• Member Since 27th Feb, 2013
  • offline last seen Tuesday

Sprocket Doggingsworth


I write horse words.

More Blog Posts281

  • 12 weeks
    Audiobook Announcement

    I'm excited to announce that I'm working on an audiobook for Hooves of Fate. I started with Chapter 63: Rivers. This way, long-time readers of HoF can reorient themselves to the momentum of the story before the upcoming release of Chapter 64 (text) this Saturday.

    Read More

    2 comments · 123 views
  • 17 weeks
    Change From Below

    Read More

    1 comments · 130 views
  • 20 weeks
    A Night to Remember (2023)

    Reblog from 2016

    Read More

    1 comments · 207 views
  • 22 weeks
    The Voice of the People

    They can cancel Friendship is Magic. They can cancel Make Your Mark. But they can never silence the voice of the people.

    3 comments · 127 views
  • 22 weeks
    Flurry Heart's Reign of Terror

    I stayed up till 2am last night talking with a friend - orchestrating a plot - theorizing what precisely it would take for (young adult) Flurry Heart to successfully depose both of her parents, and Twilight Sparkle.

    Read More

    2 comments · 134 views
May
13th
2019

Help! My Heart is Full of Pony! - Yona · 4:14am May 13th, 2019

Yona best. Yaks best. This why Yona first of Young Six to get own episode. This why, even in early Season 8 episodes, Yona feel fully fleshed out as character, while others still struggle to develop beyond tropish archetypes.

But how come Yona, who is ordinarily most confident creature - best creature - grow to feel like worst creature?

Simple. Yona come from society which value tradition above all things. So when Yona learn of pony dance event, (which Yona perceive to be highly traditional), Yona pressure yakself to assimilate, so Yona can fit in.

This not like Season 5, when yaks, (who are best), scorn ponish culture. Yona - unlike other yaks - immersed in ponish culture. Have permanent place in ponish culture.

Yona has two hooves in each world. So, upon learning of a ponish formal occasion with time-honored rituals of its own, Yona feel pressure to honor them.

Everypony always say "be yourself." This simultaneously and paradoxically easiest and hardest advice to follow. Difficult, even for yak sometimes.
(Though yaks still best).

-Sprocket


Please support me on Patreon. That is, if you want to. No pressure of course, but I ask because I do have mouths to feed. You can also follow Heart Full of Pony on Tumblr

Comments ( 5 )

I've always enjoyed the Student 6 than it seems most people do on this website (although that's just among the sample size of bloggers I follow). But I never expected to be cheering this much Yona. In her montage, Yona is never spontaneously inept at something, and the strides felt objectively obtainable, just requiring rigorous work. And she works her butt off and attains it.

It would have been really easy to furlough Rarity into being less sensitive than she should be to Yona's struggle. At worst, it might have made her into a condescending prick. But this is the woman who we all admire for her maximum effort, and no hesitation in giving. She never demeans Yona's physicality, her sociology or culture. Her enthusiasm comes from the excitement of sharing something that brings her joy. In fact, this might have been Rarity's first chance to ever do so; I can't recall a time where any of the Mane 6 or CMC ever asked her to tutor them so much in higher society. Also, I'm going to steal quote FanOfMostEverything's overview to add something on:

The song reflects the same issue Rarity showed in “Spice Up Your Life.” She’s brilliant when it comes to operating within the bounds of society, but she has a blind spot when it comes to when it’s best to work from outside of those bounds. She may innovate in terms of fashion, but she plays the rest of the game by the rules.

Actually, all the non-royalty Mane 6 got to share their passions that logically tied in to the Ball, and giving advice to Yona. Amity Ball worked remarkably well as a device for including the original cast that went beyond cameos, and didn't feel awkwardly shoehorned. Also, how rare is it for an episode to have all of the girls EXCEPT for Twilight be have a supporting role in a story?

The time Yona spent with her teachers is never actually portrayed as detrimental or some kind of "pony-washing." Her newfound skills were achieved with her qualities of work ethic, and can probably serve her later in life. (You'll notice that the show never slights her change in recipe for the potluck; that root stew seemed more in line with survival rations.) But there are still nods at ethnic exclusivity that persist even after the threat of overt racism has been defeated back in Season 8. Along with the name change to the award implemented at the very end, Spike accidently slips in the Fetlock Fete, reminding us that the Ponyvillians have essentially lifted and transplanted one of their own celebrations. Yona is literally pointing it out the (unintentionally) intended audience with the pony silhouettes on the posters. How often has the MLP community seen or used that artstyle and imagery in our own fan works? These stylized pony silhouettes that have for so long been part of the details of the living setting. But now Equestria itself might now be make the conscious decision to change that.
vignette2.wikia.nocookie.net/mlp/images/f/f0/Sisterhooves_Social_poster_S2E5.png/revision/latest/scale-to-width-down/300?cb=20140527235842
img10.deviantart.net/0546/i/2012/157/b/3/mlp___sisterhooves_social___movie_poster_by_pims1978-d52ieaa.png

This recognizable shift in the culture reminds me of how the trailer for the new Adams Family begins.

A really amazing detail is how the end product of Yona's dress doesn't really look right on Yona. The dress itself isn't ugly at all. It just never looks like it's suppose to go over a Yak. It doesn't fit her form and feels more stretched , and the colors aren't right for the distinct mud brown that makes up most of her color pallet. This seems like was literally meant for the pony form of Yona, working with the typical pony form, and having the cream color of her muzzle suddenly extending all across her. Think back to what Fluttershy was wearing during her stint as a model; she may have hated the role, but most of those outfits looked like natural extensions of her character. They didn't just look good, they looked good on Fluttershy. Whoever illustrated all this is a true artist that understands the language of fashion, and captures a struggle that some demographics of people face when accessorizing themselves or are using designing as expression. Say, a black women whose natural hair won't ever be falling down shoulders and back (barring copious hair product).

The only true downside that stuck out to me were the overabundance of cartoon physics towards the end. Yona trips with one leg, and suddenly she's launched at a 15 foot arc. That could be believable if she went off balance while charging, as would happen during during School Daze. But not while just taking several-inch steps. This hyper-destructiveness is something I had worried about earlier with the "spontaneous ineptitude," although not as demeaning to Yona or the audience. Recall the destruction at the end of the first Grand Galloping Gala. The scale of property destruction came from more logical preceding steps, with a statue tilting on its axis (Rainbow Dash) and knocking one heavy pillar into the next. Then we got an unspecified number of scared animals spreading the destruction across the venue. It also just feels more satisfying because each character's faff-up was building up, and then combine like Faux Pas Voltron.

Then there's this weird habit of characters running at full tilt whenever they lose their vision. This is something I found bizzare and extremely annoying back in Games Ponies Play with Peachbottom. When someone's , their first instinct is to try and figure out their surroundings. Why would that ever lead to a decision to INCREASE their speed?
vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/mlp/images/5/52/Ms._Peachbottom_trots_in_place_S03E12.png/revision/latest?cb=20130210161104
I guess I'm suppose to realize that this is a reference to the instincts and habits of animals, much like when crowds of ponies shake the ground they're standing on instead of applauding. But that could be made more clear with unspoken details, like a yelling yak noise when Yona her sight is taken from her.

Great little bit, though one correction, the Yaks never scorned 'Pony Culture', what pissed them off was the Ponies trying to imitate Yak culture, and failing.

Well put. Yak insight best insight.

Thank you for pointing this out. I was exhausted on Saturday, so I didn't notice that myself, otherwise I would have written it into my episode review. It makes me happy that traditions were the topic of an episode. Brilliant analysis!

Login or register to comment