• Member Since 24th Jul, 2016
  • offline last seen 11 hours ago

Shadow Quill

A Thestral mare who enjoys reading amazing stories almost as much as she enjoys writing them. Come on over to Luna's night and see just what you've all been missing in your sun-lit days.

More Blog Posts26

  • 47 weeks
    Belated Reader Request Poll Results!!

    Well, I guess I'm a bit late for my own Poll's results. Hehe, um, sorry for the delay everypony, I got a bit hung up with other things and time just slipped away.

    Read More

    2 comments · 322 views
  • 49 weeks
    Reader's Request Book Update Poll

    Hello to everypony, this is your friendly neighborhood Shadow Quill with a VERY important question for you all. I am currently facing a dilemma pertaining to my unfinished books and need your help to sort through the miasma in my brain.

    Read More

    8 comments · 228 views
  • 62 weeks
    A Question on the Origins of Heartsong

    Read More

    1 comments · 156 views
  • 110 weeks
    Last Call to Save My Books!! (If any of you want them)

    Alrighty then. I've laid the ground work and now the final sign has come at last. The three books that I originally placed on the Cancelled list are going to be disappearing for good soon. FOUR DAYS until they are deleted from FIMfiction and are lost to the ether for all of eternity. That means on Saturday the 29th of August will be the day that I come like the Grim Reaper and cleave them in

    Read More

    1 comments · 446 views
  • 111 weeks
    Books Up For Grabs!! (because I can't finish them all)

    Well, I'm sad to say this, but as of right now I'm cancelling some of the books that I've had sitting in my to do list for a long while now. I have realized that with as many books as I have in my to-do list, and my current system of only working on one book at a time until they are complete, it would take an eternity to finish everything that I currently have at my current pace. Thus, I have

    Read More

    2 comments · 264 views

A Question on the Origins of Heartsong · 5:55am Jul 28th, 2021

So I've been pondering something for a while and I wanted to ask all of you what you had for thoughts on this matter. I understand fully well that the term Heartsong is something that the fandom associates with the seemingly random and yet perfectly timed/choreographed musical numbers that have popped up so many times in MLP throughout its nine season runtime. Most of our number can probably name several right off the top of their heads that could count as personal favorites or character themes without even trying too hard.

Reasons as to why ponies and other creatures seemingly jump into random musical numbers with music that plays from nowhere have been passed around left and right across the various modems of MLP fanfiction, with a seeming majority falling into the camp that it is the magic of Equis and Harmony itself that fuels these epic/sad/happy/whatever emotion you need musicals. I like to believe that it is a combination of said inherent magic and the powerful emotions the characters are feeling that lead to these songs, with more self-centered emotions resulting in masterful arias like, well, This Day Aria, and more altruistic emotions like joy and hope creating wonderful numbers like the Smile Song and You'll Play Your Part.

But where did this idea originate? I have a personal theory and this is where all of you come in. For the members of the fandom who remember this, there was a movie that came out in 2006 that used the exact same term to describe a very similar idea. While it was more centered around the notion of soulmates through songs, the idea still has enough similarities to the MLP Heartsong that I was curious if anyone else felt the same way. The movie, as some of you may have guessed, was Happy Feet, where the main characters all sing their heartsongs in the hopes of finding true love.

So, does anycreature think that this might have been the inspiration behind the fandom's notion of how an MLP Heartsong works? Could this have been the spark that led not only FIM authors to the term but those of other fandoms as well? Let me know what you think in the towel section below, I'm curious to see if I'm the only one who thinks this way or if there are others who share my ideas. If anycreature has another possible source for the term Heartsong and thinks it might be a more likely candidate, please feel free to share below as well. I'm certain we would all be intrigued by it even as nothing more than a conversation starter.

Comments ( 1 )

It wouldn’t surprise men if that was the case of happy feet being an inspiration, but for the spontaneous musical numbers I have heard the term “harmony moment” tossed around to discribe them

Login or register to comment