshmallows down and made her way towards the bedroom. Rainbow carefully opened the door and peeked inside. She could see that the window was wide open, but other than that, nothing was out of the ordinary. She went to close the window, but upon stepping inside, the door was closed behind her, as the little changeling came from behind the door, grabbing Rainbow from behind, putting a hoof over the athlete's mouth.
"Ah, ah, aah... You're not going anywhere dear."
Card grinned evily while levitating some ropes from his bag around Rainbow's hooves, beginning to tie her up.
"GHGHRP!"
Rainbow cursed behind the hoof on her mouth, beginning to struggle very hard, making it infinitely harder to restrain her. So he turned into Rainbow Dash herself and tickled her sides with his newly obtained blue wings, making Rainbow giggle in a high pitch behind his hoof. Nearly all her strength slipped away from under her hooves as the tickling made her go weak. Card used this opportunity to quickly bind her front hooves to her sides and her lower limbs together. Lastly, he put a piece of tape over her mouth and let go of her again, watching her struggle.
"Aww, you look super cute like that."
"MMMPGH CMMMMPPH!!"
Rainbow Dash kicked around in the ropes wildly, angrily thrashing in the tight restrainment.
"Hush, cutie. I'm gonna turn that frown upside down soon."
He evily smiled, leaving the room to go and bundle up Fluttershy as well, leaving Rainbow Dash to struggle in her bondage.
The disguised changeling went over to the still highly alarmed.
"We're in the clear."
Card said in Rainbow's form.
Fluttershy sighed in relief.
"Thank you for checking..."
The yellow pegasus sat back down by the fire.
"Say, how about a little game?"
Card suggested.
"To help you calm down."
"A game? But didn't we want to eat marshmallows now?"
Fluttershy asked.
"We can still do that afterwards."
The changeling said.
"Come here, I'll show you."
The shy mare went over to the impersonator of her friend, sitting down next to him.
"Now put this on."
Card said, showing her a white cloth.
"What do mean? How?"
She asked.
"Around your eyes. Like a blindfold."
The imposter answered.
Fluttershy stared oddly at the cloth.
"But, I won't be able to see anything... What if the changeling shows up?"
Card shook his head.
"Pff, as if! Even if, I'm here, aren't I? I'll protect you from the bad guys."
"Um... Okay..."
Fluttershy unsurely put on the blindfold.
"So... Uh, what's this game about?"
"Hold still for me please."
The changeling grabbed more from his rope bag and began tying Fluttershy's front hooves behind her back.
"Ngh...! What are you doing?"
Fluttershy asked, trying to stay still.
"You'll see."
The disguised changeling smirked, tying up the pegasus' hind hooves as well.
"I- I don't like this game, Rainbow... Can you at least remove the blindf- Mmmph!"
Fluttershy's request was cut off by a piece of duct tape being slapped onto her mouth. After this, he turned back to his normal form.
"Thanks for making it so easy for me."
Card Shark whispered softly, setting the yellow pegasus into a high state of panic.
"HHHHMP?!"
"Shh, calm down sweetie. I won't hurt you. I'm simply gonna take you and your friend somewhere, where we can have *lots* of fun."
He chuckled in a dark tone, putting the blindfold back onto the shy pegasus. After this, he went to go grab his other victim and blindfolded her as well.
With both mares securely tied up, Card levitated them alongside him while walking through the woods to his hideout.
Fluttershy kept completely still, not moving an inch. Rainbow on the other hoof struggled, kicked and cursed like crazy, trying her absolute hardest to loosen her bindings. This resistance was making him all the more eager to quickly get there and make her scream with the most devious tickling he can dish out.
Much like Pinkie, they could hear leaves moving, the lock being removed and the metal door being pulled open.
Then Card warped them both into his restrainment devices. Fluttershy was cuffed to the table while Rainbow was strapped into the chair. But her hooves weren't put into the stocks. The stocks were gone. Instead, the chair had a slight extension, so her hooves could be strapped to that, like a hoof chair. Their gags, blindfolds and restrainment simply fell to the ground, as it stayed in place while they were warped. Rainbow furiously struggled.
"You better let us go RIGHT NOW!"
She warned him.
"Pl- please don't do this..."
Fluttershy quietly begged.
Card smirked and pulled out a remote.
"Oh I will... Eventually. But for now, let's have some real fun."
He pressed something on his remote. The chair and table briefly vibrated before little robotic griffon claws came out of them, vigorously scratching their utterly exposed bellies. The adorable reactions were very delightful, as both of their expressions completely vanished into a forced smile, accompanied by some cute giggles. Rainbow's giggles being slightly louder.
"Stohohohohohohop ihihihihihihihihit ohohohohor yohohohohou'll behehehehe sohohohohohorry!!"
Rainbow Dash demanded, despite the tickling really doing a number on her.
"Nohohohohohohoho plehehehease nohohohohoho tihihihihihihihicklehes!!"
Fluttershy begged, bouncing up and down in the chair.
"Oh ladies, we're far from done."
The claws were working their way all over their sensitive tummies, properly scratching both upper and lower belly with clearly visible results. The two pegasi were helplessly laughing their heads off.
Card adjusted the settings and made the claws absolutely ravage their poor bellies. Rainbow especially went into into squeaky laughter quickly, rocking in the chair but to no avail.
"My, my, quite sensitive, aren't you?"
Card teasingly noted while watching Rainbow's adorable reactions.
"SHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUHUT UHUHUP!"
Blushing Rainbow protested in between fits of uncontrollable laughter.
"That's not very nice."
The changeling shook his head and pressed something on his remote control.
Little feathery drill shaped devices came from their respective restrainment furniture, beginning to spin lightning fast against the two pegasi's ticklish sides.
Wide eyed, Rainbow Dash and Fluttershy went on a whole new level of laughter, as Rainbow went from laughing, to screaming with uncontrollable laughter, while Fluttershy suffered a cute voice crack from the sudden increase in punishment.
"AHAHAHAHA! IHIHIHIHIHIHIHI'M STOHOHOHOHOHORRY! PLEHEHEHEHEASE STOHOHOHOHOHOHOP!"
The blue lightning fast athlete helplessly exclaimed as good as she could while laughing her flank off.
"IHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHI CAHAHAHAN'T TAHAHAHAHAHAKE IHIHIHIHIHIHIHIHIT AHAHAHAHAHANYMOHOHOHORE!"
Fluttershy sputtered in between a series of voice cracks.
"No can do, ladies. If anything, your demands just make me wanna tickle you harder."
Card smirked, doing something on the remote control before the feather drills began moving from their hips up to their sides, stopping at their hoofpits, tickling there also. After that they would move back down to their hips and repeat to cover all the spots.
It sounded like they were trying to form words, but at this point, it was simply impossible to make out, other than "Help" "Please" or the occasional "Stop".
The changeling was very pleased with his work.
"These machines are amazing. Gonna have to consider getting more of these. Wouldn't you agree?"
Card asked his ticklish guests, who were too busy laughing the whole whole forest down. The loudly squealing Fluttershy was looking with big teary eyes at herself how the claws were ruthlessly scratching her sensitive yellow tummy, while Rainbow Dash couldn't possibly keep any sort of focus.
"Now, let's add the last bit. The most fun part~"
Card flipped a switch, which made three roller brushes come down from the ceiling. A longer one at Rainbow's hooves and two smaller ones at Fluttershy's hooves, one for each hoof, as she was tied in an X position. A few seconds later, they began spinning slowly, delivering teasingly soft tickles to their exposed hooves. Rainbow was highly alarmed by this, as it was a known fact that she didn't like ponies touching her hooves. A lesser know fact was that it's because they're super ticklish. Though from Rainbow's more sudden panicking reaction, he knew what was up.
"Aww, what wrong Rainbow? You were spitting big words a few minutes ago. Nervous by the fact, that your ticklish little hooves are gonna get it good?"
The hooded changeling asked, as the roller brushes tickling their hooves picked up the pace.
He leaned onto Fluttershy's table.
"How would you rate this experience?"
The changeling held the remote to her laughing and screaming mouth like a microphone.
"Thanks for your feedback. I'll increase the tickling power by double the amount, as you said."
Both the ticked victim's ears twitched in utter disbelief from what they just heard, but sure enough, the roller brushes picked up an insane amount of speed, ruthlessly brushing against Rainbow and Fluttershy's sensitive little hoofsies.
Both were nonstop screaming, crying and laughing, which was music to the evil changeling's ears.
Rainbow looked like she was ready to fall unconscious at any second now, while poor Fluttershy's mane and tail were completely ruffled.
He left the claws scratching their soft tummies, feather drills tickling their sides and hoofpits and finally, the roller brush tickle torturing their hooves, before deciding what to do with these cuties...
(Please choose your outcome in the chapter selection.)