Screwball has waited long enough for Discord to return to his old ways. Bored with toilet-paper rolling houses in Ponyville, Screwball decides it's time for a new God of Chaos to take the throne.

Sunset Shimmer was able to escape from a fire in the throne room. But during her first day in the new world she gets hit by a car trying to save Screwball and lost her memory. After the incident Screwball offers to let Sunset stay with her and her dad. Can Sunset handle having a lost memory and survive living in a now world.

One night Twilight Sparkle is visiting Canterlot to eat dinner with the princesses. She takes a walk in Canterlot Gardens and sees something heart-wrenching that will change how she lives forever.

Screwball was alone for 1,000 years, waiting for her father to come back. Too bad chaos only lasted a day. Now she's back in the same position, and more determined than ever to get her Daddy Discord back.

This story is sequel to Even if it Kills me. You can find the original story here.

Takes place after Keep Calm and Flutter On. After Screwball sees Celestia taking Discord's statue away from Canterlot, she goes to Ponyville to find Twilight Sparkle and confronts her about reforming Discord. Twilight tries to explain there's more to life than chaos. Screwball, upset by this, runs back to her cave in the Everfree where she is found by Discord.

Dr. Scarabew Ballentine(Ponyville's resident Psychotherapist) has time & time again proven to most likely be the best Mental-Health Professional in all of Equestria, but after Discord defeats the Mane 6 in the Hedge Maze, then goes to turn Ponyville into the Chaos Capital of the World, he'll really put her skills to the test, can she solve Discord's problems & convince him to not bring all of Equestria into Eternal Chaos, or will she just end up becoming another one of his chaotic victims, or will something else completely unexpected happen between these two?

As you can tell by the title this story is a "What if..?", meaning that it takes place in an Alternate Reality, so it is Not Canonical with any other story that I or Anyone Else has already created.

P.S. I take no credit for the Cover Art, it rightfully belongs to Captain-Waterfire, I just liked it So much that I simply Had to use it for this story.

I am lost and that is okay

I cannot find the normal

but I do not need it

I have the ones that find me.

Cover art by WubcakeVA. Part of the Oversaturated World.