The lightening repeated over and over outside. The rain drops danced in a violent motion to the rhythm of the pain down below. Forced to head the direction given to them, their ending had already been decided by the wind.
Pinkie Pie groaned in agony.
"I'm never gonna forget to eat ever again."
Checking that the coast was clear, she left the safety of the table and exited the dinning room into the kitchen. She had to cover her eyes as she drew close to Rainbow Dash. The smell was unbearable, yet her stomach continued to guide her forward. She pushed the door to find the kitchen in a similar state as that of her dreams. The walls were decorated with pony blood and the organs of her friends hanged from the ceiling. She couldn't keep it in any more. She ran to the sink and pulled herself over it to vomit, but she stopped. The sink was filled with blood and two blue eyes looked out at her. Pinkie Pie just puked where she stood. Her dream may have had more blood, but these were the death of her friends she was experiencing.
She wiped her mouth and heard the swooping of a knife behind her. By instant, she ducked and watched as a bright silver edge fly by her head. She turned expecting someone behind her, but all she saw was the shadows of far side of the kitchen. She swore someone just...
The knife came at her again from her right. She dodged it, but it quickly changed direction catching her right leg. She fell backwards and began backing away from the knife. That when she noticed the magic on the handle.
"Twilight?"
"Hiya Pinkie Pie! Or should I say other Pinkie Pie. I think that's what I called you last time."
The voice came from the shadows, she couldnt tell where. What she could tell was that the voice was from her dreams. The one who butchered so many ponies. The one who tried to kill her while she was sleeping. The one who she killed right in front of her.
"It's been a long time. Well for me at least! You don't know how board I've been!"
"You... You... You..."
"Died? Oh yes, and I don't blame you. I mean if I really wanted to, I could have killed you first! But I used the number system again, then every pony has a chance to have fun with me!"
"How are you alive? Where are you?"
"Even I don't know that fully, but I have an idea. Your friends who helped you, I think she didn't know that when she could go in, things can come out."
Twilight walked out right in front of her with the knife floating besides her. Or whatever 'remained' of Twilight. Her mane was puffed up like Pinkie Pie's, but it was mixed with blood and other colored hairs. She had also reconstructed half of the original outfit she wore when they met.
"Oh, do like my work? Rarity thought it was to die for. I got some blood on it though since i didn't have my proper tools."
Pinkie Pie stared in horror to see all her friends combined into one piece. A necklace of Rarity and Celestia's horns hung around her neck; her tail was a combination of all her colorful victims'; a cyan and white wing laid attached to her attire; and finally Pinkie's eyes fell upon the cutie marks.
They were all there with the exception of one.
"What have you done to Fluttershy?"
"Her? I actually don't know. I think she must have ran away before we could have any fun. Her lost, right?"
Pinkie Pie finally backed into the wall behind her. There was no escape this time.
"How long have you been in her?"
Pinkie Pie was grasping at straws as her mind struggled with what to do.
"Oo, are we playing games to distract me! How fun! Well I was only able to actually control her for the past three days, but I thought of my plan for eternity... Or however long I was dead for. I invited her to the castle before brining any of you here. She came willingly and didn't expect any bad from me. During dinner I drugged her meal with sleeping powder."
The 'other' Pinkie Pie boasted with pride of her work.
"It wasn't easy to drag her down to the cellar where my medical equipment was located. I also to play with her while she was asleep because of her magic powers. It wasn't much fun until I though of how I could use her body for; I thought you would have liked the decorations I set up for you!"
The knife floated above the real Pinkie's head. It was waiting for the finale command.
"When we arrived, I was sad that no one liked my master piece. Rainbow Dash seemed scared of it even. While I traveled up stairs, I decided to cheer her up by acting out a good book. She knew every line and expression by heart, I was very impressed."
Pinkie Pie didn't want to remember the horrors of that book ever again...
"I wanted to finish all the wings off, but as you guessed, Fluttershy must have scampered off. I used the group to explore outside, but she wasn't there. That's when I decided to set the fuse of the TNT below the bridge."
She shook her head to get some of the blood off her and continued her story.
"When we got back, Applejack and you found the secret passage ways of this lovely home. So I flipped a coin and decided it was Applejack's turn. It was unfair to not give her a chance so I gave her a time based challenge. I think I gave her the wrong impression because she thought I was you. It didn't help that I left her a walkie-talkie to contact us either. When Rarity heard Applejack blaming you, she attacked you and I couldn't let that happen. I decided to lock her up while I finished with Applejack."
She pointed at the sink, where Pinkie Pie saw the eyes.
"When I finally came to Rarity in my beautiful dress, she called me ugly. I decided to show her true ugliness and gouged her eyes out. Funny, she didn't appreciate it that much."
The knife began to press upon Pinkie Pie's cheek.
"You know, friendship is magic! Look how useful it is, I won't cut myself this time."
This looked like the end for Pinkie Pie. She closed her eyes and wished she could apologize to everyone for what she did.