• Member Since 9th Sep, 2014
  • offline last seen Last Wednesday

LightningSword


Me. Take it or leave it.

More Blog Posts730

  • 32 weeks
    Just some thoughts

    Yeah. Been awhile, I know.

    Read More

    4 comments · 399 views
  • 188 weeks
    Why I Don't Write Here Anymore

    I suppose it's been on my mind for a long time, but it never really occurred to me until recently. And because a few of you have been waiting for some projects I promised I'd finished, you deserve to know, as well.

    Read More

    16 comments · 1,694 views
  • 222 weeks
    This exists . . .

    This is a thing that exists. This was made with effort, and money.

    And Hasbro actually put their name on this.

    . . .

    . . .

    . . .

    I'm gonna step away from this one.

    9 comments · 754 views
  • 228 weeks
    My good friend needs some support

    You all probably know HudsonHawk, especially if you know me. Even though I've never met the man in person, he's my best friend on this site, on the internet, and probably ever.

    Read More

    0 comments · 568 views
  • 232 weeks
    Embarking on a new venture

    Recently I discovered a site for content creators called Daisie. It allows people to post their work and ask for collaborators, and it was created by actress Maisie Williams, whom many of you might know as Arya Stark from Game of Thrones.

    Read More

    3 comments · 667 views
Aug
18th
2015

Aw, hell, just to get it out of the way · 10:30pm Aug 18th, 2015

MLP QUIZ!

Fav characters? Fluttershy; more than anypony :yay::heart:

Least fav characters? Gilda. You have a long way to go before you get redeemed, sweetheart. :ajbemused:

Fav background pony? Derpy, Lyra, Octavia

Least fav background pony? I don't think I have one. :applejackunsure:

Fav Mane Six member? Fluttershy, as above. But I like Rarity, too. She always makes me smile. :raritystarry:

Least fav Mane Six member? Rainbow Dash. Can't stand the bitch.

Fav CMC? Sweetie Belle. She's just so cute and squealy!

Least fav CMC? Scootaloo, or as I like to think of her, Rainbow Dash's Mini-Me.

Fav princess? Cadance. She doesn't get enough love. :applecry:

Least fav princess? Again, don't really have one.

Fav season? Season 2, by far.

Least fav season? Season 3. Too short, too rushed.

Fav episode? "Power Ponies" and "Hurricane Fluttershy".

Least fav episode? "The Mysterious Mare Do Well" and "Tanks for the Memories".

Fav episode focused on your fav Mane Six member? For Fluttershy, "Hurricane Fluttershy", "Dragonshy", and "Filli Vanilli", and for Rarity, "A Dog and Pony Show".

Any episode you hate but everyone else loves? "Tanks for the Memories". I don't understand why everyone worships that horrible fucking episode! :twilightangry2:

And the other way around? "Magical Mystery Cure". I don't love it, but I don't think it deserves the hate it gets.

Any guilty pleasures? I don't believe in guilty pleasures. If it makes you happy and no one's getting hurt, why feel guilty?

But if I had to pick: shipping Fluttershy with my OC, Nocturne. :twilightblush:

Fav season premiere and finale? Premiere: "The Return of Harmony" and "Cutie Markless". Finale: "Twilight's Kingdom".

Least fav premiere and finale? Premiere: "The Crystal Empire". Finale: "The Best Night Ever".

Fav song? "Find the Music in You".

Least fav song? Anything sung by Pinkie Pie. Ugh . . . :pinkiesick:

Best villain? Pre-reform Discord.

Worst villain? Sombra.

Like Equestria Girls? It was okay. Not the best ever, but not worthy of the hate it gets.

What about Rainbow Rocks? Far superior sequel.

Looking forward to the third movie? Sure. Looks good, so far.

Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? Absolutely. :twilightsmile:

Fav shippings? Married couples, a.k.a. the only canon ships.

Least fav shippings? TwiDash, incest couples, anything involving Fluttershy, especially FlutterCord (and not just because she's my waifu. :ajbemused:)

Fav bronies in the community? Grayson Bruce. I wish I'd had his guts when I was his age. That kid is my hero. :pinkiesmile:

Least fav bronies? Anyone that matches the "obsessive, fat, neckbearded clopper" stereotype. :pinkiesick:

Any character you didn’t like but grew to like as the series progressed? Pinkie Pie. I don't completely like her (see above, "least favorite song"), but she has her moments.

Have a waifu? You have to ask? :yay:

If you could remove one meme from the fandom, what would it be? MLP/Creepypasta crossovers. Not necessary.

And finally, can you name anyone you want to guest star on the show? Off the top of my head: either Keith David or Mark Hamill. I'd be over the moon either way.

Report LightningSword · 580 views · #mlp quiz
Comments ( 55 )

Power Ponies?

Interesting choice.

Somehow, I don't feel terribly surprised by any of your answers, though I don't try to guess the favourite tunes folks have. :pinkiesmile:

What would Mark Hamill voice as, though? For some reason (and it's pretty sad) I can only see him as the Joker nowadays... (FREAKING BEST JOKER EVER. AND KEVIN CONROY IS BEST BATMAN VOICE EVER. DON'T EVEN FIGHT ME ON THIS! :flutterrage:) :twilightsheepish:

3329935 Who says there's a fight to be had? Correct on all counts! :pinkiehappy:

3329865 I'm a huge superhero geek. As a kid, I was Batman every other year for Halloween, and I follow the Marvel Cinematic Universe religiously. So imagine my fangasm when I see an MLP episode based on Dr. Strange, Wonder Woman, Storm, Green Lantern, the Flash, the Hulk, and Robin teaming up to beat a fusion of Doctor Octopus and the Joker! :raritystarry:

Why does everyone I ask despise "Tanks for the memories"???

I would DIE to get Edward Norton, Kevin Spacey, or Gary Oldman on the show. They're 3 of my all-time favorite actors. As for my favorite pony, that would be Twilight. She'll always be my waifu... My favorite episode is a hard one, but some of my personal favorites are The Cutie Mark Chronicles, It's About Time, Sisterhooves Social, and Amending Fences. Though my least favorite episode is definitely easy. COUGBridle GossipCOUGH COUGH.

3330046 I can sum up my feelings on that episodes in two words: THREE MONTHS.

3329943

For me, the episode didn't sit too well for me.

However, I'm a fan of Rainbow Dash, so my opinion is immediately 100% nullified.

-ShadowFall

Fav characters? I like Maud and Sapphire Shores. They're both so pretty.
Least fav characters? Tree Hugger. Bad design and annoying.
Fav background pony? Bon Bon.
Least fav background pony? I don't know.
Fav Mane Six member? AJ, even if her character is somewhat typical.
Least fav Mane Six member? Pinkie, if I had to say. Not that she isn't cute or enjoyable, but out of the mane 6, she's my least favorite for whatever reason.
Fav CMC? Sweetie Belle.
Least fav CMC? Scootaloo. She just looks odd to me.
Fav princess? Big Mac.
Least fav princess? Honestly, Celestia. She comes off smiling and being too kind... I don't know, it's weird.
Fav season? I've honestly never really paid enough attention.
Least fav season? See above.
Fav episode? Tanks for the Memories. A nice euphemism for death, which is an important lesson for children.
Least fav episode? Anything with the CMC, to be honest. i don't know, they just seem lacking.
Fav episode focused on your fav Mane Six member? The reunion one.
Any episode you hate but everyone else loves? The one with Tree Hugger. I mean, it's a nice lesson in jealousy, but GOD does she just annoy the hell out of me.
And the other way around? I honestly don't know.
Any guilty pleasures? Like, about MLP? Uhh... Not really. I just watch the show, I don't do anything embarrassing. Unless you count reading on this site, then yeah, this.
Fav season premiere and finale? Haven't cared for any of them.
Least fav premiere and finale? See above.
Fav song? Life is a Runway. It's too fab, don't judge me.
Least fav song? Giggle at the Ghosties? I dunno.
Best villain? Even if she was sort of typical, Nightmare Moon. I just like pretty things.
Worst villain? Sombra. That, I will agree with.
Like Equestria Girls? Meh. Hated it at first, but the second movie made up for it... Sunset is best waifu.
What about Rainbow Rocks? Far superior sequel, I agree.
Looking forward to the third movie? I honestly haven't looked too much into it.
Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? The what? I'm so out of the loop.
Fav shippings? I don't know.
Least fav shippings? Not to diss it, but just shipping in general. That sounds odd because I do like reading the romance here, buuut... It just feels incorrect to play matchmaker. Hell, I usually read those "anon" or OC type deals.
Fav bronies in the community? *Gag* I think i'll avoid looking into the fandom too hard, thanks.
Least fav bronies? The types who would lead me to answer the question above as I have.
Any character you didn’t like but grew to like as the series progressed? Dash. She seemed (and excuse my french here, but) bitchy. Eventually though, I just kind of got it in mind that she's too prideful to really admit her feelings and faults.
Have a waifu? Sunset Shimmer.
If you could remove one meme from the fandom, what would it be? Pinkamena... Is she a meme? i just feel like the canon character is ruined by the fanon. Real Pinkamena is just a depressed Pinkie, but if you do an image search, all you'll find is the Cupcakes nonsense.
And finally, can you name anyone you want to guest star on the show? Like a celeb? Screw that scene.

My MLP: FIM Quiz!

Favorite Character? Twilight Sparkle (book horse).

Least Favorite character? Don't really hate any character, maybe Suri Polomare. She was a major bitch!

Favorite Background Character? Lyra Heartstrings (you won't remember her, though).

Least Favorite Background Pony? Don't hate any of them, bit if I had to pick one, Bon Bon.

Least Favorite Mane Six Member? Love them all, but my least favorite of them is, Fluttershy.

Favorite CMC? Sweetie Belle.

Least Favorite CMC? Apple Bloom (still like ya, though).

Favorite Princess? Almighty sun goddess, Celestia (praise the sun).

Least Favorite? Love them all, but Cadance takes the cake here.

Favorite Season? Either four, or two.

Least Favorite? Three

Favorite Episode? "It' About Time."

Least Favorite? "The Mysterious Mare Do Well."

Favorite Episode focused on your favorite mane six member? "It's About Time."

Any episodes you hate but everyone else loves? I like all episodes, really...

And the other way around? "Magical Mystery Cure."

Any Guilty Pleasures? That's none of your god damn business! xD

Favorite Season Premiere And Finale? Premiere: "The Cute Map." Finale: "The Canterlot Wedding."

Least Favorite Premiere And Finale? Premiere: "The Crystal Empire." Finale: "The Best Night Ever."

Favorite Song? "I'll Fly," "This Day Aria," or "The Smile Song."

Least Favorite Song? "Find The Music In You."

Best Villain? Nightmare Moon.

Worst Villain? Sunset Shimmer (Equestria Girls).

Like Equestria Girls? Kinda.

What About Rainbow Rocks? Oh, yeah!

Looking Forward To The Next Movie? yes.

Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? Who isn't?

Favorite Shipping's? TwiDash FlutterCord, TwiLuna, DoctorDerpy, OctaScratch, Disluna.

Least Favorite? Sparity and incest couples.

Favorite Bronies In The Community? Silver Quill, Pen Stroke, Dr.Wolf, KP, Jerry Peet, and Antony C

Least Favorite Bronies? 4Chan trolls

Any Character You Didn't Like, But Grew To Like As The Series Progressed? Nope. :D

Have A Waifu? Twilight, and Moondancer (I relate to them the most).

If I Could Remove One Meme From The Fandom, What Would It Be? Scootaloo is a chicken, heard it to many times.

And Finally, Can You Name Anyone You Want To Guest Star On The Show? David Tennant.

3330046 I like it, you're not alone.

Why do you hate RD? Just a tad curious.

3330239 I would say, but I don't want to go off on a tangent. I tend to do that sometimes, and it doesn't always end well . . . :twilightoops:

...I'm sorry, my brain broke when I thought of Hamill guest staring... :pinkiegasp: But I like your list! Very interesting...

that was a little lol

Fav characters? vinyl scratch easy lol
Least fav characters? dimond tira I hate that bitch
Fav background pony? Derpy, vinyl, Octavia

Least fav background pony? I don't think I have one. :applejackunsure:

Fav Mane Six member? I knda like rainbow but futtershy

Least fav Mane Six member? raity she's a bitch
Fav CMC? scoot's cause I feel bad for her :(

Least fav CMC? applebloom not devpoed and too rushed in

Fav princess? luna wtf not

Least fav princess? twilight wtf Larson

Fav season? Season 4, it was okay

Least fav season? Season 3. Too short, too rushed.

Fav episode? bloom and gloom

Least fav episode? "The Mysterious Mare Do Well" cause it dident have carther development

Fav episode focused on your fav Mane Six member? For Fluttershy, "Dragonshy",

Any episode you hate but everyone else loves? sleepless in ponyville no charter devlpoment

Any guilty pleasures? alicorn twilight wtf m.a. Larson

Fav season premiere and finale? never seen permire and don't have one

Least fav premiere and finale? again never watched any

Fav song? winter wrap up fking love it

Least fav song? we got heat's "anthogy fked that song up

Best villain? the dazzling holy shit 0-0

Worst villain? cyrsilisa wtf Larson

Like Equestria Girls? fking hate and has too many plot holes

What about Rainbow Rocks? fking best sepual holy shit

Looking forward to the third movie? Sure. Looks good

Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? maybe

Fav shippings? Married couples, a.k.a. the only canon ships.

Least fav shippings? TwiDash,

Fav bronies in the community? lighting and terin love you two :heart: :twilightblush:

Least fav bronies? Anyone that matches the "obsessive, fat, neckbearded clopper" stereotype. :pinkiesick:

Any character you didn’t like but grew to like as the series progressed? Pinkie Pie. I don't completely like her (see above, "least favorite song"), but she has her moments.

Have a waifu? son of a bitch umm ... vinyl I guess
If you could remove one meme from the fandom, what would it be? MLP/Creepypasta crossovers. Not necessary.

And finally, can you name anyone you want to guest star on the show? I though werid al was a good star and wish he came back (kinda)

3330099 but replace the word "hibernate" with "going to die".
Also, don't you dare hate on the orphan pegasus filly.:scootangel:

3330250 do you at least think her charector developed for the better over the season?
And C'mooon, you have to admit she has a beautiful singing voice.:rainbowkiss:

3330668
3330670 I know perfectly well what they were trying to do with the episode. And the simple fact that Tank is still alive means they failed at it. It completely destroys Dash's character and makes it clear that she doesn't learn her lessons from previous episodes. And no amount of singing, however good it may be (which, admittedly, it is), can save her from that.

"Tanks for the Memories". I don't understand why everyone worships that horrible fucking episode! :twilightangry2:

BECAUSE OF THE GAME OF THRONES REFERENCE!

Least fav Mane Six member? Rainbow Dash. Can't stand the bitch.

We have some serious talking to do, mister.

Least fav CMC? Scootaloo, or as I like to think of her, Rainbow Dash's Mini-Me.

...And a Chicken!

Fav episode? "Power Ponies" and "Hurricane Fluttershy".

Wow.

Power Ponies, as one person of moderate wisdom once said, "Power Ponies is just filler... the worst kind of filler."
I really think it was good for one thing: Spike
At least he was done proper justice then. Actually, now that I think about it, the fact that it acknowledged spike in a positive way made it a great episode!

Fuck yeah!

Least fav episode? "The Mysterious Mare Do Well" and "Tanks for the Memories".

TMMDW was... yeah. A piece of shit.
As for tanks for the memories... you just... wait.

Oh that's why. You don't like RD.

May your soul forever be missing a piece. For one does not know true happiness until they embrace the egotistical and rather brash mare that is Rainbow Dash.

"Filli Vanilli"

This episode here perfectly demonstrated Flutter's lack of development. When was this? Season 4?
In your other blog post you say that all those accusations are just plain lies. But... they're not.
In fact, I can point you to many a episode where dear old Flutters rolls back on something she learnt in an episode prior. Hurricane Fluttershy is a prime example.

I don't believe in guilty pleasures. If it makes you happy and no one's getting hurt, why feel guilty?

A guilty pleasure could involve someone being hurt though.
That's why it's a GUILTY pleasure.

Cutie Markless

Not an episode.

Fav song? "Find the Music in You".

HOLD UP
No way...

I don't believe it! T'is it true?

It is. Dear god.

What, in all thing holy, inspired that to be your favorite song? Surely you'd think that This Day Aria is better. Or perhaps that new song I Am Just a Pony.

That song was poorly made, and a horrifically bad demonstration of acapella.

Anything sung by Pinkie Pie. Ugh . . . :pinkiesick:

So not Smile Smile Smile?
Dude, that's sad.

What about Rainbow Rocks? Far superior sequel.

Tips fedora

Worst villain? Sombra.

Tips fedora again

Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? Absolutely. :twilightsmile:

Uh huh. I just hope that there isn't going to be any Rainbow Dash in it.

Fav shippings? Married couples, a.k.a. the only canon ships.

So you haven't seen the clear lesbianism of the LyraBon ship in canon?

Least fav bronies? Anyone that matches the "obsessive, fat, neckbearded clopper" stereotype. :pinkiesick:

I'm actually rather disappointed in you.
For me, it's the people who are negative. The people who bring others down. Not the fat people. Not the obsessive people. And not the cloppers. I think the best thing about the brony fandom is how supportive and friendly it is. Or, at least what it's supposed to be.

While this whole blog post sounds to me like it's to let off a lot of steam, it's certainly not a happy one.

3330250 I already have a good idea as to why, but I would really love to hear the whole story from you.

If you don't mind, please tell me all about it.

3330926 While I wholeheartedly agree on that point (Spike being the hero was one of many things this episode did right) . . .


3330929 . . . this, I'm afraid, we will have to disagree on (except the "Mare Do Well" part, which I totally agree). Once Dash agrees to stop bullying Fluttershy into doing what she wants, fine, then maybe I'll vaguely consider half-tolerating her. Maybe . . . :ajbemused:

3330959 I'm certainly not a happy person.

And please, keep your responses in one comment. Just to make it easier on my Alerts section? Thank you.

3330981 Apologies.

There were just... so many things to say. And not a lot of time to say it.
That's kind of what life is, in a way.

3330977 Hmmm, interesting. Can you give me a few examples of this? (I don't doubt it I just want to see what you're talking about)
Everything has become clear to me. You like Fluttershy, That much is plainly obvious. But, I never realized just how much you like her. It seems to be that anyone who treats her badly/unfairly is someone who immediately gets put into your Black List. And while I can understand that, I must say that it's a little bit unfair.
You know, on a rather similar note, I'm going to take a chance here, but I think I'll probably succeed.

Angel bunny is a piece of fucking shit. Am I right? Worse than Rainbow Dash. Worse than everyone.

3330991

Angel bunny is a piece of fucking shit. Am I right? Worse than Rainbow Dash. Worse than everyone.

As Igor said in Young Frankenstein, "On the nosie!"

But if you want some detail, then fine. Here's how Rainbow Dash bullies Fluttershy:

"Dragonshy", when she gave her a hard time all the way to the dragon's cave (and ended up being the one to fuck things up herself.

"Hurricane Fluttershy", when she insisted on coercing Fluttershy into helping with a twister she didn't even need to be a part of in the first place, just to beat some stupid record.

"The Crystal Empire", when she made her do the jousting event and punted her 50 feet into the air, for basically no good reason (she could have asked anypony else).

"Sonic Rainboom", when she kept screaming at her just to make her cheer better.

"Dragon Quest", when she tried to drag Fluttershy out of her house just to see the creatures Dash knows FULLY WELL she's afraid of (and for that, she deserved the ass-kicking she got).

"Rainbow Rocks", when she ignored Fluttershy's suggestions for songs and focused on the crap she wrote to stroke her own ego.

"Bats!", where she, and pretty much everyone, forced her into the situation that turned her into a blood fruit-sucking monster.

"Trade Ya!", where she almost traded her friend's services (and essentially, her friend, period, as in "childhood friend"), for a book.

It is for these reasons, and many others, that Rainbow Dash is my least favorite of the Six. At best, she is enormously overrated. At worst, she's a Mary Sue who gets away with everything and never has to answer to her own stupid, often illegal, actions.

But again, I don't want to get into an argument. I'll just end up freaking out and attacking everyone, and I'll end up being the bad guy again. If I keep going, that's exactly what will happen.

3331001 Thanks for taking your time to write such a big comment :twilightsheepish:

"Dragonshy", when she gave her a hard time all the way to the dragon's cave (and ended up being the one to fuck things up herself.

Ah yes, a prime example. I must agree with you on this one.
However...
If this wasn't a kids show all about friendship on it's....7th episode, then I would have probably Sided on Rainbow dash on that one. I mean, Fluttershy was downright terrified, and was pretty much doing everything she could do to get out of it. If it was me, I certainly wouldn't have expected to see her turn around a pwn that dragon like that.
At the same time... that pwnage was actually pretty unrealistic. But that is besides the point.
If it were not for Rainbow Dash then, that episode's lesson would have had far less of an impact. I'll use this excuse, and I'll probably only get to use it once, but here it goes:
Rainbow Dash learnt a lesson here. That was, after all, the whole point of the episode. I'll be she won't do it again.

"Hurricane Fluttershy", when she insisted on coercing Fluttershy into helping with a twister she didn't even need to be a part of in the first place, just to beat some stupid record.

Interesting perspective. It's been a while since I've watched that one, so please excuse me if I am not 100% accurate. But, I think that Rainbow Dash actually had the right idea here. Fluttershy has a problem. She has an extremely bad case of social anxiety-- something that is extremely dangerous, and needs to be fixed as soon as possible. Rainbow actually managed to convince Fluttershy to give it a go. And, after all, is this episode all about the hurricane? No. It's about Fluttershy getting the determination to accomplish what she thought was impossible.

And guess what? She did it. And, it wouldn't have happened without Rainbow Dash.

"The Crystal Empire", when she made her do the jousting event and punted her 50 feet into the air, for basically no good reason (she could have asked anypony else).

Nocking a main character on a kid's cartoon show that never has had a character die or even draw blood, 50 feet into the air is something that I would probably place in the 'comic relief' class. Was Fluttershy hurt?
I think that whole scene was more of a joke. Not entirely serious. I'd say that everyone acted a little out-of-character, even.

"Sonic Rainboom", when she kept screaming at her just to make her cheer better.

Again, that was something that spawned perhaps one of the brony fandom's greatest memes. When the writers made that, they weren't thinking "We're going to make RD mean towards Fluttershy" they were thinking "This is gonna be funny".

Actually, let me explain something. The reason I'm using this 'not what was intended in this scene' is because I am trying to excuse RD's character. Now, the show is the sole provider of what information we have on her character, but I would say that it is now always true to what the characters would be in real life. Characters actions are deliberately altered throughout scenes depending on the stakes and atmosphere, and so cannot always be compared to each other and to real life. Moving on.

"Dragon Quest", when she tried to drag Fluttershy out of her house just to see the creatures Dash knows FULLY WELL she's afraid of (and for that, she deserved the ass-kicking she got).

You know, I think I might give you that one. However, what was it that RD said? She said something about watching the butterflies with Flutters, and that she owed her. Now, I'm no expert, but I'd say that Rainbow dash is just as effected by frilly and cute things as Fluttershy is by scary things. It's one of the great things that one can delve into her character with. It's a situation that is deep, and rooted among feelings of vulnerability and helplessness.
Ass-kicking? Ah... that. A buck to the chest. I ought to call you on that hipocracy. In real life, that'd probably be close to fatal.

"Rainbow Rocks", when she ignored Fluttershy's suggestions for songs and focused on the crap she wrote to stroke her own ego.

Wait! I'm getting an incoming message from Starfleet! It reads "I know just the song. Fluttershy's written a really great one." It goes on to read that Rainbow Dash, does indeed, play Fluttershy's song instead of her own!

"Bats!", where she, and pretty much everyone, forced her into the situation that turned her into a blood fruit-sucking monster.

Completely unfair. While you do acknowledge everyone else, I would say that the CLEAR offender in that story was Applejack, and to a lesser extent, Twilight.

"Trade Ya!", where she almost traded her friend's services (and essentially, her friend, period, as in "childhood friend"), for a book.

I have to give that one to you. That episode has to be one of the most horrible ever written, considering that it nearly sold off the element of kindness into slave labor. While I understand blaming RD for this, I'd say just poor writing.


It seems to me that I enjoy characters that are not perfect, but interesting. Something that I've noticed time and time again.

I think that Rainbow Dash is often not written correctly. The writers give her a sort of... blunt air about her. That's not who Rainbow Dash is, in my mind. She is the element of loyalty, that has to count for something.
But sometimes, as far as the show is concerned, it doesn't.

I can say one thing, though, with absolute certainty. My Little Pony would not be what it is today without her.

I don't expect much of a reply to this, as you said you didn't want to get involved in an argument. But I still would love to discuss the differing perspectives with you. Upon revision of this, there is lots more I would love to say, but I don't think it'd be necessary to mention it unless you do.

I'll end with one final statement.

This entire comment is redundant.

Is it not about what he or she is, it's about what you think he or she is.
I've probably read too many amazing fanfictions about Rainbow Dash in the past months, and my opinions of her character have definitely been warped.

Fluttershy used to be my favorite, but then I realized just how great of a character Rainbow Dash could be. Not what she is. What she could be.
I guess I found all that potential interesting. I found it intriguing. I found that it was beautiful.
Perhaps you see a blunt, brash, mean mare. But what I see, is the element of loyalty. A friend who will never give up on a friend, no matter the chances, or effort. I see a mare with determination...

Determination... and potential.

P.S I apologize for the mess of a comment. Sometimes, as I write a comment, my opinion changes. As you read through this comment, you can see it changing, time, and time over. This has happened to me before, more than I would like, and it usually ends up with me retracting back to my original statement.
All I'm saying is, she's not a bad character. It really does sting to see all this hate directed towards her. I guess that's one advantage of liking Fluttershy, you can just respond with "how could you?!??!".
I've gotta stop myself before this comment becomes long enough to write a biography off of.

MLP QUIZ!
Fav characters? :trollestia: , :twilightsmile: and Luna in that order
Least fav characters? Diamond tiara, snips and snails finally, Gilda.
Fav background pony? Derpy, Lyra, Octavia ( same here!)
Least fav background pony? Flash sentry
Fav Mane Six member? Twilight ( was there ever any doubt?) and ( prepares for incoming hate) rarity is my next favorite
Least fav Mane Six member? Applejack, she's cool but somepony has to be last
Fav CMC? Sweetie Belle. She's just so cute and squealy! ( same)
Least fav CMC? Applebloom mini applejack and I don't see scootaloo as that much of a jerk
Fav princess? Celestia, Luna is cool too and cadence is a close second for second place because I love to be a match maker
Least fav princess? big Mac lol it makes no sense
Fav season? Season 2, by far.
Least fav season? Season 3. Too short, too rushed.
Fav episode? The pinkie snense one and the first three episodes of season five ( there are probably more but I can't think of them)
Least fav episode? The one where where fluttershy says something about not blaming the things that are eating the apples and "Tanks for the Memories".
Fav episode focused on your fav Mane Six member? Celestia ( all the episodes! Although I was very disappoint that she lost to chrysalis and that Luna wasn't there to help) Luna ( crap I forgot the recent episode name) twilight ( the one where she try's to find out the pinkie sense, the one with the enchanted smarty pants) For Fluttershy, "Hurricane Fluttershy", "Dragonshy", and "Filli Vanilli", and for Rarity, "A Dog and Pony Show".
Any episode you hate but everyone else loves? "Tanks for the Memories". I don't understand why everyone worships that horrible fucking episode! :twilightangry2:
And the other way around? "Magical Mystery Cure". I don't love it, but I don't think it deserves the hate it gets.
Any guilty pleasures? What does this have to do with mlp?

Fav season premiere and finale? Premiere: "The Return of Harmony" and "Cutie Markless". Finale: "Twilight's Kingdom".
Least fav premiere and finale? Premiere: the first episode ( lol) Finale: "The Best Night Ever".
Fav song? This day aria
Least fav song? You gotta share or the one that she laughs at the trees ( can't be bothered to look up the name)
Best villain? Pre-reform Discord.
Worst villain? Sombra.
Like Equestria Girls? It was okay. Not the best ever, but not worthy of the hate it gets.
What about Rainbow Rocks? Far superior sequel.
Looking forward to the third movie? Sure. Looks good, so far.
Speaking of movies, looking forward to the 2017 movie? Yus thanks for telling me! http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Zuk-StWq0DQ
Fav shippings? My girlfriend and I ( I know it's not in the show) Cadence and shining armor, twilestia, soarinshy
Least fav shippings? anything involving Fluttershy or discord ( the exception with Fluttershy being soarinshy) especially FlutterCord and celesticord
Fav bronies in the community? Captain sparkles he introduced me to the community
Least fav bronies? Anyone that matches the "obsessive, fat, neckbearded," stereotype. :pinkiesick:
Any character you didn’t like but grew to like as the series progressed? Pinkie Pie. she has her moments. Rarity she at first seemed like a drama queen ( and still might be) but she as a friend would be a great one.
Have a waifu? Well I have a girlfriend but if it's show characters i think it's quite obvious :trollestia:
If you could remove one meme from the fandom, what would it be? Idk
And finally, can you name anyone you want to guest star on the show? Off the top of my head: idk I'd love to give it a shot

3331570 As I said, I know what the episode was supposed to be. It was an allegory for pet death. In fact, if Tank had died, this would have been the best episode ever written. But he's alive. That one detail soured the whole episode and made it one of the worst ever made. Period.


3331049

I'll be she won't do it again.

That's the problem. She did it again. Several times. As I have already outlined.

Fluttershy has a problem. She has an extremely bad case of social anxiety-- something that is extremely dangerous, and needs to be fixed as soon as possible. Rainbow actually managed to convince Fluttershy to give it a go. And, after all, is this episode all about the hurricane? No. It's about Fluttershy getting the determination to accomplish what she thought was impossible.
And guess what? She did it. And, it wouldn't have happened without Rainbow Dash.

Wrong. Fluttershy did it to improve herself, not because Dash pushed her into it. True, she pushed her, but that wasn't the main reason. She figured out her problem on her own, and strove to fix it herself. That's why I loved that episode; she improved herself for her own sake, and showed a hidden strength that no one ever credits her for. More to the point, if a friend of yours needs to get to the bottom of a staircase in the dark, do you guide them down, or push them down? Tough love doesn't work on Fluttershy, and if Dash doesn't know it by now, they shouldn't be friends. She never takes her feelings into account; with Dash, it's always "ME, ME, ME".

Incidentally, I'm working on a one-shot based on that assessment. :derpytongue2:

Was Fluttershy hurt?
I think that whole scene was more of a joke. Not entirely serious. I'd say that everyone acted a little out-of-character, even.

Still no excuse. I hate it when they use Fluttershy as a joke character. Aside from Pinkie Pie (which works much better, anyway), she's the brunt of more jokes than any of the Six. And Dash could have picked anyone else to do the event with, someone that she knew wouldn't be too badly hurt or would be able to handle it easier. But she went with Fluttershy because she knew she could bully her into doing it. She went the easy way, which is another thing I don't like about Dash. She's lazy.

Again, that was something that spawned perhaps one of the brony fandom's greatest memes. When the writers made that, they weren't thinking "We're going to make RD mean towards Fluttershy" they were thinking "This is gonna be funny".

The meme is the only good part of that. And again, no excuse to make Fluttershy the punchline of a joke. In fact, by that logic, this was less about Dash bullying her and more about the writers bullying her; not writing her feelings doesn't mean she never had them. Good joke. Bad writing. :ajbemused:

She said something about watching the butterflies with Flutters, and that she owed her. Now, I'm no expert, but I'd say that Rainbow dash is just as effected by frilly and cute things as Fluttershy is by scary things. It's one of the great things that one can delve into her character with. It's a situation that is deep, and rooted among feelings of vulnerability and helplessness.
Ass-kicking? Ah... that. A buck to the chest. I ought to call you on that hipocracy. In real life, that'd probably be close to fatal.

That's bullshit. Butterflies don't eat ponies whole. Fluttershy has a legitimate reason to be afraid of dragons. If Dash were afraid of butterflies (which has never been said), then I would let up on her (but she would also be a hypocrite for being tough in the face of danger but scared of a harmless insect). But she doesn't. She only wanted Fluttershy at the dragon migration because she felt she was owed. Again, only looking out for herself. Not caring about how Fluttershy felt at all.

Also, how am I the hypocrite? Fluttershy was backed into a corner and used force as a last resort, something she rarely does. Dash ALWAYS uses force. Not the same thing.

Wait! I'm getting an incoming message from Starfleet! It reads "I know just the song. Fluttershy's written a really great one." It goes on to read that Rainbow Dash, does indeed, play Fluttershy's song instead of her own!

She only did it at the last possible second, and you know it. The wise-assery is not necessary. :ajbemused:

Completely unfair. While you do acknowledge everyone else, I would say that the CLEAR offender in that story was Applejack, and to a lesser extent, Twilight.

Bandwagon. It counts. To a significantly lesser degree, maybe, but it counts.


Like I said, I want to be able to discuss this calmly and logically, but this whole reply probably defeats that purpose. In fact, I feel I must apologize for whatever was said here; I'm sure I must have sounded like a jerk at least once. This is why I didn't want to reply, not because I didn't think you deserved one, but because I couldn't give one without being an asshole.

You like Rainbow Dash. That's fine. But I only go by what the show has given us, not by what they could have given us. Yes, she has the potential to be a better character. But it's been four and a half seasons. If she hasn't improved by now (which I have given my arguments as to how she hasn't), she never will.

I can give multiple arguments for how Fluttershy is a superior character (and I've given several in a separate post) and not be just a mindless drooling FlutterFan (unfortunately, they do exist :ajsleepy:), but that's another argument. My point is, the show has given me no legitimate reason to like Rainbow Dash (no, the Sonic Rainboom doesn't count; they would have gotten their cutie marks eventually). Meanwhile, Fluttershy continues to give me reasons to love her as a character, and defend her when she comes under scrutiny. Just as you have done so with Rainbow Dash.

As I said, at best, she's overrated. At worst, she's the worst character of the Six. But I've expended my welcome on the subject, and if it hasn't already, I will stop this argument before it turns ugly. As much as I want to defend my position, I've let things get out of hand in arguments before, and I won't risk that happening again.

Again, I apologize, and I thank you for understanding.

3331893 dude like it or not, they cant show death because its still a Kids show. So they had to work with what they had.

Login or register to comment