• Member Since 26th Sep, 2011
  • offline last seen 8 hours ago

FanOfMostEverything


Forget not that I am a derp.

More Blog Posts1135

  • Wednesday
    Animate Well

    I'd put a "Contest!" in the blog title, but I'm not running this one. I'm just helping judge it. Pick your favorite classic cartoon and throw them into ponies, because it's time to ask a question that's been echoing about the site practically from the day it went up: Who Crossed Over My Little

    Read More

    3 comments · 159 views
  • 6 days
    Friendship is Card Games: Rainbow Dash Presents: Captain Hook the Biker Gorilla

    This week, we’re putting ourselves four degrees away from the source material. It’s a card blog based on a video based on a story based on a song based on FiM. Let’s get going.

    Read More

    10 comments · 202 views
  • 1 week
    Friendship is Card Games: Generations #2 & #3

    This week, we return to the union of modern ponies and 80’s villains. Well, the daughters of 80’s villains. Well, the minions of the daughters of 80’s villains.

    … Let’s just get started before I take this any further.

    Read More

    9 comments · 189 views
  • 2 weeks
    Alms Collection

    A friend alerted me to this situation, and so I'm sharing the news: Eponafest, an Italian pony convention set for May, is running crowdfunding to get some operating funds... and they're about halfway to their goal with a week left. See here for details.

    0 comments · 79 views
  • 2 weeks
    Friendship is Card Games: The Journal of the Two Sisters

    This is the main reason why I decided to skip over the comics a few weeks ago. I like the idea of the first card blog of 2022 using one of the oldest in-universe documents we have for source material. Let’s see what the diarchs thought of their first days on the throne.

    Read More

    19 comments · 285 views
May
6th
2016

Crimehunter Bat · 12:53pm May 6th, 2016

One of the really fun things to do with crossovers is exploring story ideas that couldn't work in either individually. I just thought of one that I can't really use, so I'm putting it up for adoption. Read on for details.

As you might have guessed from the blog title, this is a Batman crossover. Standard mythos applies by and large: Night out on the town, parents shot dead (perhaps with a repeating crossbow if you don't want to use firearms,) son swears never to let it happen to anyone else, becomes the best at everything, adopts the guise of a bat because criminals are a superstitious, cowardly lot, and becomes the night.

Equinizing the setting is fairly simple. Pony comics with metropolitan settings were established in "Power Ponies," so Trotham City (or your preferred pun) is certainly feasible. Batman (Batstallion, Batmane, perhaps Batmare) himself should probably be an earth pony, Poison Ivy definitely should be, the Penguin can be a griffin who actually is part penguin (or possibly puffin, making him very touchy about how close he comes while still missing the mark,) the Joker can be a party pony gone horribly wrong, and so forth. Assume that Bruce Wayne's cutie mark isn't the Batman logo.

As for the story itself, it's as follows: Early in Batpun's career, criminals begin attacking Trotham's bat pony communities because of a rather logical assumption regarding the bat-themed vigilante's true identity. The Caped Crusader must try to address the persecution of innocents while still preserving his own secret identity.

The problem is that I'm not that big a comic book fan, and I don't think I can do the idea justice. The most experience I have with Batman is through the DC Animated Universe, which I haven't dallied with in over a decade, and Atop the Fourth Wall, which tends to focus on Batman's more out-of-character moments. As such, this one's up for grabs.

Comments ( 13 )

I fail to see why this would need to be a Pony crossover. It sounds like a normal if clever Batman story.

In all fairness, the DCAU is one of the best things to ever come out of comic books so it would be a great source. Honestly with comic book characters picking one source and using it is usually a good call, since it helps keep a consistent baseline for things that fluctuate a lot between writers or series.

3924172
Unless Man-Bat has been unusually fecund in recent years, Gotham doesn't normally have a community of people with actual bat wings.

There are actually a couple of groups for stuff like this:

The Idea Exchange
Write my fic for me

3924286
I've crossposted this to the Exchange, actually. However, the blog is both more immediately visible and reaches almost four times as many people.

Historically the technical term for this is not a crossover -- those happen when characters cross between universes -- but a fusion, when plots and character attributes cross. Not that anyone cares... That said, it is a good idea, which is why I am pretty sure I've read shades of that -- not the story as described, but references to the story as described, uncannily similar in places -- already. I think it was one of RealityCheck's works... Somehow, it never got written out earnestly, as it happens with most particularly good ideas.

Mr. Freeze should be a unicorn scientist transformed into a wendigo. :)

The Animated Series is actually a VERY good starting point, for the record. It and Justice League/Unlimited are my definitive Bat.

3924483 Oooh oooh, Bane could be an earth pony who super-charges his magic with zap apple juice!

3924930

Ra's al Ghul has to be a rogue alicorn or an Umbrum. No other kinds of ponies would be so long-lived. Riddler would be a party pony gone horribly wrong in a different way... We don't have canonical examples of pegasi party ponies, but I expect nothing actually stops them from existing. Scarecrow would be an alchemist, and probably a zebra.

Catwoman can be an actual cat like Baast. :)

3925322 Killer Croc would be an only slightly darker Garble.

Two-Face was the chief crown prosecutor and a unicorn, but after his childhood friend moved and didn't answer his letters, this caused a complete psychotic break (as we know, that is a normal reaction for ponies) and he poured acid on half his face and began a life of crime.

Changling damaged by the love blast and unable to stop uncontrollably changing shape? Clayface.

"the Joker can be a party pony gone horribly wrong"

...That's a rather interesting idea all by itself.

And then it's up to Pinkie Pie to save the day from... "The Party Clown"! :pinkiehappy:

Login or register to comment