“Just a little more further. No peeking.” Headmare Starlight singsongery says.
“I’m coming I’m coming. And I’m not peeking!!!” Kyle shouts out while he continues to follow Headmare Starlight to someplace secret, having on a blindfold so as to not know where he’s going.
“If I fall off a cliff and hurt myself really badly, all because I can’t see where I’m going, your taking the blame on this one hundred and ten percent.”
“Just one moment.”
Five more minutes until Starlight leads Kyle to a part of the Friendship School that he most likely doesn’t know about.
“In three, two, one... now take off your blindfold!”
Kyle uses both of his wings to untie the blindfold off, opening up his eyes to see that everypony (and creature) of whom he’d all ever known are in this room, all gathered together.
“Wha...?”
“Surprise! Happy birthday!!” Pinkie Pie and everycreature else shouts enthusiastically as Pinkie jumps right in front of Kyle’s face, what soon sounds like a million party cannons all going off at once occurs afterwards.
“You...-”
“Threw you an awesome party.” Rainbow Interjects.
“All for you.” Fluttershy said.
Kyle looks up from the two pegasi towards Princess Twilight, seeing her smiling at him.
“I don’t... words cannot...” Kyle stops what he’s trying to say, looking around at everyone in the room.
Everypony (and creature) that he’s ever met is here. Everyone who had ever interacted with him. Why, even Principal Clover is here. Looking still as unimpressed as always. But at least he has a smile on his face.
And there’s... Rose Streaks?
Rose sees Kyle looking his way, smiling and waving at him. Kyle blushing a shade of red never seen before.
“Well, you’re gonna blow out the candles or not?” Applejack snaps Kyle’s attention back to the six ponies all around a round table with a birthday cake on it.
“Oh yeah, yeah... candles. Candles?!”
“Uh huh,” Applejack replies back, “And don’t forget presents.” She directs his attention to a pile of presents in the back, all stacked neatly.
“Presents?” At that moment, something inside Kyle just, oh I don’t know, exploded(!). All of Kyle’s feelings that he had pushed down his whole life coming out. Kyle feels happy.
Kyle smiles a whole big smile, everyone looking at him with their own smiles.
***
“Aight, next present please?”
“Okay.” Starlight says as she levitates away Trixie’s gift to Kyle and brings him another present.
Brimming with excitement, Kyle takes hold of the present, ripping apart the wrapping paper as fast as he can.
“Oh well... this is awkward.” Kyle blushes a deep red as he sees that under all the wrapping paper is a puzzle. A fifteen hundred piece puzzle, when all pieces are connected reveals an image of a small, red barn.
There’s also a note taped to it saying that it’s from Rose Streaks.
“Oh uh... thanks.” Kyle says, smiling embarrassingly while blushing a light shade of red.