JohnPerry

Joined October 2011
739 followers
85,584 story views
Online

For lack of a creative handle.

Watching

739 members follow JohnPerry

JohnPerry follows 33 members

Too Brilliant For Me To Have Written

  • Letters from a Senior to a Junior Changeling A series of notes sent to a young changeling in the field by her superior. by Chris 9,395 words · 1,261 views · 147 likes · 2 dislikes
  • Daring Do Bakes a Cake Dinner with Daring Do and her mother. by Lucky Dreams 6,365 words · 3,200 views · 204 likes · 4 dislikes
  • Lost Cities North of Canterlot, in the far marches of the Equestrian lands near the border with the Griffon tribes, there is a mountain that flies. by Cold in Gardez 7,144 words · 3,918 views · 621 likes · 6 dislikes
  • The Writing on the Wall Beneath the earth rests something beyond equine understanding. by Horse Voice 6,207 words · 7,874 views · 372 likes · 7 dislikes
  • Pears Pinkie Pita lives in Vanhoover, works at a pita shop, and has no family to speak of. She hates pears, and she has no idea why. [No overt spoilers for "Pinkie Apple Pie", but you won't get the story if you haven't seen the episode. by Aquaman 4,525 words · 289 views · 51 likes · 5 dislikes

(More Stuff) Too Brilliant For Me To Have Written

  • Promised Land Twilight Sparkle has walked the wastelands for a very long time, but now, at last, he has reached the end of his journey. He only hopes now that the gods will listen to his prayers, and finally allow him a good place to die. by Obselescence 7,054 words · 3,903 views · 722 likes · 19 dislikes
  • The Best Night Ever Grand Galloping Gala meets Groundhog Day time-loop by Capn_Chryssalid 53,935 words · 30,808 views · 3,336 likes · 47 dislikes
  • When the Levee Breaks Daring Do returns home one final time. by Cynewulf 6,581 words · 1,322 views · 154 likes · 3 dislikes
  • Harmony An adaptation of BioShock for the world of MLP, starring several OCs and the entire Mane cast. by Aquaman 103,530 words · 9,264 views · 795 likes · 27 dislikes

Wacky Stories Too Hilarious For Me To Have Written

  • Certain Advantages When Dash makes Spike bet on this year's Sisterhooves Social, she's sure she can't lose... right? by The Descendant 12,055 words · 15,040 views · 1,691 likes · 22 dislikes
  • A Slice of Life Surely the End of Equestria. Lock the cupboards and barricade the fridge! It's the Royal Diet! by Dawnscroll 87,905 words · 33,614 views · 2,125 likes · 41 dislikes
  • Sparkle's Law Twilight slowly loses her mind as preparations for the Summer Sun Celebration go horribly wrong. by AestheticB 17,765 words · 26,917 views · 1,084 likes · 15 dislikes
  • Nineteen Neighty-Four 1984 pony style! by Blueshift 8,346 words · 9,199 views · 823 likes · 12 dislikes
  • The Mailmare Derpy Hooves attends the annual magic users convention in Canterlot. by theamberfox 56,722 words · 11,084 views · 227 likes · 13 dislikes

My Best Stuff

  • Go West, Young Mare An older Daring Do, restless and pensive, is called out west by a figure from her past. by JohnPerry 10,180 words · 697 views · 86 likes · 3 dislikes
  • Do Changelings Dream of Herding Sheep? Daring Do ventures into the desert chasing changelings, but uncovers a dark secret... by JohnPerry 11,720 words · 6,781 views · 197 likes · 4 dislikes
  • Maybe Some ponies never change. Prince Blueblood is one of them. by JohnPerry 7,812 words · 2,889 views · 274 likes · 3 dislikes
  • The Final Quest of Star Swirl the Bearded The last journey of an unusual wizard and the role he played in the founding of Equestria. by JohnPerry 64,492 words · 3,105 views · 190 likes · 2 dislikes
  • The Wreck A.K. Yearling is haunted by dreams of a shipwreck... by JohnPerry 13,126 words · 471 views · 72 likes · 1 dislikes

The Mission: Implausible Series!

  • Mission: Implausible Octavia and Vinyl Scratch: Musicians and secret agents. by JohnPerry 31,111 words · 9,244 views · 650 likes · 7 dislikes
  • You Only Live Twice Secret agents Vinyl and Octavia reunite to tackle a threat to Canterlot. by JohnPerry 36,476 words · 3,137 views · 325 likes · 2 dislikes
  • The West Is Not Enough Secret agents Vinyl Scratch and Octavia find themselves locked in an epic struggle against a ruthless group of outlaws in the wild west. by JohnPerry 29,047 words · 2,304 views · 307 likes · 6 dislikes
  • When the Curtain Falls An incident in a Manehattan theater quickly draws secret agents Vinyl Scratch and Octavia into a hunt for a strange killer. by JohnPerry 36,535 words · 2,147 views · 248 likes · 4 dislikes
Jul
28th
2014

So in the last couple of weeks, I’ve come across a couple of different comments along very similar lines that express a view about Friendship is Magic that bothers me a little. Now, I’m not sure whether this was just a weird coincidence or if these comments are indicative of a larger train of thought, but if it’s the latter, I want to see if I can get ahead of this. So at the risk of attacking a straw man, let me lay this out.

In both cases, what happened was that someone referred to Friendship is Magic as children’s entertainment or as a show for little girls (and not in a negative sense, it must be pointed out; let me make it very clear that there’s no way it could have been misunderstood as attacking the show), then received a rebuttal from someone stating that Friendship is Magic wasn’t a show for little girls or a show for kids, but “family entertainment” or “a show for everyone.”

Now, at first I just chalked this up as a slightly annoying semantic argument. My response, had I written one, would have been something along the lines of, “Yeah yeah, it’s a show that appeals to a broad demographic, right right right, but you know what I mean. It’s targeted at little girls. But whatever.”

And I would have forgotten about it, had I not read this claim in the second instance of this argument:

Indeed, Laurin (sic) explicitly stated that MLP FIM was NOT for little girls, but rather was intended for all ages.

Now, a cursory glance at some quotes from Lauren Faust suggests otherwise:

"I've always looked at my work feeling like I was trying to make stuff for girls," says animator Lauren Faust, "and then accidentally getting guys interested as well."

To look at the quality of most girls’ cartoons, it would seem that not one artist really cared about them. Not one designer, not one background painter, not one animator. […] In short, animated shows for little girls come across as boring.  Stupid. Lame.

This perception, more than anything, is what I am trying to change with My Little Pony.

Not to make Lauren Faust the be-all, end-all of arguments related to the show, but my impression – which was reinforced by re-reading these articles – has always been that Lauren Faust set out to create a cartoon geared for girls, but that would hopefully appeal to a broader demographic as well. And in that, I think she obviously succeeded.

In my mind (and this is purely personal opinion), just because children’s entertainment appeals to a broader age range doesn’t mean it stops being children’s entertainment. It’s just a better example of children’s entertainment.

Now, if the argument being presented in these “it’s a show for everyone” comments was something along the lines of, “Entertainment is entertainment; let’s just like what we like and stop trying to classify everything,” then I wouldn’t have any problem with it. That sounds awesome! Instead of constantly trying to stick this thing in that box and that thing in this box, we could stop having these semantic arguments trying to draw a line between “boys” and “girls” entertainment or “children’s” and “general” entertainment and just agree to enjoy what we enjoy. But that’s not what these commenters are suggesting; in both instances, what they were suggesting is that there’s some clear delineation between “children’s/girl’s entertainment” and whatever Friendship is Magic is.

And this is why it bothers me, and why I’m bothering to write this post. Because it feels like a backhanded, roundabout way of saying, “A show for little girls? Ha, I don’t watch those! That’d be crazy, because those are lame!” I doubt that’s what these commenters intended, but it doesn’t look great if a brony is so quick to say, “Oh no no no, you misunderstand. I don’t watch a show for little girls.” Which, in spirit, seems to be kind of the opposite of what Lauren Faust was hoping for.

Call the show what you will, but what I fear is that this sort of semantic sparring, this line drawn between “little girl” things and “everyone” things, does no good for bronies or girls’ entertainment in the long run. Maybe I’m overreacting (scratch that; I know I’m overreacting), but that’s my feeling on it. Friendship is Magic is indeed a show that can be enjoyed by people of all ages, but can we avoid going into a defensive stance whenever someone says we watch a show for little girls? To claim otherwise just makes it look like we’re in denial, while also subtly putting down a whole host of other "little girl" things that might have entertainment and artistic merit that we haven't discovered yet.

JohnPerry · 258 views · Report

Comments

#1265974 · 2w, 5d ago · · ·

>>1209508 Why is the Featured Box male? :twilightoops:

#1265961 · 2w, 5d ago · · ·

>>1265956 You're welcome. :pinkiehappy:

#1265956 · 2w, 5d ago · 1 · ·

>>1265052 Yep, roadrunners are dicks. Clever little bastards...

I don't remember Santa Fe having that many tall buildings, though. :derpytongue2:

Thanks for sharing that!

#1265052 · 2w, 5d ago · · ·

You at all familiar with Dan Vs.

#1224994 · 6w, 1d ago · · ·

Fascinating.

5 1652
Login or register to comment