The Mysteries of Love

by MysteriousStranger


What's Promised is Due

Trixie's P.O.V.

I felt free to sleep until noon. It was Sunday, after all. Besides, I couldn't fall back to sleep yesterday after Rarity woke me up early in the morning. She was so worried about how her parents would react to our relationship and so was I. The real reason I couldn't go back to sleep yesterday was because Rarity spread her anxiety to me. I'm relieved that her parents turned out to be so supportive, and friendly! They immediately made me feel welcome. They asked me question after question. In the end, Rarity's mother found out she helped my brother. Luckily, they didn't ask me about my parents yet. It could have really ruined the atmosphere. Rarity will take care of that. I know it's also painful for her to talk about it, but it's better this way.

I decided to start the day with a walk. I'll think on what to do next after returning. I got changed and combed my hair into a ponytail using the hairpin Rarity gifted me. She wasn't even here, but she still managed to make my day.

I left my apartment and walked around the city. I did around an hour of exercise, until it started to wake up my appetite. I stopped by a convenience store to buy a sandwich and juice. I finished my sandwich fast, threw the garbage in a trash can and started my way back home while I drank the juice.

Once I got back home, I took a shower and got changed. I sat on my couch and pulled out my phone. My intention was to call Rarity, but my eyes shifted to Sunset Shimmer. I don't know why, but I felt the urge to call her. But what really was weird was that I don't find her as annoying as before. I still don't want to meet the rest of her friends, but Sunset herself was... okay. So was that Fluttershy girl, but I noticed she was very nervous when we met.

In the end, I decided to call Sunset first. I heard the tone a few times, but she eventually picked up. "Sunset Shimmer... hello?"

"Trixie?" she was confused at first, but I heard her chuckle. "You didn't even let me answer first. Do you always have to be the first?"

Her comment made me smirk. I was lucky she wasn't able to see that. "Yes, well, that's how Trixie does it. So, what are you doing?"

"I was feeding Ray. He's a leopard gecko. My pet."

"A pet? That's... nice. I have never had one."

"They're amazing! My girlfriend, Fluttershy, helped me to find a pet. Ray and I had a connection since the beginning."

"Fluttershy? Is that the friend you and Rarity have in common?"

"Well... y-yes. We were friends for a while before we became a couple." she sounded nervous. I knew the feeling very well.

"I remember that you told me that you liked someone you would never date. You were talking about her?"

"I thought I didn't deserve to be happy, after everything I did. I wasn't kind to Fluttershy either. But Rarity convinced me to express my feelings. When I returned from Equestria last week, Fluttershy and I talked. I couldn't believe my ears when she said she liked me. We hugged, and... oh, sorry. I'm probably boring you."

"No, it's fine. Congratulations!" I was being honest to her. I would have interrupted her if I was bored.

"Thank you, Trixie. Anyway, have you met Rarity's cat?"

"She has a cat? How come I'm finding out now?" Why didn't she tell me? Why haven't I seen the cat? maybe it's because the house she lives in is so large.

"Her name is Opalescence. She doesn't show much interest on Rarity, no matter how hard she tries."

"Something's definitely wrong with that cat. She doesn't know how lucky she is to have Rarity as her owner."

"Some cats are like that. You don't own the cat, the cat owns you."

"Sounds like dogs are a better option."

"Everyone has their preferences. Maybe you can ask Rarity about Opalescence."

"I might." There was an awkward silence to follow. This was the longest time I spoke with Sunset through the phone. I didn't know what to say now.

"So, uhh... around a week ago, Rarity left school early. She said it was an emergency. She didn't tell me exactly what happened. Just that it had to do with you. I, umm... I hope everything's okay, whatever it was."

"Oh?" It seems like Rarity said the truth. Even when we weren't on speaking terms back then, she kept her promise. I shouldn't be surprised. It was important for her that I meet her parents. She really wanted my approval. Her anxiety couldn't be faked. Rarity really wants to be with me. Why is there still small parts of me that think she will betray my trust one day? It must be because of her. My first... 'love'. It has been years, but my... ex is still causing me problems. Why can't I forget her?!

"Trixie? Oh, no... I shouldn't have brought that up..."

"No, wait!" I got too focused on my thoughts. Sunset almost hung up.

"Trixie, listen, I'm sorry for mentioning it..."

"It's not that. I got... distracted." I was still surprised that I didn't want Sunset to feel upset. "I... appreciate your concern, Sunset. Everything's better."

"I see. I'm glad to hear it. I want you to know that I'm here if you need anything, okay?"

"Yes, I know. Th-thank you, Sunset."

"You're welcome, Trixie."

"I have to... do something. I suppose I'll see you tomorrow."

"Okay, I understand. Goodbye."

"Bye." I hang up and stared at my phone for a while. Until a couple of weeks ago, I could barely stand Sunset. Now, I'm voluntarily calling her just to talk. I... care about her. I guess this whole friendship wasn't a bad idea, after all.

I scrolled through my short contacts list and called Rarity. She picked up almost immediately.

"It's a beautiful day, but not as beautiful as you."

"Aww, thank you, Trixie!" I immediately realized that it wasn't Rarity. It was her sister the one who picked up. How? I don't have her in my contacts list. I don't even know if she has a cell phone of her own.

"Sweetie Belle?"

"Hi, sis in-law! How are you?"

"I-I'm... confused. I dialed Rarity's number, right?"

"Sweetie Belle! Give me my phone back!" I heard Rarity's voice in the background.

"But, I want to talk to her!"

"I gave you her phone number. You can call her later."

"I want to talk to her now!"

"Later! Give me my phone!" I heard the sounds of someone grabbing the phone by force. "Don't steal my phone again. That wasn't nice. Hello? Trixie?"

"What was that all about?"

"I'm sorry. Sweetie Belle snatched my phone when I said you were calling me. I regret doing it."

"Don't worry. It was kind of cute. Is she okay?"

"Yes, don't worry. She's sitting on my bed right now."

"Tell her I say hi!" Rarity's sister said from the background.

"You already greeted her!" My girlfriend said to Sweetie Belle before returning to the speaker. "I'm not mad at her, don't worry. Anyway, I was hoping you would call me..."

"Oh, really? Any particular reason?"

"I just wanted to hear your voice."

"W-Well, I'm..." I had to clear my throat. I think I'll never stop getting breathless as long as I'm with her. I relaxed and regained my composure before continuing. "Trixie knew that. That's why she called you."

"Charmer. What's in your mind, Trixie?"

"You mean, besides you?"

"T-Trixie!" I smirked when I heard how nervous I got her. Two could play this game.

"Are you free this afternoon?"

"Yes, I am. Why?"

"I think it's time we have that date I'm owning you."

"Wonderful!" Rarity sounded very excited. I think she didn't plan to sound so overjoyed. "I-I mean, that sounds lovely. Where shall you be taking this lady?"

"I want to take you to the karaoke. I know we have been there already, but, this time it will just be the two of us." I want to do something special for her, but I need a microphone for it. The karaoke was the perfect place for what I have in mind.

"Yes, of course. Will you come here or we'll meet there?"

"We're going together. I'll go to your place."

"Okay. Send me a text when you're here. I can't wait."

"Me neither, Rarity. I'll see you later. Now, put your sister on the phone. There's something I wish to tell her."

"Okay. Sweetie Belle, Trixie wants to speak with you!" I heard the little girl cheering on the background. "Goodbye, darling."

"Bye." I waited for Sweetie Belle to take the phone.

"Hey, Trixie!"

"Hello, Sweetie Belle. If you have my number, you can call me whenever you want, you know?"

"Yes, but I got excited when you called Rarity. I couldn't help it. How's Clementine?"

"Better than when you visited him last week. They keep telling me that he will be released soon, but that 'soon' is taking forever."

"He seemed to be in a good shape. His arm was healed. Can't they give him a wheelchair and release him?"

"That's exactly what I'm thinking! I can take care of him at home. Rarity keeps saying that I should be patient, and that the doctors know what's best for him."

"We should probably listen to her. Anyhow, I better return the phone to Rarity. Will I see you later today?"

"If you want. Try to be around when I go to pick your sister up for our date." Sweetie Belle squealed all of the sudden, leaving me almost completely deaf from one ear. "See you!"

"Yes! See you! Goodbye!" I hang up and scratched my deaf ear. I should have known that she would react like that. She was adorable, always making me smile.

When I recovered my hearing, I stood up and headed to my room. I must choose what to wear during the date.


Fridge, fridge, fridge! I forgot to do the laundry! I only had what I was wearing. A dress and my favorite cotton jacket. This day didn't have a good start. At least I thought on tying up my hair into a ponytail. I'm not fan of this hairstyle, but Rarity likes it. The sun was still present. Our date had to be early since we have to go to school tomorrow. At least it was the last week with classes before Summer. Finally! One more week and I'll be able to spend more time with Rarity!

As we agreed, I sent her a text message when I arrived and waited patiently. When the door opened, it wasn't Rarity the first person I saw. Sweetie Belle rushed to me. I managed to see that she was sad before she hugged me tightly, burying her face on my belly. "Sweetie Belle?" The little girl said something, but her voice was muffled since she spoke into my belly. "What's wrong?" She was happy when I spoke to her through the phone earlier today.

"I told her and my parents about... you know..." Rarity said as she walked out with her arms crossed. She was wearing dark blue jeans, boots, a black jacket, and I could see part of a purple t-shirt, matching her hair.

"Oh..."

"You said it was okay that I told them. I did it after your call."

"I'm not saying it was wrong. I just wasn't prepared to be greeted like this." I smiled at Rarity, letting her know that I wasn't mad. When she returned the smile, I focused on her sister again. "Sweetie Belle, hey..." The child raised her head. She was sobbing and her eyes were wet. "Listen, it's okay..."

"No, it's not...!" she sobbed again. "It's unfair!"

"It was unfair..." I said as I knelt to be able to look straight into her face. "I'm never going to stop missing them. I'm wishing for my parents to be alive all the time, but all I could do is to move on. I try to avoid the subject as much as I can to not feel pain. I know that you're feeling upset, and I know that you just learnt it, but don't let your sadness control you. Help me to be happy."

"H-How?"

"Just be yourself. Your cheerfulness is one of the reasons I smile. Can you do that for me?" Sweetie Belle used her arm to clean her tears and nodded, smiling slightly. "You can do more. Let me help." I said before tickling her from her armpits. She started to laugh.

"No, no, wait! Trixie!" She kept laughing until I stopped tickling her. She looked at me before hugging me again. This time, a happy hug. I hugged her back before standing up. I glanced at Rarity and noticed that she had a warm smile on her face. I grinned and opened my mouth to say something, but she walked towards me and kissed me on my cheek before embracing me. I put my arms around her waist and closed my eyes. I'll never get tired of her hugs.

"Let's go before it gets late." Rarity whispered. I nodded and stared at her into her eyes. I opened my mouth to try to tell her something again, but I heard a low giggle. Both Rarity and I shifted our heads to the direction of the sound to realize Sweetie Belle was still there with a big grin on her face. "Seems like you're in a good mood again, darling."

"Sweetie Belle!" Someone called from the door. We focused our attention on it to see that it was Rarity's mother the one who was calling the young girl. "Come on inside, dear! Trixie is only dating your sister, not both of you!"

"M-Mom!" Rarity blushed of embarrassment and quickly broke the embrace. I chuckled, but I didn't like that the hug ended so abruptly.

"Oh, don't worry, Rarity. Your father and I were just like you when we started dating. Always gazing into each other's eyes and always holding each other. I'm happy that I'm present to see you go on your very first date. My baby has grown!"

"Mom!" I chuckled again. Was I a bad person for finding Rarity's embarrassment amusing? I probably was, since Rarity glared at me. "Don't encourage her!"

"Aww, what if I kiss you on your cheek? Will you feel better?"

"Trixie!" Rarity pushed me, but in a playful way. I laughed, alongside Rarity's mother.

"I won't be taking any more of your time. Don't return too late." Cookie Crumbles said while Sweetie Belle ran to her side.

"Don't worry, Ms. Crumbles. She's in good hands."

"I'll take your word. I would hate having to release my husband on you, Trixie!" Rarity's mother joked before she and Sweetie Belle waved at us. "Have fun!"

"Bye Bye!" Sweetie Belle said. Rarity and I waved at them before turning around and walking towards the bus station. After hearing a door closing, I looked at Rarity and smiled at her, but she didn't return it.

"How can you smile after embarrassing me like that?"

"Come on, it wasn't so bad. What's wrong about showing affection in front of your parents?"

"It's... uhh... " Rarity looked away and remained silent.

"See? You don't even have a reason."

My girlfriend sighed. "Just, take my side next time, yes?"

"Okay. I'm staying neutral."

"Trixie!" I laughed when Rarity had the reaction I was expecting. She puffed her cheeks and avoided my gaze. She's so cute! I took my chance and took her hand. She gasped before looking at me.

"Don't tell me you'll be mad for the rest of our first date."

"I-I'm not mad..." Rarity said, visibly blushing. "Your hair... you look... astonishing."

"I had nothing to wear, so I thought on surprising you with this."

"It was a nice surprise." Rarity said as she stroked my hair with her free hand.

"You know... I can fix my hair like this all the time if you want..." Even though I didn't like it as much as my girlfriend did, I would use this hairstyle regularly just to see her smile.

"You don't have to, darling. I won't be the kind of girlfriend who tells you how to look or what to wear. Arrange yourself however you prefer." Rarity said before putting her arms around my own arm. "Something that trivial won't make my feelings towards you change." She rested her head on my shoulder as she said the last.

"R-Rarity..." Oh my gosh! She's so... so! I can't find the right words to describe how marvelous she is. I never thought a person like her would exist. I'm glad that I listened to my brother. I couldn't let my past relationship destroy my faith in love. Sometimes, though, I wonder if she's really into me or if she was only curious about how it felt dating me. After all, she never had feelings on another girl until we became close. Luckily, these worries were easy to ignore. I'm 90% sure she's really into me. I kissed her on her hand and we continued walking until we reached the bus station.


Rarity kept holding my arm even once we were inside the karaoke. She was forced to let me go when we found a table. The place was crowded, but that won't stop me from do what I have planned. They had the perfect song to properly express my feelings.

"So, we're just going to listen or we'll be part of the fun?" Rarity commented.

"We'll be listeners. We might join or not, who knows?" I said while trying to sound natural. Rarity didn't know that you could book a turn in advance. There was some time left before I climb the stage.

My girlfriend giggled before speaking again. "Alright, I might sing something. I'm actually not a bad singer."

"Me neither."

"I have heard you sing before, darling. Since things are different now, I would love to hear you." We smiled at each other before Rarity shifted her eyes to the stand. "I'm thirsty. Do you want something? Maybe a snack?"

"No, thank you. I'm good."

"Okay, I'll be right back." Once Rarity was far enough, I sighed strongly. I rejected the offer because I was too nervous to eat or drink, not to mention that I didn't want to throw up on the stage. I generally enjoy being the center of attention, but singing for Rarity in front of a crowd? I'm about to reveal my affection on Rarity in front of a group of strangers. But it will be worth it. After all, they don't know who we are. I don't see anyone from school around. "I'm back~" I almost gasped when Rarity announced herself with a melodic tone.

"That was fast."

"I was the only one to order. I know you said you didn't want anything, but... I asked for an extra straw. Just in case." Rarity's blush became more visible as she spoke. I smiled and leaned to kiss her on her cheek.

"Thanks." I said with a soft voice. Rarity giggled and took a sip from her drink. Seconds later, an employee climbed the stage and took the microphone.

"Alright, everyone! It's time to get this started! Be ready when I call your name. Remember, you can join the fun whenever you want by completing a short form which you can find on the table with your name and the song you're interested in singing. Without further ado, first, we have..." I stopped listening to instead focus on my girlfriend, who was taking a look at the form. The document was accompanied with a menu, similar to the ones in restaurants, to list all the available songs.

"'I'll browse to see if I find a nice song. Maybe we can make a duet! What do you think?"

"I-Umm... I..." my cheeks became warm. I would love to make a duet with her, but today wasn't a good idea. At least not before I dedicate a song to her. Rarity noticed my nervousness and giggled softly.

"What's the matter, darling? Are you afraid of sharing the spotlight with someone else?"

"That's not it! It's just... I-I would get distracted by your beauty."

Rarity's jaw dropped slightly and she blushed madly. "W-Well, I'm... is it me or is it getting hot in here?"

I laughed lightly and stared into her eyes. Then, I stroked her hair. She leaned her head and sighed happily. It filled me with joy hearing that she was enjoying it. Even though the music was loud, I could still continue my conversation with Rarity. "So, a little bird told me that you have a cat. When were you going to introduce me to her?"

"Who told you-?" Rarity's confusion didn't last long. "It was Sunset, right?" She asked with a smile.

"Maybe." I said as I placed my hand on the table. My girlfriend placed her own hand on mine before speaking again.

"Opalescence is... complicated."

"So I heard."

Rarity smiled again and continued. "I didn't introduce her to you because... she does what she wants. She doesn't sleep with me often and she only meows to me when she wants food or water. We could try to find her the next time you come to my house, if you want." Rarity said as she gently caressed my hand with her thumb.

"Cats are a mystery. That's why I prefer dogs. They do show move love."

"But they tend to have more energy. I don't want paw traces on my clean clothes."

"But cats love to rest on any surface, especially if said surfaces have extra cushions."

"That's why I keep all my clothes in my closet, darling. The doors remain closed at all times." Rarity took a sip from her drink while I glanced at the stage. I couldn't recognize the song the boy was singing, but he was putting his heart into it. Everyone was paying attention to him. I have the lyrics memorized. I hope I don't forget them when my turn arrives. For Rarity.

We watched three more performers. Neither of them were bad. Rarity moved her chair closer to me to be next to me while the people sang. I wasted no time to lay my head on her shoulder as soon as she was all set. I hope my heart could take all my happiness. Rarity offered me some of her drink and I accepted. My mouth was dry and I needed it.

“Thank you for participating!” The employee and the spectators applauded as the performer abandoned the stage. “Alright, next up we have a familiar name! She’s going to perform a classic song from a classic movie. Come to the stage, Trixie Lulamoon!”

There was a loud ovation after my name is mentioned. My brother’s reputation sure precedes me. Rarity looked at me, confused and surprised at the same time.

“Why didn’t you tell me you were going to sing?!”

“Make sure to get as close as possible.” I said before kissing her on her forehead and standing up. I walked towards the stage as everyone kept cheering. I took the microphone the employee gave me and gazed into the spectators to find Rarity. She found a spot right in the front row. Perfect! At this point, my heart was racing like never before. This was it. I took a deep breath and spoke. “Thank you, thank you! I want to dedicate this song to someone dearly important to me... My girlfriend.” There were more ovations as Rarity gasped. She must be blushing like crazy.

The music started. I danced a little until it was time to start singing. I focused on Rarity during the first four lines, then I started to walk around the stage as I continued to sing the rest of the song, this time focusing more on the crowd. I put my heart into it, singing every word with passion, like if I was in a concert. When I reached the chorus, I lifted a hand into the air and closed my eyes. Then, I put my hand on my chest. I didn’t open my eyes until the chorus was over. I walked around the stage again when the normal lyrics returned. I even pointed at some random people of the crowd. Some of them knew the song and even sang along. Right before the second chorus, I unzipped my cotton jacket. I kept my eyes opened on the chorus this time, but I still lifted my arm into the air. Then, when I reached the end of it, I focused on Rarity again. I didn’t see anyone else around her. It was just like if it was just her and me in the entire building. She was smiling from corner to corner, still blushing. With the next regular lyrics, I started to walk towards her. She opened her mouth, still smiling. When I was in front of her, I removed my jacket, knelt and threw it at her. She caught it and I winked at her, all without stopping singing. Then, I stood up and returned to the center of the stage. With the third and final chorus, I once again lifted my arm into the air, but I also walked around and danced more. I continued until I sang the last words directly to Rarity.

The cheers returned when the music was over. I returned the microphone to the employee before taking a moment to enjoy the applause. I just loved the way it sounded. I bowed at the crew before walking down the stage.

“I don’t know about you, guys, but I think she was outstanding! If only we had a prize to give her. Next up, we have…” I stopped paying attention to him when I saw Rarity approaching me. She had my jacket tied up around her waist. I smiled and tried to say something her, but she put a finger on my lips and used her other hand to grab mine. She lead me towards a door that lead outside, to a small ground balcony.

Once here, Rarity pinned me to a wall, with her hands on my waist, and kissed me on my lips. She took me by surprise, but I returned the kiss soon afterwards, closing my eyes. Nothing out of the ordinary until I felt Rarity trying to do something new with the kiss. I felt her… muscle. I opened my eyes and broke the kiss. I was blushing and surprised. “R-Rarity…? Did you just…?” My girlfriend didn’t change her expression. She was love dazed, completely lost in my eyes. She just muttered three words that almost made me faint.

“I adore you…” Losing myself in the moment, I placed my arms around her neck and kissed her passionately, returning the favor. Once again, I stopped caring about everything around us. It was just her and me. The small part of me that was still doubting about her feelings finally got silenced, permanently.