• Member Since 4th Nov, 2012
  • offline last seen Sep 7th, 2023

Remi-Chan


E
Source

Angel runs into the Everfree Forest causing Fluttershy to freak out. She will do anything to find her bunny. Even going into the Everfree Forest. Flan Chan helped me with this one too.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 9 )

Angel is best pony.






:trollestia:

Your face is an angel~!!!

As much as I love Fluttershy :yay: ... Downvoted because this doesn't make any sense plot-wise, and the other characters are borderline OOC (I don't think they would just let Fluttershy run off alone into the Everfree Forest like that) :applejackunsure:

1741552
I hold you in high respect for commenting why you dislike a story instead of just disliking and calling it a day. :moustache:

Hello! I'm here as a reviewer from Editors Dreamland.

The story itself is fine. I love the idea, but there are a number of issues that detract from the quality of the fic.
Like Zephyrus Scary said, this is borderline OOC. But I overlook that namely because if Fluttershy did run off to the Everfree Forrest to place frogs back in it, without the Mane 6. So that is not any issue at all. It's totally canon for her to care about her pets. You win FlanChan!

“Angel?” Fluttershy screamed as loud as she possibly could, which really wasn’t that loud, “Angel! Where are you?” No response. Fluttershy started to sweat. “Where in Equestria could he be?” she worriedly mumbled to herself, starting to get extremely worried about her little bunny.

The syntax here needs to be changed a bit. Enter when ever there is a character speaking, or just change the sentence so it doesn't seem fragmented.

Ex. “Angel?” Fluttershy screamed as loud as she possibly could, which really wasn’t that loud, “Angel! Where are you?”

No response. Fluttershy started to sweat. “Where in Equestria could he be?” she worriedly mumbled to herself, starting to get extremely worried about her little bunny.

It just is reader friendly to separate ideas and when a charcter is talking!

"Fluttershy ran to the library, her hair whipped by her face,obscuring her view. She was too upset to be bothered by it. The moonlight made all of her colors seem pale, but maybe it was because of her anxiety. She eventually made it to Twilight’s doorstep."

The flow of this needs to be improved mainly because you can do so much more with her running to Twilight's library from her cottage. That might be a time for her to reflect on the disappearance. If someone is missing something, they don't go immediately to a friend, they search themselves. So there is a lot you can do to flush out the story just in that second paragraph.

“Can’t talk!” Fluttershy gasped. She continued running, right past Pinkie. Pinkie raised an eyebrow in confusion.

This has the same syntax problem but you can just edit the sentence and include a comment to make it flow a lot better.
Maybe:
“Can’t talk!” Fluttershy gasped. She continued running, right past Pinkie, who raised an eyebrow in confusion at her friend as she flew past her.

"

Fluttershy stopped just inches before the entrance to the large forest looming over her

."
This seems just a little to sudden. Again use the traveling as an opportunity for personal reflection that adds depth to the character.

The dense foliage instantly blotted out the light. Unable to see anything, she blindly trudged on, until a loud crack behind her made her instinctively jump into a nearby bush.

You do a very good job with description! :scootangel::yay:

“What is going on here?” she asked herself, putting a hoof to her forehead as she tried to come up with an explanation. Something was seriously wrong here. She gulped, very slowly starting her trek forward. She looked left and right quite often, getting the uneasy feeling of being watched.

Is,

Something was seriously wrong here

, a thought? If so, use italics and spacing to signal it.

She collapsed onto the ground and sobbed, her tears landing on an orange flower, when suddenly she looked up to see a large house.

Add a description of the house to make it easier for the reader to conjure up a mental image of the house. Your leaving us hanging.

She got to her feet and started for it.

This would be the best time to add that description.

What if this isn’t where Angel is?

Again if this is a thought, signal it!

“What?” Fluttershy’s face was stuck in a startled expression.

The wording here seems a little awkward, that might just be me, but there are some changes that would make come off a lot better to the reader. Like:

"What?" Fluttershy's voice sounded startled and her face reflected the absolute confusion she felt.

She placed the rabbit on her back and ran towards her cottage. When she arrived, she saw Pinkie Pie waiting outside.

Again with the traveling issue. There is so much you can do! Include a dialogue between Angel and Fluttershy! Like how she usually talks to him. Make the characters seem real.

Those are my only real concerns:twilightsmile:

Again, I love the idea and I think you have talent, but making those changes will add to the story and make it better.

Again, head on over to Editors Dreamland to get help with reviews and editing!

Thanks for the Fic,
SilverTongue123

P.S.

Upvoted:twilightsmile::twilightsmile:

I feel like your description is a little short. I implore you make a more specific and less choppy description. Right now you currently have either very short sentences or sentence fragments. Re-read it to yourself and make editions as necessary! Other then that good idea! I like the idea, though I had to figure it out for myself. :twilightsmile: Not liking, not disliking.

1744802
That wasn't the Everfree Forest but Froggy Bottom Bogg.

1793341
My point being, she could go of without having her friends with her always. Regardless of location.

Ah, a typical in-a-rush story.:twilightsheepish:
Nonetheless, the concept is acceptable, interesting and quite well-executed. Perhaps with some practise, your fiction will improve to a greater level.:pinkiesmile:

Login or register to comment