What happened during the cruise in P.P.O.V. (Pony Point of View). · 5:58pm Oct 6th, 2019
This episode was great, but we never get to see what happens on the journey. So I will theorize what happened, and see who was the most accurate.
First off, in the beginning they were boarding. Applejack must have tried her hand to do a "pirate accent," causing Rarity to think that there was something wrong. Rarity had a few porter ponies with her. When they got on, Pinkie showed everyone her treats. Rarity pushed them away to make room for her cucumber sandwiches. They got into a fight, and accidently knocked the sandwiches overboard. Then Pinkie started the game with the piƱata. She grabs AJ and puts the blindfold on. Them they hear a growl, thinking that they were in a storm. AJ grabs the map she had to try and get them to safety. Rarity tries to stop AJ, and Pinkie thinks that they were playing tug of war. A wave sinks the boat, and they realize that they had never left the port.
So, with this story, Pinkie was the most accurate, and Rarity was the least.
I hope you agree.