After several months of sewing her costume, it's finally October 31st in Ponyville. At 8:00, Fluffle slips into her Chrysalis costume and goes out with her giant pillow case ready to collect tons of candy. Chrysalis heads out an hour later in her Mane-iac costume and her giant pillow case over her shoulder ready to collect tons of candy. A few minutes later, the two meet up outside Twilight's castle, pick up the Mane Six, Trixie, and Starlight and they all head out to do the night's festivities.
Outside the mayor's office, everypony happily tosses spider shaped toys onto a net made of sticky string. Foals run around everywhere. Fluffle happily bobs for apples alongside Derpy and several other ponies. After several hours of games, everypony goes out to collect candy together from every house in Ponyville. By the time the clock reaches midnight, they've hit every house in Ponyville and return to their houses with their spoils. They all plop down on their beds in their houses and fall fast asleep. They can all agree, this has been the funnest Nightmare Night they've had in forever and they wouldn't have had it any other way.