After Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day left for Manehattan, Ruby had a plan. "Sunshine." Ruby called to her.
"Yah." She answered, walking up to Ruby.
"Anything that happens can you promise to take care of the foals?"
"Yes, but what do you mean?" She asked, not knowing what Ruby was talking about.
"Just promise me. Please." Ruby asked again needing to make sure.
"Yes, of course I will. But what's going on?" Sunshine asked, worried about her friend.
"It doesn't matter now. I need to go." Ruby left, with Sunshine trying to figure out what she was talking about. Ruby went to the hardware store to buy an axe and a pick axe. After buying them she went to Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day's house.
She knew the house had a security system, and was only a matter of time before the police arrived. Breaking the door down with the axe, and rushing to the bath room she used the pick axe to break the floor. She was able to make a hole when the police arrived to arrest her.
One of them noticed the hole and looked inside to find Filly. "Hey, there's a pony down here!" He called. After having to use the pick axe to make the hole big enough, they grabbed Filly and pulled her out. They took her to the hospital.
The police told Twilight and Sunshine that Filly is at the hospital, and that Ruby has been arrested. Sunshine went to the hospital to see if Filly is okay, while Twilight went to the police station to talk to Ruby.
Ruby told Twilight how she found Filly and that it was Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day who took her. Twilight placed an arrest order to Manehattan on Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day.
At the hospital, Sunshine was still waiting to see Filly. She was being cleaned for being covered in water, pee and poop for over a week. After she was clean, Sunshine went inside to see her. "Hi Filly." Filly turned her head to look. "How are you feeling?" Sunshine asked. Filly turned her head back to stare at the ceiling. Sunshine was getting worried and sat next to her. Filly looked at her again, but then went back to stare at the ceiling.
In Manehattan, Ocean Rise was walking down the side walk when she was interrupted by a police pony. "Mrs. Ocean Rise?" He asked, assertively.
"Yes." She answered, questioning why he's here.
"Your under arrest."
Ocean Rise ran, after he said that.
He chased after her catching up quickly and tackling her to the ground. After reading her her rights, he took her back to the police station where Cloudy Day had already been arrested.
"I need to contact my lawyer!" She cried out.
"Don't worry I already spoke to him." said Cloudy Day.
They were taken back to Canterlot to face trial. Ruby's trial was on the same day.
Ruby was found guilty on "Breaking and Entering" and "Property Damage", but because of the fact she rescued Filly, she was given a lighter sentence of 2 years and a fine of 500 Bits.
Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day were found guilty on "Breaking and Entering", "Property Damage", "Foalnapping", "Foal Abuse" and "Resisting Arrest". They were sentenced to 38 years in prison and a fine of 157,000 Bits.