The next day, Snow Lotus was called as a substitute teacher and couldn't see Filly, Sunshine Velvet went to the school to talk to the principle about having Filly to start going there, Ruby Summer was at the grocery store shopping for food and all the other orphans were in school. Filly was all alone.
Filly heard a noise downstairs thinking it was one of them, until she heard the voices. "Make it look real Dear, we need to make this look like a robbery." Cloudy Day said.
"I know, but we need to find that, that … gerrrrr." Ocean Rise said, angrily. "I'm going upstairs to keep looking. You stay here and keep trashing the place." She said.
Filly was hiding under her bed listening the closer her mother came to her room. Filly just learned to speak, but right now she couldn't make a sound. Filly heard her mother enter her room, searching for her. Ocean Rise finally found her hiding. Flipping over the bed, Filly was paralyzed with fear. She couldn't run or scream, she was frozen, unable to move, completely at her mother's mercy.
Ocean took the garbage bag she had with her and wrapped Filly up in it. Filly tried to scream again but couldn't. "I've got her, let's go!" She called to her husband.
"Good." he answered. They ran away back to their new house carrying their foalnapped daughter. Filly didn't know where they were taking her, but she knew it wasn't good. She found out when they poured her out in a small cement hole. She could barely move. She saw 2 pipes until they put a cement lid on, and sealing it with wet cement and tiles, finishing the look of the bathroom.
The 2 pipes were attached to the toilet and sink. Cloudy day went first using the toilet and flushing it having it pore on her face and body with piss, and washing his hooves with hot water, having it burn Filly when it went down. It was mostly the same with Ocean Rise, only she shit and used cold water freezing Filly and having her face covered in shit. Ocean Rise leaned over the sink. "Better get use to that Dear." She said evilly. "Because that's all your ever going to get to eat and drink for the rest of your pathetic miserable existence."
Ruby Summer came back from the grocery store. She saw that the door was opened and thought Sunshine Velvet was back. Walking in, she dropped her bags when she saw that there was a robbery. She ran upstairs to Filly's room calling her name. Filly's room was also a mess. She checked the other rooms looking for Filly but not finding her.
Sunshine arrived shortly after. Seeing the bags, she called their names. "Ruby! Filly!" Ruby ran downstairs hearing her name called. Ruby and Sunshine ran to each other.
Panting nervously Ruby asked "Have you seen Filly?"
Sunshine answered, "No."
"I can't find her anywhere." Ruby said, still panting. "We should get the police." She said.
"I'll tell Princess Twilight, you tell the police." Sunshine said.
After school the police were still at the orphanage. Twilight, Spike, Ruby, Sunshine, and the orphans went out searching for Filly but found nothing.
It's been a week and all Filly had to eat and drink was from the toilet and sink. Everypony was still out searching for her. Ruby went to her friends house asking if they saw her, not knowing they were the ponies who foalnapped her.
They invited her in for tea. Ruby went to use the bathroom. When she went to wash her hooves, she thought she heard a coughing sound coming from the sink. Getting suspicious, she didn't wash her hooves. Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day were outside the bathroom waiting. "I think you forgot to wash your hooves Dear." Ocean said.
"Oh, sorry. I forgot." Ruby said. Going back inside and closing the door. Ruby wasn't sure if what she heard was what she heard. After washing, she listened closely to the sink. She definitely heard coughing.
Ocean Rise and Cloudy Day told Ruby they had to leave in two days for a conference in Manehattan.