//------------------------------//
// Pinkie is the only one of the main 6 who didn't believe in Santa, but doesn't say anything because it brings everyone else happiness? 
// Story: What If... 
// by TheMajorTechie 
//------------------------------//

"Pinkie, what about you? What did you put on your wishlist to Santa?"

Pinkie froze up. "I... uh..." She stared at Twilight. "Nothing!"

"...Nothing?"

"C'mon, Pinks, it's Christmas! You can't possibly want nothing, right?" Rainbow Dash swooped down. "Like, me, I'm asking for a new pair of goggles, 'cause I kinda broke mine flying into that wall a few weeks ago."

Pinkie didn't respond.

"Pinkie, are you alright?"

The mare walked out of the room.





"Gummy, you know what it's like, right? I don't want to tell them!"

Gummy licked his eyes.

"They still believe in Santa, even though they're all grown up! Me? I walked in on Granny Pie putting my presents under the tree a loooong time ago. I... don't want to ruin things for everypony else."

Gummy blinked.

"You're right. It's just one little lie, right? And I can go and buy it myself after, so that it looks like I actually did get a present!"





Pinkie slammed the door open. "I KNOW WHAT I'M PUTTING ON MY WISHLIST!" She gasped. "I'm gonna ask for a new party cannon, three boxes of confetti, a big box of cake mix, a large wooden mallet, and a cute sweater for Gummy!"

Twilight looked away from her conversation to Pinkie, then back to the others again. "Yeah, nevermind, she seems fine now."

tbh tho she would probably go nuclear in studying Pinkie again to figure out what the heck happened.