10
58
184
Joined May 2012
53
1,002
Even Celestia could give up.
A/N This is my first attempt at a sadfic. I guess a new school and stuff has left me in an emotional state. I have not been able to edit yet, please feel free to point out writing errors. I also want as much criticism as possible if it helps me improve my writing.
Shoutout to NotTheOP for fixing all my grammar mistakes! :D
That was a good start of a sad fic. More stuff could have been an option (Explaining what happened to Twilight etc.) But it's up to you.
First fic is the hard one. The next one you will write will be much better and bigger. So keep on writing and you shall be surprised.
I remember my first sad fic. And I could say that you have a future on the sad part of this place 
And I am currently editing this story. So if you want some grammar fixes, let me know 
You will get used to the sad in time 
Reading later, eh? Prepare yourself, The tale of the Slenderman is getting a 11K-words sequel chapter because it got requested. It's ready and will be published whenever I have the time to stalk the possible readers and commentators for a couple of hours.
Interesting concept, but incomplete. Also, I have a lot of problems with Twilestia ships; Celestia's love would be better placed in the mother/daughter category. And you can be vague about Twilight's maiming, but there still needs to be a context for it. Had Celestia sent her to help establish the trade route (being the superior planner that she is)? If so, perhaps Celestia would feel responsible for her death, and allow herself to become fatalistic as a result.
There also needs to be more dialogue; perhaps Celestia has that philosophical discussion with Luna, but does not openly announce her intentions. The method of her suicide also relies a bit much on the Deus ex Machina trope--I think most of us here believe that although the sisters are practically immortal in that they have a longevity comparable to dragons, they can still be maimed and killed with sufficient force, but it is difficult as the alicorn in question will most likely draw upon her huge magic reserves to defend herself from force.
With your permission, might I take a crack at expanding this idea to give it a bit more depth?
>>1136172 Go ahead! Also, I kinda wanted this to be a short fic revolving around Celestia loosing what she cares for the most before even realising how much she cares for her. I also wanted to keep it very open so that people may write sidestories and sequels. I tend to get a writers block after 2000 words so I wanted to do a very short fic to se how it worked out :)
Also I don't know why but I like the thought of a ritual being the only way of killing the demi goddes. I hope this explains my thought proccess somewhat. I'm kinda exhausted after little sleep and school and stuff so I'm sorry about phrasing my self horribly and explaining in weird ways. Gah I'm even rambling now.
Anyways feel free to expand the idea and bring more depth! :D
If you made a sequel I would read it, this was really good! I got a really complete feeling from this. I should also add that I think the Pinkie Pie conclusion really added a sense of dread. It was like you were confirming what the reader already knew, that this story ended in Twilights death.
Reset Password
Resend Verification Email
1,002 ( 1,624 )
More
Less
Post Comment
Refresh
Now, I can see you have a long journey ahead of you. So do I, so if you don't mind, could you check out my only story, and see what should be done? 
I tend to rush through, so please forgive 
there are not enoughemoticons to express my sadness for my favorite pony
Cancel
Send