Source

What I'd like to do here is to see if anyone has any critical thoughts regarding Archives of the Friendquisition. Sometimes when I'm down in the fiction mines, I worry that I'm losing sight of some bigger writing principals. I get insecure like that. Is there anything you, as a reader or (if applicable) a fellow writer, have noticed in the entire story thus far, that you think I could improve on? More specifically:

Plot: Does anyone feel like the plot right now is confusing or incomplete? Does it feel slow or lacking momentum? Does anything feel "accidentally" unresolved. Obviously, it's a mystery-heavy part right now, so new revelations are always right around the corner, but does anything strike you as missing?

Characters: I'm really trying to "show, not tell" about my characters. The first step is to "not tell" you about them, which I think I'm doing okay with. But sometimes I feel like I'm forgetting to then actually do the "show" part. Which characters do you get a pretty clear characterization from? Do any of them seem bland, or too similar to one another? Am I overdoing anything? Does it seem like the action and plot are done in compliment to character development, or at its expense? I'm mostly concerned with the "mane 5" (Caballus, Roughshod, Mystic, Fyzzix and Hairtrigger), but thoughts on secondary characters are good too.

The comments I receive to the story are, of course, always welcome and encouraged. It's just that it feels like all the feedback I get is mostly praise (again, always welcome and encouraged), and sometimes specific praise, which is more useful. To me, specific critique is the most useful comment of all, so that's what I'm after here. I figure I have all you guys following me, so I might as well take advantage of you.

...

That came out wrong. Just... uh... let me know what you're thinking.

Inquisipony Stallius · 42 views

Latest Stories


Archives of the Friendquisition

In the grim darkness of the far future, there are only ponies! Equestria is assailed by countless foes from without, but only the shadowy Friendquisition can protect it from the enemies within. Can one Inquisipony and his team uncover a plot that threatens to destroy everything they hold dear? Or will sinister forces prevail in an MLP future that has become like the Warhammer 40k universe, the original grimdark franchise?

As seen at Equestria Daily. Note that the most recent version of the story, including edits and new chapters, will be available there first, and changes will eventually trickle over here. Please feel encouraged to leave comments here, there or at this thread on Ponychan. I would very much like to hear from you.

The Princess Protects

Vector by Prince Bluelolz on Ponychan

More Less
84,618 words ( 28 chapters ) · 2,081 views  ·  90  ·  1  · 

Comments

#322596 · 14w, 2d ago · · ·
Reply 

Why havent I done this sooner?

#277494 · 18w, 1d ago · · ·
Reply 

Thanks for faving Ridin' Wif Da Boyz. WAAAGH!!! :flutterrage:

#210659 · 24w, 4d ago · · ·
Reply 

Thank you for the critique, well keep out in mind.:pinkiehappy:

#196993 · 26w, 22h ago · · ·
Reply 

>>196829 oh, well it'll be approved soon, the title is faith, fire, steel, and...friendship, the cover art had nothing to do with the plot

#196829 · 26w, 1d ago · · ·
Reply 

>>196683

Did you write a fic of your own? I don't know how to view it with only a password. Is there a link I was supposed to get?

#196683 · 26w, 1d ago · · ·
Reply 

Just finished first chapter:rainbowderp: so many different versions, but it is ready, password is 133725

#187666 · 27w, 1d ago · · ·
Reply 

LOYALIST DOG! KHORNE SHALL HAVE YOUR SKULL!

#28729 · 52w, 4d ago · · ·
Reply 

>>28623

Oh nothing much, just dropping in to say hello. :twilightsmile:

I thank you for the Critique on CMoC, By the way.

#28623 · 52w, 4d ago · · ·
Reply 

>>28223

Quite well, sir. Just got done with your latest chapter, in fact.

What can I do for you?

5 8207