What if...?

What if Celestia lost the battle with Nightmare Moon and was banished?

What if Luna took Twilight under her wing?

What if Luna returned to her "good" form but never released Celestia?

What if Twilight was evil?

What if she was an evil accomplice to Nightmare Moon?

What if all the villains formed an alliance?

just publicly brainstorming... Don't mind me.

Comments

[BrenTenkage]

hmm evil Twilight...hmmm

[Bastler]

What if Celestia lost the battle with Nightmare Moon and was banished?

The Pony lifestyle would change in a drastic way. Every Pony would be forced to be awake in the night and sleep at daytime.

What if Luna took Twilight under her wing?

Luna would teach Twilight how important the night is and why she should never be awake at daytime?

What if Luna returned to her "good" form but never released Celestia?

Ponies could choose when they want to be awake again, but the daytime wouldn't be the same as in the old tales.
---------------------

What if Twilight was evil?

The Element of Magic an evil pony Oo
She would kill ponies for science? Definitely something like an evil scientist.
----------------------

What if she was an evil accomplice to Nightmare Moon?

She would modify ponies so they couldn't survive the daytime. Results in everypony is playing at night.
----------------------

What if all the villains formed an alliance?

Very interesting. Ponies would definitely be an very sad race.

I mean you wake up in the evening working the whole night for king sombra in an discorded city where the weather changes in an short unsteady period and when you are done you have to feed some changelings. Every new born unicorn would have to give its power to Tirek, so no magic to even change something. No hope, no dreams, just the live of very sad slaves.

The death would be a welcomed guest.

I hope my English is readable :/