• Member Since 31st May, 2012
  • offline last seen Sep 1st, 2023

mageli7


T

Gilda never wanted to be mean, far from it, but what caused her to be evil, rude, bad? Maybe it was a little chaos, or maybe she's just a bad person in general. Nobody knows, well nobody knows besides her.

AN: This is an idea I had for a story awhile ago, and yes, it is a oneshot.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 17 )

Your punctuation needs work.

And also this bothered me. "As in the element of harmony?"
I wasn't aware that Rainbow Dash, the element of loyalty, became the only element of harmony somehow.

Good idea but it is a bit of a cop out.

always just thought she was short tempered and proud and the ponies were waay to fast wanting her gone

What a wonderfully twisted story! :pinkiecrazy:

I liked the pacing. You went over every point that was needed, and kept the story short enough that it didn't overstay it's welcome.

Also, dat ending. :pinkiesad2:

963282

There's more then one element of harmony, he just overheard Celestia talking about them... I wasn't going to say as in the element of loyalty

963473
Perhaps the words "one of the elements of harmony" would do better?

963313

She had tried to kill herself before, that didn't work, the day he had gone quiet was her chance, she didn't know he was gone. I thought it was a good ending, but that's just my opinion.

great story. it puts a whole new perspective on gilda

963531

Thank you! I really did love her character in the show, one of my favorites actually, no idea why...

963537
yeah, she is my favorite antagonist, and this story only makes me like her even more.

963560

I always felt bad for her, losing Dash as a friend.

It's one of the saddest fics I've ever read... Of course, there was "My Little Dashie", but it ended in a cheerful way. This is a disaster. I don't know why I feel bad about gilda now... You, kind sir, are surely one hell-of-a writer. 'Nuff said.

963789

Sorry to do this, but it's kind lady... :rainbowlaugh: Thank you though, I really do make sad fics at times, this one I didn't end happily, well I suppose it could be happy depending on how you look at it. And also, is it a good disaster or a bad one?

963876 Oh dear :D Good and bad disasters, huh? Well, bad disaster, as in the death of Gilda. Good disaster as in the crushing power of immersion. Anyways, disaster is a disaster. 'Nuff said

I have been mildly disturbed. But that's what writing is about, to jerk your readers' emotions around, so for that, you get a thumbs up. :pinkiehappy:

966506

Yep, I always felt like Gilda had a reason for being mean, here was her reason...

966529
and this is definitely a reason for being mean. except for the ending, i could see this as being a future episode if gilda was to return. with discord defeated, she returned to her senses and tries to get everyone to forgive her, but no one believes her.

Login or register to comment