This story is a sequel to Too Shy for a Rainbow
If you liked this fic, check out the awesome Audio Dub version of it by The Lost Narrator!:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLnqCBZacYIwK0xcHv85Lke-xFf5V9p7R4
It's been a month since Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash started dating. Everything was going fine until Fluttershy started experiencing horrific nightmares that started keeping her up at night. Looking for answers, Rainbow Dash, Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie seek out Twilight. But when the three mares find themselves within the world of Silent Ponyville, will things turn out for the better? Or will things end in tragedy?
Sequel: http://www.fimfiction.net/story/14866/Silent-Ponyville%3A-Reunion
Chapters (14)
Finally it's available on FIMFic! Big hug for you
Finally!
Its gonna be Hilarious.. yet at the same time.. tragic.. and or horrific.. with a pinch of happiness... thumbs up!!!
O_O its on fimfic now SWEET
Hey @ the author, are there any plans for a third one?
This is how you're supposed to do grimdark. One of my favorite fics, you auto-get five stars.
HA! The UFO ending... awesome
...
great, i can say this is my favorite fic of all time, im feeling great to see silent ponyville here in fimfiction
WOOHOO, IT'S ON FIMFICTION!
Oooh, it has been a long time since I have read this one. I must say that I love your fics! Take my 5 stars and keep up the great work!
Could someone please explain how the endings work?
I enjoyed this. Although I must admit I wish the main story had been longer. Anyway, TAKE MY STARS. TAKE THEM.
Yesh Yesh Yesh probably everybody waited for the moment it came on fimfic
wonder if your gonna make a series out of this, its pretty good (just finished reading through the first silent ponyville story), and fits the theme... i feel like i should try and play more of that game series now, well maybe
Right.. Time for the endings ! Great story...
Hmmm Odd... Less depressing than the first ending though !
WHERE IS THE LOVE !?
... Wow, Why dont I just go kill myself !
I hope there is an 'Everything Turns Out Fine' ending. 
THIS IS THE 'EVERYTHING TURNS OUT FINE' ENDING I WAS TALKING ABOUT !
Great, another interesting fic to pour more of my free time into. Curse you, interesting fics! Total love/hate relationship.
I revoke my previous comment... THIS IS THE BEST ENDING !
HOLY APPLEBUCKS!!!
Dear Celestia... I need to read these long fics so I can understand the comments! I'll read it tomorrow in my spare time.
147149
you do that, TROLLESTIA!
When I read Silent Ponyville 2 I was hoping their would be an ending like this
Oh damn, nice way to leave us in this chapter though.
Good story so far yet, i'm wandering what happened to Rainbow Dash and Pinkie...
Saddest and most depressing ending i've read so far...
I also hope there would be a happy ending somewhere...
poor fluttershy
hope for the ufo endiong to be funy
I feel stupid
the monster is her abusive father
sweet celestia
WHAT IS LOVE! BABY DON'T HURT ME, DON'T HURT ME, NO MORE.
*Starts to cry angerly* "WHHHHHHHHYYYYYYYYYY!!!! WHYYYY! WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT FLUTTERSHY! WHYYYYYYYY!
google.se/imgres?q=Win&um=1&hl=sv&biw=1366&bih=667&tbm=isch&tbnid=qf0mremFrdbKAM:&imgrefurl=http://shisymbolinternational.wordpress.com/2009/07/29/promos-giveaways-and-much-more-with-shi-symbol/win/&docid=ffXioCDLxa97MM&imgurl=http://shisymbolinternational.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/win.jpg&w=915&h=686&ei=li4bT568D4iB4gSdzsDMDQ&zoom=1&iact=rc&dur=325&sig=101397893350272697660&page=1&tbnh=145&tbnw=193&start=0&ndsp=18&ved=1t:429,r:6,s:0&tx=33&ty=38
EPIC!
........................................What?....................................
Oh god what now???
Brad is now officially MY FAVORITE PERSON!!!!!!!
THIS IS MY FAVORITE ENDING!!!!!! 
Brad should be paired up with Fluttershy for this, he deserves one date with her since hes so awesome!!!!! 
THANKS FOR BLOWING THAT MOTHERBUCKER UP IT PLEASES FLUTTERSHY!!!!! FANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 
whoo neat
I cried.
And just so you know, I'm the kind of person who never cries. This had me bawling over the computer.
You wonderful, wonderful evil person.
WHY ARE YOU SO GOOD AT WRITING?!
cool
terrible grammar here and there, but i don't give a fuck
No comments!?
Was that a Gundam reference I sensed in this ending? Because that fire fist seemed awfully familiar...
I find it odd that I absolutely cannot get into or play the silent hill games, yet the silent ponyville's got me hook, line and sinker.
And I don't remember the alternate endings being quite this awesome, but they are awesome.
I'm loving the story but how dare you let anything harm Fluttershy!
fluttercry:
I loved Silent Ponyville.
I love Silent Ponyville 2.
You NEED to make a Silent Ponyville 3!
This is an amazing story! I just think poor Fluttershy spends a bit to much time in the otherworld.
Finally on FimFiction!
Now there's no excuse for people not to know this story. Its one beautiful work of art.